grooveraider User
Posts: 50 | RE: TRON Legacy FAIL Points on Monday, December, 20, 2010 1:32 PM
Imbroglio Wrote:Sub-Odeon Wrote:Imbroglio Wrote:I don't blame flotilla for waiting 28 years only to be let down. Not everyone is an obssessive Tron fanboy willing to overlook shortcommings of TL. |
From what I have seen, flotilla would have probably ripped apart ANYTHING that Disney gave us. Some fans are their own worst enemies -- and enemies of the franchises they claim to love.
So far I am seeing 5/1 positive reviews, with the haters being the outliers.
GO TRON! |
He isn't the only one that is voicing the same concerns on his list. With the amount of money that Disney spent on production and pre-release, people had high expectations that the movie would live up to the hype. There just isn' t the same "magic" that was present with the first movie and I doubt that TL will have the same influence with the audience as Tron did back in 1982. If you ask those in their 30s to early 40s in the computer field if Tron meant anything to them, they would probably have a story to tell. |
Dude, people in their 30s and 40s are desensitized by VFX nowadays.
You're NEVER gonna get that same feeling in 1982 !
But ask a child today in 15 years who would've seen TRON Legacy in IMAX 3D
I'm sure they'll have stories to tell as well.
|
donkeykong-tron User
Posts: 15 | RE: TRON Legacy FAIL Points on Monday, December, 20, 2010 6:56 PM
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR STAYING TRUE MAN ! I just have one question.........do you think the title should have been .......... TRON: "COME AND SPEND TIME WITH FLYNN ONE MORE TIME" ?
|
donkeykong-tron User
Posts: 15 | RE: TRON Legacy FAIL Points on Monday, December, 20, 2010 7:16 PM
Imbroglio Wrote:ShadowDragon1 Wrote:Tron Legacy has inspired me as an aspiring game designer/concept artist **immensely** and I know other graduates in the same subjects as me, that HAVE been inspired by Tron Legacy as well.
I'm sure me and my recent graduates are not the only ones. |
I am not talking about Tron fanboys or other people ALREADY in computer fields.
How many KIDS, who haven't already planned to, are going to be inspired by TL to do so? Back in 1982 I had no idea what direction I wanted to take in high school. Then I saw Tron and it was a big in the direction I took in my life. My mind was awakened to the near endless possibilities that would be possible through the use of computers. |
This movie has no better effects than any other movie of today.
order abortion pill abortion pill buy online where to buy abortion pill
|
donkeykong-tron User
Posts: 15 | RE: TRON Legacy FAIL Points on Monday, December, 20, 2010 7:23 PM
Imbroglio Wrote:Sub-Odeon Wrote:Imbroglio Wrote:I don't blame flotilla for waiting 28 years only to be let down. Not everyone is an obssessive Tron fanboy willing to overlook shortcommings of TL. |
From what I have seen, flotilla would have probably ripped apart ANYTHING that Disney gave us. Some fans are their own worst enemies -- and enemies of the franchises they claim to love.
So far I am seeing 5/1 positive reviews, with the haters being the outliers.
GO TRON! |
He isn't the only one that is voicing the same concerns on his list. With the amount of money that Disney spent on production and pre-release, people had high expectations that the movie would live up to the hype. There just isn' t the same "magic" that was present with the first movie and I doubt that TL will have the same influence with the audience as Tron did back in 1982. If you ask those in their 30s to early 40s in the computer field if Tron meant anything to them, they would probably have a story to tell. |
i have a story to tell alright, buddy. check out my topic. And why are people mad and talking mess and calling names to flotilla for saying this movie was a dud? he has to agree with everyone because this is a tron forum? But you are rite on the money with your post, too. Matter of fact, i think t is funy how people are talking about a Tron3. There wont be one, thanks to this movie error.
|
CaptainCR User
Posts: 1,468 | RE: TRON Legacy FAIL Points on Monday, December, 20, 2010 7:30 PM
DevourTheLiving Wrote:OT: Am I the only one who has grown tired of the rapid rise in the use of the words, "epic", "fail", and "win"? It was fine at first, but now it's just incredibly annoying. Are there really no better adjectives to describe a good or bad...anything? acman: |
TRON LEGACY was......
radical manwhere to buy abortion pill abortion types buy abortion pill online "You know you don't look a thing like your pictures?" |
ShadowDragon1 User
Posts: 2,056 | RE: TRON Legacy FAIL Points on Monday, December, 20, 2010 7:31 PM
oh boy.... order abortion pill abortion pill buy online where to buy abortion pill
"The film is about finding human connection in an increasingly digital world." - Joseph Kosinski
|
Wugmanmax User
Posts: 131 | RE: TRON Legacy FAIL Points on Monday, December, 20, 2010 7:46 PM
I thought the movie was great, as did several of my fellow TRON-fan companions. Even friends that came along that hadn't even seen the original thought it was good. They didn't geek out like us fans, but they thought it was a cool movie nonetheless.
