TronFAQ Sector Admin
 Posts: 4,467 | TRON page on Wikipedia - Fans sites removed on Friday, October, 20, 2006 8:26 AM

You know, I can't believe how anal the people who maintain Wikipedia pages can be sometimes.
Seems there's a new policy that pages should not link to fan sites any more. They're not "relevant" enough, I guess. So, for example, the link to Tron-Sector on the Tron film page was removed. I expect the same to happen to the Tron 2.0 page soon.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tron_(film)
This, to me, makes absolutely no sense. If people are looking for information on Tron, what is wrong with listing other sites that can contain more detailed information than what the wikipedia page can provide? Just because they're "fan" sites?
Stupid.
  where to buy abortion pill abortion types buy abortion pill online LDSO • Facebook • Twitter • YouTube • DeviantArt
 |
CyberBlade User
 Posts: 131 | Re: TRON page on Wikipedia - Fans sites removed on Friday, October, 20, 2006 9:07 AM
for amny years now they have been doing that.
wiki is just power hungry where they can choose whats "relevent" and what isnt.
even though it is.
Wiki isnt a public service and never has been since 2004.
but, no reason why you can have your own.
lookup
http://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/MediaWiki
and you can have your own tron one
hehe ill host it if you wish, just grab a tk domain for it too!
-
Unlimited bandwith and unlimited hdd space
i love my isp!
Signiture
"So, You are a user, Facinating." "Yes" "No"
"Hah, ICP should stand for Incompetant Confused Programs." |
|
Boingo_Buzzard User
 Posts: 0 | Re: TRON page on Wikipedia - Fans sites removed on Friday, October, 20, 2006 10:35 AM
CyberBlade Wrote:
Wiki isnt a public service and never has been since 2004. |
Wow... "never" only goes back to 2004?
 |
TronFAQ Sector Admin
 Posts: 4,467 | Re: TRON page on Wikipedia - Fans sites removed on Friday, October, 20, 2006 6:43 PM

Well, how's this for hypocrisy . . .
I see information in those pages that came from those very fan sites. Very specific examples of info that had to come from those sites, and nowhere else.
Yet, those fan sites are not cited as a source.
And then they have removed, or potentially will remove, links to them on top of that?
It's wrong. Very, very wrong.
EDIT: Haha, what do you know. Someone put the link back. Thanks to whomever did that. I would have done it myself, but it's nice to see someone else agrees.
  LDSO • Facebook • Twitter • YouTube • DeviantArt
 |
TheReelTodd Sector Admin
 Posts: 0 | Re: TRON page on Wikipedia - Fans sites removed on Friday, October, 20, 2006 7:00 PM
redrain85 Wrote:EDIT: Haha, what do you know. Someone put the link back. Thanks to whomever did that. I would have done it myself, but it's nice to see someone else agrees.
|
Well, I saw that someone tried to put a link to TRON-Sector on there, but it wasn't done correctly and didn't show up, so I corrected the link and modified the text a little.
But I'm not sure which other links were removed or missing. Probably best for a volunteer to become a member there and monitor the TRON film page - JUST to make sure no one messes with Wiki's entry of TRON. 
        
|
TronFAQ Sector Admin
 Posts: 4,467 | Re: TRON page on Wikipedia - Fans sites removed on Friday, October, 20, 2006 7:10 PM
LDSO • Facebook • Twitter • YouTube • DeviantArt
 |
TheReelTodd Sector Admin
 Posts: 0 | Re: TRON page on Wikipedia - Fans sites removed on Friday, October, 20, 2006 9:53 PM
redrain85 Wrote:I'm going to download the software that assists in editing Wikipedia pages, and start monitoring the Tron pages more closely.
Since I didn't create the pages, I think I'm going to be in for some potentially huge battles. But I'm willing to represent the fan sites in this matter. |
Excellent!
I'd hate to think you're going to have to do battle, but if that happens and you feel things are being treated unfairly, you keep us well informed here. You're not alone either. I think it's safe to say you'll have the support of TRON-Sector, Boxhat and many other TRON fan sites behind you. My apologies for knowing the two off the top of my head.
This may prove to make an interesting article for TRON-Sector's main page - one that many TRON fans may be very interested in learning about.
Let's hope there is nothing to have to blow the cover on though. I'd rather TRON and resources there of just be treated fairly there. 
        
