Forums (I/O Tower)
Forums 
 TRON: LEGACY 
 Would Clu's plan have worked?


New New Comments | Post No Change | Locked Closed
AuthorComments: FirstPrevious Page: of 9 PagesNextLast
laphtiya
User

Posts: 948
RE: Would Clu's plan have worked?

on Wednesday, August, 10, 2011 3:22 AM
ashrond Wrote:I'm guessing that no one here has ever seen an episode of star trek? (Transporter/Replicator)
*matter energy conversion
Those cans on the laser are not for storage, there for the chemical cooling of the laser most likely. Or perhaps it’s a chemical laser?

But hey, flame away, because I’m sure that at no point in the original movie do they say that their storing matter, as opposed to digitizing it.

Alan Bradley statement that Flynn had claimed to have discovered the key to quantum teleportation, lends credence to this.

Hey I've seen star trek but I think this is different, and the molecules are said to be suspended in the laser beam in the original and seeing as the beam has not been active in over 20 years they need to go somewhere. I think what people need to realise as well when it comes to molecules is that there is no such thing as a solid object when you get down to it. There are MASSIVE gaps between molecules even between the subatomic particles so they can be condesned. But I think the issue has moved on slightly.where to buy abortion pill ordering abortion pills to be shipped to house buy abortion pill online


 
Vaporware
User

Posts: 217
RE: Would Clu's plan have worked?

on Wednesday, August, 10, 2011 6:42 PM
Well, like I said in the original post. I'm referring to the "Art of Tron" book, not the movie. I watched the original tron a couple days ago, there are no canisters on the original Shiva laser, but the one in Kevin's lab is *much* smaller and the photos clearly show canisters.

--------------
Page 45 of The Art of Tron says:
"...updated version of the Shiva laser, a more compact version of the device that transported Kevin into the digital world of Tron (1982)."

"The filmmakers went to great lengths to make the laser look both real and functional. For example, around the base of the laser are four cylindrical silos designed to hold the chemical elements that theoretically would remain if a human were broken down and transferred into digital space - carbon, as well as hydrogen and oxygen (water). This idea came out of a meeting with several notable physicists who were brought in to consult on the scientific realities of Tron."

-------------

So back to my original point. Why bother with the "scientific realities" if you just want to wave a magic wand and say "Kevin Flynn's lines are the absolute laws of the world."
on line abortion pill misoprostol dose abortion medical abortion pill online


 
ashrond
User

Posts: 7
RE: Would Clu's plan have worked?

on Wednesday, August, 10, 2011 10:56 PM
laphtiya Wrote:
ashrond Wrote:I'm guessing that no one here has ever seen an episode of star trek? (Transporter/Replicator)
*matter energy conversion
Those cans on the laser are not for storage, there for the chemical cooling of the laser most likely. Or perhaps it’s a chemical laser?

But hey, flame away, because I’m sure that at no point in the original movie do they say that their storing matter, as opposed to digitizing it.

Alan Bradley statement that Flynn had claimed to have discovered the key to quantum teleportation, lends credence to this.

Hey I've seen star trek but I think this is different, and the molecules are said to be suspended in the laser beam in the original and seeing as the beam has not been active in over 20 years they need to go somewhere. I think what people need to realise as well when it comes to molecules is that there is no such thing as a solid object when you get down to it. There are MASSIVE gaps between molecules even between the subatomic particles so they can be condesned. But I think the issue has moved on slightly.

This is true, however I think that when reviewing older movies, especially from a time when people were not as familiar with computers as they are today; it’s not so much nitpicking as it is not taking EVERYTHING as gospel. A prime example of this is Kevin Flynn referring to computer files as being off "in one of these memories" certain ideas may have been conveyed in terms or a manner that the producers and writers felt would be easiest for the audience to understand.

If you take this approach then you can easily say that molecules remaining suspended in laser beam is just a way of dubbing down the idea of a person being suspended in computer memory, in a way that still sounds high-tech and cool. Remember lasers were still relatively new back then and you couldn’t get on a keychain.

anyway, getting down to my point, if you take the onscreen evidence like I do; that the digitization process is matter to energy conversion, then YES Clu's plan would have worked, becase all the equipment in the realworld would have needed was energy equivilant to the matter its producinng.

however if you don’t like the way I look at things, you could also argue that the laser would simply have to start deconstructing its surrounding environment for raw materials.... but I think this is far less likely to be the case.