My kids on the other hand... have not been able to stop talking about TRON since we saw it. They liked the original TRON... they loved TRON: Legacy.
http://www.10mfh.com, a great place to read nerdy stuff! |
donkeykong-tron User
Posts: 15 | RE: TRON Legacy FAIL Points on Monday, December, 20, 2010 7:48 PM
flotilla Wrote:
As an absolute fan of the original Tron (viewed over 300 times), listed below are a couple FAIL points that I observed in Tron Legacy during a midnight screening of the film:
1. Garrett Hedlund's acting ability
2. Minimum use of the Tron character in the movie.
3. Horrible redo's of the origiinal films one-liners
4. Flying Top Gun-like space ship fighter vehicles
5. Clu's Face (holy horrible cgi)
6. The Plot
7. Too many boring scenes (way too many)
8. Costumes (compared to original)
9. Transistion from Real World to the grid (way too short)
10. The character of Zues
I'm sure there are many more but those are the initial 10 that bothered me the most.
|
1. agree......people are have been brainwashed by bollywood into believing what a "good actor " really is............
2. agree........oh, looking at the wannabe Boba Fett 3-second scenes didn't make him mysterious, and the honda motorcycle helmet didn't make him scary enough for you ?
3.agree..............hey---who wants originality these days ???
4.agree...................what??? hey,if they can do star wars scenes, they midus well have the same ships with street glo tubing too !!!!!
5.agree............hey, botox wasn't as good then as it is now, ask jeff bridges !!!!
6.agree..........huh? what plot?? what are you talking about??
7.agree........ok. you are really upsetting me. when they showed flynn on the grid reminicing about boy wonder on the beach riding his bike you didnt cry ???
8.agree.......dude, you're full of it. spandex was hot when the original tron came out, and who needs any lighting on a bruce lee "game of death" suit ?
9.agree.............i think i had already fallen asleep by the time that part of the comedy happened.
10.agree............hey, british homosexuals that resemble david bowie don't make movies fun????
11-1000...................Hey, why did you leave these out ?order abortion pill http://unclejohnsprojects.com/template/default.aspx?morning-after-pill-price where to buy abortion pillwhere to buy abortion pill ordering abortion pills to be shipped to house buy abortion pill online
|
Euphemizm User
Posts: 112 | RE: TRON Legacy FAIL Points on Monday, December, 20, 2010 7:49 PM
Its like CLU says to Jarivs.... "It wasn't for them".
I agree.
---edit---
What I mean is that Tron Legacy wasn't for the people who dislike it.
|
CaptainCR User
Posts: 1,468 | RE: TRON Legacy FAIL Points on Monday, December, 20, 2010 7:54 PM
Imbroglio Wrote:ShadowDragon1 Wrote:Tron Legacy has inspired me as an aspiring game designer/concept artist **immensely** and I know other graduates in the same subjects as me, that HAVE been inspired by Tron Legacy as well.
I'm sure me and my recent graduates are not the only ones. |
I am not talking about Tron fanboys or other people ALREADY in computer fields.
How many KIDS, who haven't already planned to, are going to be inspired by TL to do so? Back in 1982 I had no idea what direction I wanted to take in high school. Then I saw Tron and it was a big in the direction I took in my life. My mind was awakened to the near endless possibilities that would be possible through the use of computers. |
Uhm I've been a fan of tron for a long time and it wasn't untill TRON LEGACY was announced that i got interested in game design and development.
and honestly ok yes, the original tron inspired ppl to be game designers and stuff but think about it..back then there was hardly any cool technology..ppls lives were not as heavily affected by technology back then as they are now..which is why TRON LEGACY won't have the technological inspiring impact as the first one..but it does still give ppl messages about technology and how we use it to communicate with eachother..where to buy abortion pill ordering abortion pills to be shipped to house buy abortion pill online "You know you don't look a thing like your pictures?" |
Euphemizm User
Posts: 112 | RE: TRON Legacy FAIL Points on Monday, December, 20, 2010 7:55 PM
Oh btw, Flotilla,
The project for 2008 comic con Tron teaser trailer is rendered at 1920x1080.
