Forums (I/O Tower)
Forums 
 TRON: LEGACY 
 What was Castor thinking?


New New Comments | Post No Change | Locked Closed
AuthorComments: FirstPrevious Page: of 5 PagesNextLast
Tron Fanatic
User

Posts: 1,461
RE: What was Castor thinking?

on Sunday, May, 08, 2011 3:31 AM
rimwall Wrote:remember how clu can feed on flynn's resistance and
become more powerful.

I don't think that was literal. Take it more like for instance, the War on Terror, drugs, or whatever... the more we fight them, the more powerful they get.... usually anyhow.

It's kind of like "for every action, there's an equal and opposite reaction."

Flynn probably figured that with nothing to fight against, CLU's zeal might die down, or the regime might collapse internally, or something.
order abortion pill http://unclejohnsprojects.com/template/default.aspx?morning-after-pill-price where to buy abortion pill

'>
 
IluthraDanar
User

Posts: 1,178
RE: What was Castor thinking?

on Sunday, May, 08, 2011 3:35 AM
Tron Fanatic Wrote:
rimwall Wrote:remember how clu can feed on flynn's resistance and
become more powerful.

I don't think that was literal. Take it more like for instance, the War on Terror, drugs, or whatever... the more we fight them, the more powerful they get.... usually anyhow.

It's kind of like "for every action, there's an equal and opposite reaction."

Flynn probably figured that with nothing to fight against, CLU's zeal might die down, or the regime might collapse internally, or something.

Man, I need to get to bed but I kep coming back here.

I took it literally when I saw the film the first time, but later thought that, as he resisted, yes, Clu would come up with ways to combat the resistance, becoming stronger. As Flynn became less involved in any resistance, Clu would lay off and just go back to controlling the city. Balance was the best Flynn could hope for.


Forget it, Mr High and Mighty Master Control. You aren't making me talk.


 
IluthraDanar
User

Posts: 1,178
RE: What was Castor thinking?

on Sunday, May, 08, 2011 3:35 AM
Tron Fanatic Wrote:
rimwall Wrote:remember how clu can feed on flynn's resistance and
become more powerful.

I don't think that was literal. Take it more like for instance, the War on Terror, drugs, or whatever... the more we fight them, the more powerful they get.... usually anyhow.

It's kind of like "for every action, there's an equal and opposite reaction."

Flynn probably figured that with nothing to fight against, CLU's zeal might die down, or the regime might collapse internally, or something.

Man, I need to get to bed but I keep coming back here.

I took it literally when I saw the film the first time, but later thought that, as he resisted, yes, Clu would come up with ways to combat the resistance, becoming stronger. As Flynn became less involved in any resistance, Clu would lay off and just go back to controlling the city. Balance was the best Flynn could hope for.


Forget it, Mr High and Mighty Master Control. You aren't making me talk.


 
rimwall
User

Posts: 507
RE: What was Castor thinking?

on Sunday, May, 08, 2011 5:53 AM
you guys are probably right

i just cant shake the feeling that
there is some sort of connection.

the mcp's words that programs "need" communication
with users.

plus flynn's thoughts and pure willpower
can prevent yori from derezzing

flynn while semi-concious - can
initiate power transfer to a recognizer. *semi-concious*

flynn's thoughts can also re-assemble
a recognizer

it's like mental processes can manifest
as energy.
edit it's like mental processes can hasten/aid
energy transfer

i mean are these just examples of different
user powers? because user thoughts seem
to be a common denominator in these examples.


in this picture flynn is *semi-concious* and the
recognizer gained power.

the *semi-concious* part is of great interest
because power is transferred to the recognizer
without the user intent to transfer.
power transferred on its own accord.

even simple prolonged physical contact with a user seems
to imbibe initial power-up to the recognizer


I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.

 
rimwall
User

Posts: 507
RE: What was Castor thinking?

on Sunday, May, 08, 2011 6:11 AM
could this be clu's secret?
a program has to want and intend to take
power from a user?

power seems to flow from the user whether
the user wants to or not.

physical contact even seems to make the
power transfer even more efficient.

is that what programs get from the simple act of
communicating with users?