Besides with mater/energy conversion, you don’t run into problems that face long term materials storage, this also allows for things to change while inside the grid, like your brain creating new memories from experience or like Flynn putting on a few pounds

btw, was just re-watching the tron, guess what i saw on the laser, canisters, look like chemical containers.
http://imgur.com/iUhe7
http://imgur.com/It2hB


 
RenegadeProgram
User

Posts: 593
RE: Would Clu's plan have worked?

on Thursday, August, 11, 2011 1:23 PM
ashrond Wrote:
laphtiya Wrote:
ashrond Wrote:. . .however if you don’t like the way I look at things, you could also argue that the laser would simply have to start deconstructing its surrounding environment for raw materials.... but I think this is far less likely to be the case.

Besides with mater/energy conversion, you don’t run into problems that face long term materials storage, this also allows for things to change while inside the grid, like your brain creating new memories from experience or like Flynn putting on a few pounds

btw, was just re-watching the tron, guess what i saw on the laser, canisters, look like chemical containers.
http://imgur.com/iUhe7
http://imgur.com/It2hB

Here's where I have to partially disagree, ashrond (since you later stated that the following is less likely to be the case):

The laser would not have, "deconstructed its surrounding environment for raw materials". Why? Because lasers are FOCUSED on a target in a single, straight path. Even more so, because the devices through which lasers emanate, have mirrors in the path of the laser, helping to focus the path to a single point, or target, if you will.


Fighting for TRON, The USERS, Both Flynns, Independents, and the mighty ISOs since '82.
 
laphtiya
User

Posts: 948
RE: Would Clu's plan have worked?

on Friday, August, 12, 2011 3:23 AM
RenegadeProgram Wrote:
ashrond Wrote:
laphtiya Wrote:
ashrond Wrote:. . .however if you don’t like the way I look at things, you could also argue that the laser would simply have to start deconstructing its surrounding environment for raw materials.... but I think this is far less likely to be the case.

Besides with mater/energy conversion, you don’t run into problems that face long term materials storage, this also allows for things to change while inside the grid, like your brain creating new memories from experience or like Flynn putting on a few pounds

btw, was just re-watching the tron, guess what i saw on the laser, canisters, look like chemical containers.
http://imgur.com/iUhe7
http://imgur.com/It2hB

Here's where I have to partially disagree, ashrond (since you later stated that the following is less likely to be the case):

The laser would not have, "deconstructed its surrounding environment for raw materials". Why? Because lasers are FOCUSED on a target in a single, straight path. Even more so, because the devices through which lasers emanate, have mirrors in the path of the laser, helping to focus the path to a single point, or target, if you will.

Should have a look at when Flynn gets digitized in the first movie, while yes a laser is a straight beam it was able to split it to cover more ground.



 
Vaporware
User

Posts: 217
RE: Would Clu's plan have worked?

on Friday, August, 12, 2011 5:34 PM
Yeah, the beam skips around taking Flynn apart. Reminds me of the explanation of how a TV Tube is "painted" from behind. I get the sense that there's some sort of refraction crystal or similar in end of it.

One issue with laser taking the room apart for th raw materials (one would guess that Kevin had a safety to prevent that) is that the servers and various other electronics are sitting right in front of the laser. I would take more a couple "extra" items being materialized from the Grid using "found matter" before the laser disintegrated the two "Super Servers" holding the entire grid as well as the all the bad guys and good guys that were still inside waiting for sufficient matter to become available.

It also wouldn't take long for the shiva to hit something really important - like some structural portion of the building, before things would have begun collapsing on top of the entire room.

My mind is forming an alternate ending.
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Clu escapes Kevin Flynn and follows Sam and Quorra out of the Grid. They run off to get help.

This leaves Clu standing in the dusty lab as the Shiva begins to move his army over to the real world.