Where it gets tricky is that they wanted 235 so they framed it like it was 235 with black bars even though the original render is in 1920x1080. It has been post cropped though framed like it was 235.
Thats what I see here in the 3D project file cameras in Maya AND the nuke composite. Also, there wasn't Vray for maya at the time of creation so animation was piped out to Max for rendering in Vray.
|
ShadowDragon1 User
Posts: 2,056 | RE: TRON Legacy FAIL Points on Monday, December, 20, 2010 7:56 PM
I must of seen a a different movie called "Tron Legacy", because I don't agree with any of these over-blown complaints or "fail points" at all.
I'm a hardcore Tron fan, but not a close-minded uber-purist fanboy, since I actually really enjoy the movie; I guess I fail as a Tron fan and must hand in my "Hardcore Tron Fan" membership card now! Wheee! :/
"The film is about finding human connection in an increasingly digital world." - Joseph Kosinski
|
Beefkiller User
Posts: 334 | RE: TRON Legacy FAIL Points on Monday, December, 20, 2010 8:07 PM
Fail points??? I didn't see any fail points in this film whatsoever. The only fail points I see is people bickering and nitpicking ...wwaahhh waaahhh waahhh grow some balls. This film was made from us fans back in '82, and nothing will stop my passion for loving this franchise. Here we finally have Tron and people complain. But oh...when harry crapper and twilight comes out with new crap, people love it. No wonder why todays society sucks. People today cant APPRECIATE anything anymore. Heck, back in '82 when I was 6, I didn't complain about TRON being "boring" or "crappy plot", no I took it in because that was OUR TIME. C64, atari, collecovision, VIC-20's. That was the graphics then. To me its not out of date and never will be...and it's still the movie I will look up to till I die.
Now we have Tron: Legacy. I felt this movie lived up to what we (real fans) have been waiting for , for these last 28 years. The graphics kick butt (better then avatar and transformers crap) , the acting was great.. soundtrack..words cannot explain. But all hell breaks loose cause of Garrett Hedlund can't act,..or "this ain't a daft punk cd"...wow seriously... oh wait here's my favorite "I'm only going to see this movie cause of Daft Punk".. HA.. I'm glad they showed you guys. I'm grateful that DP did the music in orchestra. If yu want to talk about "fail points" , might as well point to yourself. Your the biggest failure of them all.. End of Line
"Like the man says, there's no problems, only solutions. " ~ Kevin Flynn |
TRONtastic User
Posts: 40 | RE: TRON Legacy FAIL Points on Tuesday, December, 21, 2010 12:13 AM
1. Disagree- He wasn't terrible. I felt he was decent. Not the best but not horrible.
2. Agree: Though when he was Rinzler I felt they could do more with Tron as just Tron like I was expecting him to fight Clu more towards the end
3. Somewhat agree - The one liners felt a little forced but I enjoyed them nonetheless as they were only a little less cheesy in the original film
4. Disagree- I thought the Light Jets were a great addition to the film!
5. Somewhat disagree - Didn't think it was too bad. For at least now.
6. Somewhat agree - Wasn't bad but it was more a father/son trip into any different world and this one happened to be a computer than one that had to do with traveling inside a computer to meet personified programs who literally perform their functions and look like their users. Only sign of this was with Clu and it just made it feel like he was the only one. Could have used a lot more.
7. Disagree- Thought the movie was entertaining and fun throughout
8. Disagree - Though I liked the original costumes they were kinda goofy lol These ones I can take a little more seriously.
9. Agree- But it's not really too important.
10. Disagree- I liked him. He was over the top but he was really entertaining to watch
Overall Don't nitpick. This was a pretty interesting and fun movie if you go into it with an open mind
As a Tron fan I didn't like it that much. It was more bleh-okay from my Tron fan point of view but as a from a just a movie point of view it was awesome!
where to buy abortion pill ordering abortion pills to be shipped to house buy abortion pill online ___________________________________
|
flotilla User
Posts: 47 | RE: TRON Legacy FAIL Points on Tuesday, December, 21, 2010 7:38 PM
Euphemizm Wrote:Oh btw, Flotilla,
The project for 2008 comic con Tron teaser trailer is rendered at 1920x1080.
Where it gets tricky is that they wanted 235 so they framed it like it was 235 with black bars even though the original render is in 1920x1080. It has been post cropped though framed like it was 235.