|
TheReelTodd Sector Admin
 Posts: 0 | Re: TRON page on Wikipedia - Fans sites removed on Friday, October, 20, 2006 10:11 PM
Ok, that was wrong.
I just went back to check and see if the TRON-Sector link I JUST added (an hour or two ago) was still there, and it was GONE!
Grrrr.
I looked at the page's history and saw that it had been rolled back a step... to where the link was there in the code, but did not display on the page.
I changed it again, and then looked at the history again. This time I noticed that the guy who rolled it back commented that "fan site is sufficient", referring to my wording of "The world's largest TRON fan site and online archive of production photos, articles, TRON 2.0 custom maps, fan art, and everything TRON" being too much.
Ok, a compromise. I edited my text down to simply "The world's largest TRON fan site.". We'll see if that sticks. If not, I hope the guy at least revises the link so that is SHOWS up and isn't just an invisible bit of text in the source code.
The guy who modified it has the user name of Theplanetsaturn.
Here is a link to the history of the TRON page there:
http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Tron_%28film%29&action=history.
I'm not going to play pong with Theplanetsaturn if he keeps revising things, contacting him may be a good idea. I don't think he's trying to be rude or snub TRON (or The Sector for that matter), but I do think this needs further looking in to.abortion pills online http://www.kvicksundscupen.se/template/default.aspx?abortion-questions cytotec abortion
        
|
MutoidMan User
 Posts: 2,232 | Re: TRON page on Wikipedia - Fans sites removed on Friday, October, 20, 2006 10:26 PM
Bah! Bring up the Death Star!where to buy abortion pill ordering abortion pills to be shipped to house buy abortion pill online
"We are, after all, not God." - Cmdr. J. J. Adams "C is for cookie. That's good enough for me." - Cookie Monster "If money is the root of all evil, I'd like to be a bad, bad man." - Huey Lewis & the News
Most recent PC game collection update: 04/12/2012. Check it out!  |
KiaPurity User
 Posts: 3,488 | Re: TRON page on Wikipedia - Fans sites removed on Friday, October, 20, 2006 11:45 PM
Wikipedia is starting to get really stupid with stupid people deciding to have their stupid immature flamefights over something like this.
Sheesh! Information is NEEDED. It's hard for wikipedia to be unbiased when there's clearly biased people keep rolling back information and/or removing pages if they don't like it. >  where to buy abortion pill http://blog.bitimpulse.com/template/default.aspx?abortion-types buy abortion pill online Kia: Cool. I'm a infamous mythological perfect User. 
 |
lurkinghorror User
 Posts: 803 | Re: TRON page on Wikipedia - Fans sites removed on Saturday, October, 21, 2006 2:09 AM
Actually, you don't need to look far to discover the identity of "theplanetsaturn".
The trick is, the listing of Tron Sector IS the compromise. I've been fighting for it's inclusion for over a week, as people who seem to believe themselves to be self appointed Wikipedia guardians keep removing it with the argument that "we don't link to fansites". I've repeatedly readded the link while citing the ACTUAL rules of Wikipedia. That rule being: "According to Wikipedia: External Links "On articles about topics with many fansites, including a link to one major fansite may be appropriate, marking the link as such."
I removed the description for two reasons. One: The entire link can be removed under the justification of "advertising". And after some of my previous conflicts with those behind the blanket deletion, I would not be surprised if that approach was attempted. And two, the fact that the link is there at all basically implies that Tron Sector is THE Tron fansite.
So basically, I'm trying to maintain a neutral position. Arguing for the link, but allowing a compromise by listing it specifically as the Wikipedia guidelines allow.
I've actually had quite a runaround with some of the people who like to practice the blanket deletion of information on that page. Support from the Sector would be most welcome.
I didn't know the link was broken. I'm terrible with code.  abortion pills online abortion pill online purchase cytotec abortion
 |
TheReelTodd Sector Admin
 Posts: 0 | Re: TRON page on Wikipedia - Fans sites removed on Saturday, October, 21, 2006 10:04 AM
lurkinghorror Wrote:Actually, you don't need to look far to discover the identity of "theplanetsaturn".
The trick is, the listing of Tron Sector IS the compromise. I've been fighting for it's inclusion for over a week, as people who seem to believe themselves to be self appointed Wikipedia guardians keep removing it with the argument that "we don't link to fansites". I've repeatedly readded the link while citing the ACTUAL rules of Wikipedia. That rule being: "According to Wikipedia: External Links "On articles about topics with many fansites, including a link to one major fansite may be appropriate, marking the link as such."
I removed the description for two reasons. One: The entire link can be removed under the justification of "advertising". And after some of my previous conflicts with those behind the blanket deletion, I would not be surprised if that approach was attempted. And two, the fact that the link is there at all basically implies that Tron Sector is THE Tron fansite.
So basically, I'm trying to maintain a neutral position. Arguing for the link, but allowing a compromise by listing it specifically as the Wikipedia guidelines allow.
I've actually had quite a runaround with some of the people who like to practice the blanket deletion of information on that page. Support from the Sector would be most welcome.
I didn't know the link was broken. I'm terrible with code.  |