Very shortly, Clu and a half dozen sentries are standing in the room having escaped from the grid. They are dismayed and distracted by dust, cobwebs, and the arcane computer hardware laying about.

All the spare matter has been used up and the Shiva now "harvests" one of the building's main columns so that it can materialize more soldiers. Clu and his soldiers are too distracted by the workshop of the creator to realize the problem.

There's a low rumble and the entire top floor drops smashing the servers and crushing the sentries, the Shiva laser, and trapping Clu up to his neck in rubble.

We then see the inside of the arcade game floor. Games are toppling backwards into the hole where Flynn secret lab was hidden. Space Paranoids, Asteroids, Centipede...

Journey's "Separate Ways" is still blasting.

Clu is trapped. He screams in agony from his massive internal wounds, but it is entirely drowned out by hard-rocking 80s music.

We then see the "TRON" video game topple over backwards and comes sliding with hundreds of pounds of mass right at Clu's face.

Close up shot of Clu's bloody face as he draws a tortured breathe to scream "no"

Fade to black.

Loud "Crunch" (like when you drop a brick on a bag of potato chips)

Credits roll

Daft Punk plays.
--------------------------------------------------------------------

So there we go. I guess Clu's plan could work.


 
Kat
User

Posts: 2,394
RE: Would Clu's plan have worked?

on Saturday, August, 13, 2011 12:37 PM
ShadowDragon1 Wrote:the Death Star wasn't made by a smalll energy-to matter device with limited capacity matter storage.

Flynn and Sam's bodily matter doesn't equal massive construct army and vehicles in the real-world, and nothing indicates the laser could or was even set-up to even be able to siphon off enough energy and local matter to materialize the whole damn army in the real world.

Until some novelization, canon material is published, the writers, or Joe explain verbatim how it could be done. I'm going to think it could NOT be done.
Not to mention, Star Wars is supposed to have taken place "a long time ago, in a galaxy far, far away." Star Wars is essentially an alternate universe. It doesn't take much suspension of disbelief to think they could've had all sorts of technology superior to ours and such (I find it harder to believe they had human beings!).

Tron, however, takes place in our own universe. We're asked to believe that Flynn's such a frigging genius that he not only personally invented technologies like wifi long before anyone else did, but he also figured out quantum teleportation.

Now, not long ago I was listening to a show on astronomy.fm and in part of it, they were talking about quantum teleportation. In this case they were talking about it re: Star Trek, but I think we could apply some of it as well. Unfortunately I was at work doing other stuff while I was listening, so I kept drifting in and out and didn't catch most of what they were saying, , but one thing I heard--and keep in mind I only caught half of this actual sentence so I've only got it boiled down to its essence and there was more to it than this-- was that we might develop the technology for quantum teleportation in 100 years IF we are making a very optimistic estimate.

That's apparently reality. The Tron universe is asking us to believe that Flynn came up with this technology and made it work almost 30 years ago, back in the day when the rest of the world barely had PCs. I mean, you guys. Commodore64 vs. quantum teleportation, dude! Belief is already expected to be stretched pretty far.


order abortion pill abortion pill buy online where to buy abortion pill

What do you want? I'm busy.


Program, please!


Chaos.... good news.
 
Zenith
User

Posts: 44
RE: Would Clu's plan have worked?

on Saturday, August, 13, 2011 7:01 PM
Quotes not working, sorry

>>>>>

I can only assume, that he wanted to assume Flynn completely in and out of the grid. He couldn't risk Flynn setting something up while he was outside of the Grid, nor could he risk Flynn escaping. Plus the master key obviously allowed Clu to take everything with him not to mention all the secrets of the Grid. Clu cannot create perhaps this is a limitation removed with the master key, also I don't think Clu was planning on taking everyone with him until he had Flynn's disc. But yes it raises more questions about this, as in has this happened??? I mean why else would Flynn have thought it possible unless it was seen?.....hmmmmm

>>>>>


Just a thought here that Clu's reason for being was perfection of the system. Clu was part of that system himself, right at the apex. However, Clu had limitations precisely because he was Clu. Seeking perfection of the system also involved seeking perfection for himself.