Thats what I see here in the 3D project file cameras in Maya AND the nuke composite. Also, there wasn't Vray for maya at the time of creation so animation was piped out to Max for rendering in Vray.
|
That's very interesting. The files for the versions released to the public seem to only show 1920x800 though.
I mean, if we were to open the vids at maximum resolution, the best we would get would be 1920x800 pixels. If we wanted the vid to be 1920x1080, we would have to strech the 800 pixels up to 1080 thus causing distortion.
I wonder if the set of final output files that you have in the project is different than what the public was offered?
Do you happen to know the filesizes, were they greater than 244MB by any chance? Sorry, I'm not familiar with 235 processing just yet.
|
Euphemizm User
Posts: 112 | RE: TRON Legacy FAIL Points on Tuesday, December, 21, 2010 8:22 PM
235 is a ratio, like 16:9
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super_35
The trick here is that though the original has 1920x1080 they are cropping pixels on the top and bottom arbitrarily to get that aspect ratio from 16:9 that is full HD.
So what you end up with is 1920x1080 though since the top and bottom are cropped to get the 235 ratio it ends up being 1920x800. The cameras were set up with safe areas that showed the 235 viewing area even though the full render was 1920x1080.
What it means is that we had more data on the top and bottom that you don't see due to the black bars. This was a time saver choice. We could have rendered much higher resolution essentially getting full 1080 from top to bottom but then the width aspect would be more then 1920. For Tron:Legacy we used much higher res then HD. It was like over 2K+. Larger then full HD but at the 235 aspect ration too. There was no cropping tricks. The final film is fully shot and rendered in very high res and that was how the print went out too.
But for the teaser, render times for the full235 were calculated in vs black bar framing at full HD and the comparison renders were made we saw little difference in the end result due to the detail levels. It was there but very slight. So the cropping at 1920x1080 to end up with 1920x800 was chosen to save time. In Legacy the details were much more defined and the higher res (especially in IMAX) makes a huge difference.
Disney may include a high res version of the teaser trailer on the Legacy Blu ray as an extra. Though it will probably be just a blu _ray quality version of the original black barred 1920x1080 uncompressed.
|
Jake73 User
Posts: 7 | RE: TRON Legacy FAIL Points on Tuesday, December, 21, 2010 8:36 PM
This film is way to new to evaluate on a completely bias level. Needs to gestate before it gets gutted by folks who have way too much free time on their hands. Granted there are some continuity errors and whatnot but seriously, THEY MADE A SEQUEL TO TRON. WHY ARE YOU COMPLAINING ABOUT IT. YOU SHOULD BE GRATEFUL IT EXISTS.
|
flotilla User
Posts: 47 | RE: TRON Legacy FAIL Points on Tuesday, December, 21, 2010 9:07 PM
Euphemizm Wrote:235 is a ratio, like 16:9
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super_35
The trick here is that though the original has 1920x1080 they are cropping pixels on the top and bottom arbitrarily to get that aspect ratio from 16:9 that is full HD.
So what you end up with is 1920x1080 though since the top and bottom are cropped to get the 235 ratio it ends up being 1920x800. The cameras were set up with safe areas that showed the 235 viewing area even though the full render was 1920x1080.
What it means is that we had more data on the top and bottom that you don't see due to the black bars. This was a time saver choice. We could have rendered much higher resolution essentially getting full 1080 from top to bottom but then the width aspect would be more then 1920. For Tron:Legacy we used much higher res then HD. It was like over 2K+. Larger then full HD but at the 235 aspect ration too. There was no cropping tricks. The final film is fully shot and rendered in very high res and that was how the print went out too.
But for the teaser, render times for the full235 were calculated in vs black bar framing at full HD and the comparison renders were made we saw little difference in the end result due to the detail levels. It was there but very slight. So the cropping at 1920x1080 to end up with 1920x800 was chosen to save time. In Legacy the details were much more defined and the higher res (especially in IMAX) makes a huge difference.
Disney may include a high res version of the teaser trailer on the Legacy Blu ray as an extra. Though it will probably be just a blu _ray quality version of the original black barred 1920x1080 uncompressed. |
That is amazing to hear and very interesting to learn about. I render in Lightwave from time to time at 5760x1080 (tri-panel) and the render times can be incredible so it makes sense to go down to the 1920x800 resolution to save time.