I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.

 
rimwall
User

Posts: 507
RE: What was Castor thinking?

on Sunday, May, 08, 2011 6:58 AM
here's some interesting insight from the draft
of tron script about ram's death.

remember this is the draft. but the best part
is the one about the flow of energy from ram
to flynn.

most interesting.

from http://www.imsdb.com/scripts/TRON.html


283 INT. RECOGNIZER 283


Through the head of the Reco, we can look out at the landscape below.


Flynn sits stunned for a moment, then stumbles over to Ram, who's
going fast.


FLYNN
You okay? You don't look so good.


Ram nods weakly.


FLYNN (CONT.)
Hang on. We'll get you outta here.


Flynn touches panels, trying to get the Recognizer going, but with
no result.


FLYNN (CONT.)
Damn! Never fails... minute the
warranty runs out...


RAM
Come here.


Flynn goes over to him and kneels. Ram grabs his hands. Suddenly
Ram's fading glow begins to flow through their clasped hands into
Flynn. Horrified, Flynn tries to pull away, but Ram holds him fast.


FLYNN
Hey... !


RAM
Little more juice's all it needs...


Ram's last bit of energy flows into Flynn and Ram's body de-rezzes.
Flynn watches in horror, frantically trying to reverse the flow,
but it's too late. Ram disappears before his eyes. Stunned, he
gazes at the empty space for a moment, then stands up.

we can see the directors/screenwriters intentions
here. ram knows that he can give his energy to
flynn and flynn would not be able to stop the
final release of energy from ram.

i realize its not exactly what happened in tron1
but read the part about the energy flow and how
flynn has little control over it.

in the tron1 draft flynn cant control energy flow from ram to him
if ram intends to give his last energy then flynn cant stop it.

in tron1 movie flynn cant control initial energy flow from
him to recognizer.

we can conclude that flynn has little mastery over whether
energy flows into him or out of him.


i swear this draft script is like looking into the
director's mind

abortion pills online abortion pill online purchase cytotec abortion

I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.

 
IluthraDanar
User

Posts: 1,178
RE: What was Castor thinking?

on Sunday, May, 08, 2011 3:00 PM
This was interesting! Initially, Ram sacrifices himself to help Flynn. In the final film, Ram derezzes because he is damaged, and perhaps Flynn is not yet familiar with his potential power, or couldn't have saved Ram anyway, that program's damages being too extensive. But it changes the whole tone of the scene. A program with the ability to be self-sacrificing? Of course, maybe Ram knew he was dying so gave Flynn what he had left.


Forget it, Mr High and Mighty Master Control. You aren't making me talk.


 
Kat
User

Posts: 2,394
RE: What was Castor thinking?

on Sunday, May, 08, 2011 5:27 PM
rimwall Wrote:we can see the directors/screenwriters intentions
here. ram knows that he can give his energy to
flynn and flynn would not be able to stop the
final release of energy from ram.

i realize its not exactly what happened in tron1
but read the part about the energy flow and how
flynn has little control over it.

in the tron1 draft flynn cant control energy flow from ram to him
if ram intends to give his last energy then flynn cant stop it.

in tron1 movie flynn cant control initial energy flow from
him to recognizer.

we can conclude that flynn has little mastery over whether
energy flows into him or out of him.


i swear this draft script is like looking into the
director's mind

Interesting. It would've been my assumption that users could transfer energy but programs cannot...where to buy abortion pill http://blog.bitimpulse.com/template/default.aspx?abortion-types buy abortion pill onlineabortion pills online abortion pill online purchase cytotec abortion

What do you want? I'm busy.


Program, please!


Chaos.... good news.
 
IluthraDanar
User

Posts: 1,178
RE: What was Castor thinking?

on Sunday, May, 08, 2011 7:49 PM
Perhaps another reason the scene was changed?


Forget it, Mr High and Mighty Master Control. You aren't making me talk.