Perhaps now that Clu saw Flynn as "corrupted" he sought to become perfect, usurping Flynn's role as creator. Becoming perfect - essentially becoming Flynn before he got "corrupted" in Clu's eyes - involved gaining the "secret knowledge" of Flynn's disk.

Edit: Perhaps that's why Clu went off the rails, it was impossible for him to be perfect unless he had Flynn's disk. He was programmed to go mad right from the start

>> 10 rem *CONFORM*
>> 20 goto 10

>> "...and I'm outta the loop"
 
Pilgrim1099
User

Posts: 606
RE: Would Clu's plan have worked?

on Saturday, August, 13, 2011 7:12 PM
Vaporware Wrote:That's an interesting point. Castor *did* say that.

So if any "stray" program could have slipped out, then why would Clu have needed the Master Key?

Army or not, why couldn't he have just waltzed right out when Sam came in and the portal was opened - 'except perhaps because Sam came in the "backdoor"?

That idea just raises *more* questions...




Exactly.


 
trekking95
User

Posts: 2,440
RE: Would Clu's plan have worked?

on Saturday, August, 13, 2011 7:42 PM
Kat Wrote:That's apparently reality. The Tron universe is asking us to believe that Flynn came up with this technology and made it work almost 30 years ago, back in the day when the rest of the world barely had PCs. I mean, you guys. Commodore64 vs. quantum teleportation, dude! Belief is already expected to be stretched pretty far.
Exactly! Most of the things in Tron are not possible and probably never will be.order abortion pill abortion pill buy online where to buy abortion pillabortion pills online abortion pill online purchase cytotec abortion

Thanks to FlynnOne for the signature!

Save Tron 3!
 
Vaporware
User

Posts: 217
RE: Would Clu's plan have worked?

on Saturday, August, 13, 2011 8:39 PM
Exactly! Most of the things in Tron are not possible and probably never will be.

Dunno.. Wireless Interlinking seems to work pretty well


I've said several times that I'll suspend my disbelief, I am more than willing to watch and enjoy a film in a world created by the director. In this case, the director set up some links to physical laws and realities and I'd like to know how he, as the director of the story, was going to reconcile the plot to the small details that he went to some lengths to include.

A foolish film is when the director can't stay within the ruled he/she created for the universe.

I'm not sure he was violating his own rules, I'd really just like to know how Clu's plan is being reconciled with the other details.




 
laphtiya
User

Posts: 948
RE: Would Clu's plan have worked?

on Monday, August, 15, 2011 2:17 AM
Flynn didn't event Wifi he said he just thought about that in 85 but yeah I know what you mean but you need to think about what is available in market and what is actually out there. For instance computers today work on either 32 or 64 bit, however the majority of mainframe computers and vast data crunchers work on 128 or 256bit computing, and I am sure that we also have 512bit super computers knocking about somewhere. But I know what you're saying lol.

@Vapoware: I have a feeling that the whole program into real world will be expanded on in the thrid installment, unless he Director and writers go for the same approach marvel took with Iron Man's Armour "It just works" not explaining any of the technology involved in it.abortion pills online abortion pill online purchase cytotec abortion


 
trekking95
User

Posts: 2,440
RE: Would Clu's plan have worked?

on Monday, August, 15, 2011 2:59 AM
laphtiya Wrote: unless he Director and writers go for the same approach marvel took with Iron Man's Armour "It just works" not explaining any of the technology involved in it.
That's funny, I was just watching Iron Man tonight and thought the same thing. They don't say anything about how the tech works. But it is still a good movie.

Thanks to FlynnOne for the signature!

Save Tron 3!
 
Vaporware
User

Posts: 217
RE: Would Clu's plan have worked?

on Monday, August, 15, 2011 7:32 PM
trekking95 Wrote:
laphtiya Wrote: unless he Director and writers go for the same approach marvel took with Iron Man's Armour "It just works" not explaining any of the technology involved in it.
That's funny, I was just watching Iron Man tonight and thought the same thing. They don't say anything about how the tech works. But it is still a good movie.

That's valid for a lot of stories. In the original Star Wars they don't bother explaining anything about light-speed, light sabers, blasters, force fields, or levitating dune cars. It all works and it is amazing. No explanation asked for, none needed. It was way after the original movies got dusty before people started picking it apart.