Curious about how long it took to render the concept trailer? Think anyone will ever render it in 2k?
|
hobowitha50cal User
Posts: 5 | RE: TRON Legacy FAIL Points on Tuesday, December, 21, 2010 9:08 PM
flotilla Wrote:
As an absolute fan of the original Tron (viewed over 300 times), listed below are a couple FAIL points that I observed in Tron Legacy during a midnight screening of the film:
1. Garrett Hedlund's acting ability
2. Minimum use of the Tron character in the movie.
3. Horrible redo's of the origiinal films one-liners
4. Flying Top Gun-like space ship fighter vehicles
5. Clu's Face (holy horrible cgi)
6. The Plot
7. Too many boring scenes (way too many)
8. Costumes (compared to original)
9. Transistion from Real World to the grid (way too short)
10. The character of Zues
I'm sure there are many more but those are the initial 10 that bothered me the most.
|
1. Agree and disagree — Yeah but they've could have done worse. Like someone mentioned: would you prefer LeBouf? Thought not. Plus, I think it was kind of in his character to be as "stiff" as he was. That's just the typical cyberpunk protagonist: Neo from The Matrix, Decker from Blade Runner, Case from Neuromancer, the list goes on.
2. Kind of agree — I liked how he was masked. It gave him more of a mysterious but heroic allure to him. They should have used that a bit more.
3. Disagree — I think those were more Dude-isms there. As a Jeff Bridges fan, I approved.
4. Agree and disagree — Okay, yeah, they were gimmicky but they were still cool.
5. Agree — ...but it kind of worked when they were inside the grid. They shouldn't have showed it in reality because when this movie's CGI gets outdated, it will, in a way, break the film's fourth wall. It wasn't terrible but it was still too obvious (and overly creepy).
6. Disagree — I honestly thought this was going to be a "Save the Princess" plot, not a "let's break out of here or die trying" one; I'm pleased by the route it took. It felt kind of short despite the film being two hours. The story's beats were separated by too many drawn out bits and those beats weren't built up at all. It was like sudden action --> steep fall --> sudden action.
7. Agree — Look at 6.
8. PFFFT DISAGREE — What the hell are you talking about? I'm sorry but I would have sex in those suits. Kinky Latex and Leather > Skin Tight Pajamas
9. I can't decide if I disagree or not. — Yeah, I was expecting something about more drawn out and epic but I was slightly high when I saw this part and it looked pretty cool to me.
10. Disagree — Blame that on him not being developed enough. He seemed really interesting but they killed him off so fast that he didn't even feel important enough to matter. I mean, what's more interesting than a coked-up, metrosexual David Bowie with a cane that shoots 8-bit bullets and has a hot mistress?
Jake73 Wrote:Granted there are some continuity errors and whatnot but seriously, THEY MADE A SEQUEL TO TRON. WHY ARE YOU COMPLAINING ABOUT IT. YOU SHOULD BE GRATEFUL IT EXISTS. |
This.
|
flotilla User
Posts: 47 | RE: TRON Legacy FAIL Points on Tuesday, December, 21, 2010 9:25 PM
Jake73 Wrote:This film is way to new to evaluate on a completely bias level. Needs to gestate before it gets gutted by folks who have way too much free time on their hands. Granted there are some continuity errors and whatnot but seriously, THEY MADE A SEQUEL TO TRON. WHY ARE YOU COMPLAINING ABOUT IT. YOU SHOULD BE GRATEFUL IT EXISTS. |
Hey Jake.
I am greatful the sequel exists I was just pointing out some things that I personally felt were lowpoints of the film, some others felt the same way, and others completely disagreed. I am going to see it in the theatre another time but I have to be honest. I enjoyed the original Tron better than the sequel and many parts in Legacy seemed boring to me, and not just me, but others I was with.
Some of the reasons are because of the 10 points I mentioned, other reasons probably have nothing to do with the film, i.e. arcades, 80's, personal computers were new, CGI being a new and cutting edge film feature whereas today it is taken for granted and many times overused, etc.
I still think the actors in the original were much better, even Jeff Bridges performance. Lots of reasons why I wasn't as impressed with Legacy as I was with the original Tron.
I am still more than happy an attempt was made. I'm also hoping that if another sequel is made, that it will outperform Legacy.
Another thing is that I consider myself to be obsessed with the original Tron movie. If you have ever pretended you were a character from a movie (like Kevin Flynn for instance) for very long periods of time such as I did with the original film, you can sort of understand why I am so critical of the sequel. Try not to take the criticism too personally, afterall, I am obsessed, so my opinion doesn't count much anyway.
|
|