 
LWSrocks2
User

Posts: 415
RE: What was Castor thinking?

on Sunday, May, 08, 2011 7:58 PM
Y'Know I think Rimwall is seriously onto something. I'd never considered it before... that users wouldn't have alot of control over their user powers and abilities. Do you think this will be the case with Sam in the next film?


 
rimwall
User

Posts: 507
RE: What was Castor thinking?

on Sunday, May, 08, 2011 8:47 PM
we've seen other examples of energy tranfer
initiated by programs. like tron transferring
power to yori during the scene where she did
not recognize him because of her low power.

let's see if we could verbalize this properly:

the initial unintentional power transfer between
flynn and the recognizer tells me that flynn's
own programs automatically take power from flynn
(flynn created the recognizer in space paranoids iirc)

if an inanimate non-thinking object can take power from flynn
then imagine what a thinking program like clu
can do.

(i'd like to think of flynn as a leaky battery that is
always recharging and a conductor at the same time)

energy tranfer between flynn and inanimate objects
is obviously simple because the mental component of
the tranfer involves only flynn's thoughts.

the complicated part is energy transfer between
flynn and one of his thinking programs(clu).
it's complicated because i don't have much
evidence (of the inner workings) when it comes to two opposing thoughts.


I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.

 
rimwall
User

Posts: 507
RE: What was Castor thinking?

on Sunday, May, 08, 2011 11:27 PM
IluthraDanar Wrote:This was interesting! Initially, Ram sacrifices himself to help Flynn. In the final film, Ram derezzes because he is damaged, and perhaps Flynn is not yet familiar with his potential power, or couldn't have saved Ram anyway, that program's damages being too extensive. But it changes the whole tone of the scene. A program with the ability to be self-sacrificing? Of course, maybe Ram knew he was dying so gave Flynn what he had left.

we could note that (in terms of visual cues about derezzing)
ram's derezzing was different from other derezzing


it really does look like ram's energy transferred into the recognizer.

i guess they dont want flynn to look like an energy vampire
that can suck friends and enemies alike.


order abortion pill http://unclejohnsprojects.com/template/default.aspx?morning-after-pill-price where to buy abortion pill

I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.

 
IluthraDanar
User

Posts: 1,178
RE: What was Castor thinking?

on Sunday, May, 08, 2011 11:44 PM
rimwall Wrote:
IluthraDanar Wrote:This was interesting! Initially, Ram sacrifices himself to help Flynn. In the final film, Ram derezzes because he is damaged, and perhaps Flynn is not yet familiar with his potential power, or couldn't have saved Ram anyway, that program's damages being too extensive. But it changes the whole tone of the scene. A program with the ability to be self-sacrificing? Of course, maybe Ram knew he was dying so gave Flynn what he had left.

we could note that (in terms of visual cues about derezzing)
ram's derezzing was different from other derezzing


it really does look like ram's energy transferred into the recognizer.

i guess they dont want flynn to look like an energy vampire
that can suck friends and enemies alike.



In all the times I've viewed this film, I noticed the difference in derezz but didn't apply it to any reason. So they changed it marginally, by having Ram directly infuse the vessel with what power had left rather than him give it to Flynn himself. It wasn't explained in this way. Maybe Ram unconsciously did it, so it wasn't a sacrifice. Who will know for sure, what was in the minds of the writers. where to buy abortion pill ordering abortion pills to be shipped to house buy abortion pill online


Forget it, Mr High and Mighty Master Control. You aren't making me talk.


 
rimwall
User

Posts: 507
RE: What was Castor thinking?

on Monday, May, 09, 2011 12:13 AM
IluthraDanar Wrote:
rimwall Wrote:
IluthraDanar Wrote:This was interesting! Initially, Ram sacrifices himself to help Flynn. In the final film, Ram derezzes because he is damaged, and perhaps Flynn is not yet familiar with his potential power, or couldn't have saved Ram anyway, that program's damages being too extensive. But it changes the whole tone of the scene. A program with the ability to be self-sacrificing? Of course, maybe Ram knew he was dying so gave Flynn what he had left.

we could note that (in terms of visual cues about derezzing)
ram's derezzing was different from other derezzing


it really does look like ram's energy transferred into the recognizer.

i guess they dont want flynn to look like an energy vampire
that can suck friends and enemies alike.