Sci-Fi experts - at least the type they interview for such things have said that Star Wars was revolutionary in that they didn't worry about explaining anything.

For all the lack of explanation, Lucas kept to the rules established in the original film. That's why we all loved it - consistent story elements, acceptable technology, things that had bounds and limits - even when we didn't know what those limits were. It was another time and another place. Rules were different.

Maybe the problem is when the attempt is made to link the story back to a reality that we recognize problems and we often start to point out inconsistencies in the director's vision. I'm not sure that there are inconsistencies, I'm just wondering how these things work.






 
TRON.dll
User

Posts: 4,349
RE: Would Clu's plan have worked?

on Monday, August, 15, 2011 11:14 PM
Vaporware Wrote:
trekking95 Wrote:
laphtiya Wrote: unless he Director and writers go for the same approach marvel took with Iron Man's Armour "It just works" not explaining any of the technology involved in it.
That's funny, I was just watching Iron Man tonight and thought the same thing. They don't say anything about how the tech works. But it is still a good movie.

That's valid for a lot of stories. In the original Star Wars they don't bother explaining anything about light-speed, light sabers, blasters, force fields, or levitating dune cars. It all works and it is amazing. No explanation asked for, none needed. It was way after the original movies got dusty before people started picking it apart.

Sci-Fi experts - at least the type they interview for such things have said that Star Wars was revolutionary in that they didn't worry about explaining anything.

For all the lack of explanation, Lucas kept to the rules established in the original film. That's why we all loved it - consistent story elements, acceptable technology, things that had bounds and limits - even when we didn't know what those limits were. It was another time and another place. Rules were different.

Maybe the problem is when the attempt is made to link the story back to a reality that we recognize problems and we often start to point out inconsistencies in the director's vision. I'm not sure that there are inconsistencies, I'm just wondering how these things work.




I think what's nice about the original Star Wars trilogy is that most of those things (lightsabers, hovercars, etc.) is that the way they work isn't explained, but an official explanation is out there, not taking up space in the movie, if needed. This way, the fan's experience is enhanced, while the casual viewer's experience isn't interrupted by explanations everywhere that they don't care about.


TRON 2.0 (PC) name - TRON.dll
I'll play any mode, but I'm best at LC.



PSN - TRON-dll
XBOX Live/Games for Windows Live - TRONdll
-I have a Wii, DS, and 3DS. PM me to exchange friend codes.
 
trekking95
User

Posts: 2,440
RE: Would Clu's plan have worked?

on Monday, August, 15, 2011 11:28 PM
TRON.dll Wrote:
Vaporware Wrote:
trekking95 Wrote:
laphtiya Wrote: unless he Director and writers go for the same approach marvel took with Iron Man's Armour "It just works" not explaining any of the technology involved in it.
That's funny, I was just watching Iron Man tonight and thought the same thing. They don't say anything about how the tech works. But it is still a good movie.

That's valid for a lot of stories. In the original Star Wars they don't bother explaining anything about light-speed, light sabers, blasters, force fields, or levitating dune cars. It all works and it is amazing. No explanation asked for, none needed. It was way after the original movies got dusty before people started picking it apart.

Sci-Fi experts - at least the type they interview for such things have said that Star Wars was revolutionary in that they didn't worry about explaining anything.

For all the lack of explanation, Lucas kept to the rules established in the original film. That's why we all loved it - consistent story elements, acceptable technology, things that had bounds and limits - even when we didn't know what those limits were. It was another time and another place. Rules were different.

Maybe the problem is when the attempt is made to link the story back to a reality that we recognize problems and we often start to point out inconsistencies in the director's vision. I'm not sure that there are inconsistencies, I'm just wondering how these things work.




I think what's nice about the original Star Wars trilogy is that most of those things (lightsabers, hovercars, etc.) is that the way they work isn't explained, but an official explanation is out there, not taking up space in the movie, if needed. This way, the fan's experience is enhanced, while the casual viewer's experience isn't interrupted by explanations everywhere that they don't care about.
Never thought of it that way. Good thought you had there. on line abortion pill misoprostol dose abortion medical abortion pill online

Thanks to FlynnOne for the signature!

Save Tron 3!
 
laphtiya
User

Posts: 948
RE: Would Clu's plan have worked?

on Tuesday, August, 16, 2011 3:29 AM
"For all the lack of explanation, Lucas kept to the rules established in the original film."

Ahhhh this isn't entirely correct, Lucas has stepped on his own toes more times than I care to mention the biggest that comes to mind would be Obi wan saying to Yoda was he any different when he was taught by Yoda then we go straight episode one to find out oh wait he WASN'T trained by Yoda at all.

I think however this is due to the nature of how Big that series has become and with other writers from all over having stuff added as Canon by Lucas things are bound to get messy. But yeah I have a strong feeling that we are going to get the "It just works" treatment with Tron.


 
trekking95
User

Posts: 2,440
RE: Would Clu's plan have worked?

on Tuesday, August, 16, 2011 3:38 AM
laphtiya Wrote:"For all the lack of explanation, Lucas kept to the rules established in the original film."

Ahhhh this isn't entirely correct, Lucas has stepped on his own toes more times than I care to mention the biggest that comes to mind would be Obi wan saying to Yoda was he any different when he was taught by Yoda then we go straight episode one to find out oh wait he WASN'T trained by Yoda at all.

I think however this is due to the nature of how Big that series has become and with other writers from all over having stuff added as Canon by Lucas things are bound to get messy. But yeah I have a strong feeling that we are going to get the "It just works" treatment with Tron.
Or Obi Wan saying to Luke that his father wanted him to have his light saber. Then in episode 3 Obi Wan took it from Anakin.

Thanks to FlynnOne for the signature!

Save Tron 3!
 
laphtiya
User

Posts: 948
RE: Would Clu's plan have worked?

on Tuesday, August, 16, 2011 5:24 AM
trekking95 Wrote:
laphtiya Wrote:"For all the lack of explanation, Lucas kept to the rules established in the original film."

Ahhhh this isn't entirely correct, Lucas has stepped on his own toes more times than I care to mention the biggest that comes to mind would be Obi wan saying to Yoda was he any different when he was taught by Yoda then we go straight episode one to find out oh wait he WASN'T trained by Yoda at all.

I think however this is due to the nature of how Big that series has become and with other writers from all over having stuff added as Canon by Lucas things are bound to get messy. But yeah I have a strong feeling that we are going to get the "It just works" treatment with Tron.
Or Obi Wan saying to Luke that his father wanted him to have his light saber. Then in episode 3 Obi Wan took it from Anakin.

Ah now be careful with that one because yes Anakin would have wanted his son to have it, but when Obi Wan took it he wasn't taking it from Anakin (from his Pov) he was taking it from Darth Vader.order abortion pill http://unclejohnsprojects.com/template/default.aspx?morning-after-pill-price where to buy abortion pill


 
cirlin
User

Posts: 382
RE: Would Clu's plan have worked?

on Tuesday, August, 16, 2011 10:39 AM
laphtiya Wrote:"For all the lack of explanation, Lucas kept to the rules established in the original film."

Ahhhh this isn't entirely correct, Lucas has stepped on his own toes more times than I care to mention the biggest that comes to mind would be Obi wan saying to Yoda was he any different when he was taught by Yoda then we go straight episode one to find out oh wait he WASN'T trained by Yoda at all.

Obi-Wan was trained by Yoda. Yoda did a lot of training of the younger students, before they went to learn under a single master. We see some of this in Ep II. So while we didn't see that period of training, there is no reason to assume it didn't happen.

The only problem I can see with that dialogue and how it relates to the prequels, is that Obi-wan says "...the Jedi master who instructed me." where "...a Jedi who instructed me." might fit in a little better, but that's a very minor quibble if you ask me.
where to buy abortion pill ordering abortion pills to be shipped to house buy abortion pill online


 
FirstPrevious Page: of 9 PagesNextLast
New New Comments | Post No Change | Locked Closed
Forums 
 TRON: LEGACY 
 Would Clu's plan have worked?