In all the times I've viewed this film, I noticed the difference in derezz but didn't apply it to any reason. So they changed it marginally, by having Ram directly infuse the vessel with what power had left rather than him give it to Flynn himself. It wasn't explained in this way. Maybe Ram unconsciously did it, so it wasn't a sacrifice. Who will know for sure, what was in the minds of the writers.

to be honest my first viewing of this i thought:

so that's what slow derezzing look like. a slow fading.
it did not really look like the recognizer was low on power

but if you notice that big round thing above ram's head (looks like a keg or a dynamo)
it got a Lot brighter once ram was derezzed.
abortion pills online abortion questions cytotec abortion

I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.

 
IluthraDanar
User

Posts: 1,178
RE: What was Castor thinking?

on Monday, May, 09, 2011 12:37 AM
I just watched this piece on youtube, and it just seems like it's yes, a slow de-rezz ,as opposed to us watching Tron smash programs with his disk. There doesn't seem to be any need to energize the Recognizer, since it was running just fine moments before. I just think it was a slow death of a program, which may or may not send it's last dying energy into whatever its touching.


Forget it, Mr High and Mighty Master Control. You aren't making me talk.


 
Tron Fanatic
User

Posts: 1,461
RE: What was Castor thinking?

on Monday, May, 09, 2011 1:13 AM
I'm not even sure if this is mean to imply any kind of energy transfer. Try to imagine a time-lapsed video of a decaying corpse, the gradual decaying from flesh to dust, it'd more or less look something like that.

'>
 
rimwall
User

Posts: 507
RE: What was Castor thinking?

on Monday, May, 09, 2011 1:13 AM
IluthraDanar Wrote:I just watched this piece on youtube, and it just seems like it's yes, a slow de-rezz ,as opposed to us watching Tron smash programs with his disk. There doesn't seem to be any need to energize the Recognizer, since it was running just fine moments before. I just think it was a slow death of a program, which may or may not send it's last dying energy into whatever its touching.

right. a couple of more words from ram and they could
have depicted it explicitly as a self-sacrifice scene,
instead of something ambiguous.

now that you mention it - it does seem weird to minimize
the significance of ram's sacrifice.
abortion pills online abortion pill online purchase cytotec abortion

I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.

 
rimwall
User

Posts: 507
RE: What was Castor thinking?

on Monday, May, 09, 2011 2:20 AM
Tron Fanatic Wrote:I'm not even sure if this is mean to imply any kind of energy transfer. Try to imagine a time-lapsed video of a decaying corpse, the gradual decaying from flesh to dust, it'd more or less look something like that.

like programs who are made of energy return back to more
basic energy? i agree.

i have to respectfully disagree on the energy transfer tho -
ram's moving energy dots travelling up an incline to a panel
behind a dynamo then the dynamo lights up- can only indicate energy transfer.



the moving-energy-dot visual cue is too universal to be anything else.

but if you meant ram's intentions on transferring his energy was
not clearly depicted in the scene then i agree.


I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.

 
Tron Fanatic
User

Posts: 1,461
RE: What was Castor thinking?

on Monday, May, 09, 2011 3:02 AM
Well it certainly wasn't well-depicted, because in all the times I've seen it, I never once got the slightest hint that he was sacrificing himself. All I saw was that he felt like he was dying, and didn't want to die alone.

There was nothing to imply that either Flynn or the Reco needed energy, or anything to imply that either of them received it.

'>
 
LWSrocks2
User

Posts: 415
RE: What was Castor thinking?

on Monday, May, 09, 2011 3:04 AM
I'd have to agree with TronFanatic, actually. I never saw it as an energy transfer, and if it was, it'd be kinda pointless. I think if thats what they were intending to convey, they might've made it a tad more obvious, like having Flynn comment: "He's... he's transferring his energy to the Recognizer..."


 
FirstPrevious Page: of 5 PagesNextLast
New New Comments | Post No Change | Locked Closed
Forums 
 TRON: LEGACY 
 What was Castor thinking?