I'm sorry, lurkinghorror - I had no idea I was playing pong with you!
I get where you're coming from on this. I know there are "Wikipedia guardians" who are very "protective" (note the quotes) of the site's articles, but I had no idea that such lengths were taken and the extent of rule they exhibit. I guess the good is that they are doing what they feel is right. The bad is that personal bias can seep in to the process.
There are many TRON fan sites - a quick search on Google will reveal that. But TRON-Sector is one of a few that stand out most in the TRON community and without a doubt, the largest, most visited TRON website on the net.
Let's see if the TRON-Sector link remains this time. It was still there minutes ago when I checked.
If it ends up missing again, we'll put it back up with a little less description. redrain85 has stated that he will be monitoring the TRON page there more closely in the future. Perhaps between the two of you, the "Wiki-guardians" can be coaxed in to allowing a little more truth about TRON and TRON resources used in the article, to be displayed properly on the page.
Just for future reference though, when you modify a link on Wikipedia, just give the page another look (using the refresh) after editing the article to be sure that the changes took ok.
TRON fights for the Users...
WE fight for TRON!
        
|
NoExcuses User
 Posts: 1,760 | Re: TRON page on Wikipedia - Fans sites removed on Saturday, October, 21, 2006 10:38 AM
TheReelTodd Wrote:WE fight for TRON!
|
Some of us fight for the MCP, Throne, FCon or are independant, you insensitive clod!
...oh, you mean the movie, right. Now I feel like an idiot.
 abortion pills online abortion pill online purchase cytotec abortion
|
Traahn User
 Posts: 3,305 | Re: TRON page on Wikipedia - Fans sites removed on Saturday, October, 21, 2006 12:12 PM
Any time there is information, jurisdiction or some other thing to control, and someone or some people feel they should control or rule said things, there will be power struggles and attempted displays of power. Thus, we have wars. Both at the global level, and the internet Wikipedia level. Pretty sad.
              
I'm getting out of here right now, and you guys are invited.  -----^ |
TheReelTodd Sector Admin
 Posts: 0 | Re: TRON page on Wikipedia - Fans sites removed on Saturday, October, 21, 2006 5:39 PM
Traahn Wrote:Any time there is information, jurisdiction or some other thing to control, and someone or some people feel they should control or rule said things, there will be power struggles and attempted displays of power. Thus, we have wars. Both at the global level, and the internet Wikipedia level. Pretty sad. |
Yes, sad but true.
Unfortunately, everyone seems to "know" (note the quotes) how everyone else should live their life, or how they should do things, or just how things aught to be, period. There are those who take a moment to understand people with opposing views and different opinions. And there are those who seek to control opinion and even knowledge. I generally refer to the latter as politicians.
        
|
TronFAQ Sector Admin
 Posts: 4,467 | Re: TRON page on Wikipedia - Fans sites removed on Saturday, October, 21, 2006 6:39 PM
LDSO • Facebook • Twitter • YouTube • DeviantArt
 |
jmaynard User
 Posts: 0 | Re: TRON page on Wikipedia - Fans sites removed on Saturday, October, 21, 2006 10:28 PM
Sounds like I need to add that page to my watchlist, as well.
Jay Maynard, the Tron Guy |
TronFAQ Sector Admin
 Posts: 4,467 | Re: TRON page on Wikipedia - Fans sites removed on Sunday, October, 22, 2006 7:26 PM
LDSO • Facebook • Twitter • YouTube • DeviantArt
 |
TronFAQ Sector Admin
 Posts: 4,467 | Re: TRON page on Wikipedia - Fans sites removed on Wednesday, May, 30, 2007 5:35 PM

I've revived this thread because I see that the struggle to keep Tron-Sector listed a a fan site, continues on the Wikipedia Tron film article.
I still can't believe what a bunch of anal martinets the moderators are, who are maintaining the article. Instead of taking the intent of the rules into consideration, they're following them as literally as possible. And somehow the mention and linkage of Tron-Sector has been deemed not worth inclusion. It has "nothing to offer" you see.
So I guess that means everything on Tron-Sector can be found in the Wikipedia article then. Photos, interviews, discussions that are relevant to Tron . . . those are all part of the Wikipedia article, are they?
I'm probably going to jump into the discussion there, but it seems to be a losing battle. I see Lurkinghorror has been arguing back and forth with them for the longest time. It's gotten simply ridiculous.
  LDSO • Facebook • Twitter • YouTube • DeviantArt
 |
Mr. Sinistar Sector Admin
 Posts: 1,642 | Re: TRON page on Wikipedia - Fans sites removed on Wednesday, May, 30, 2007 5:50 PM
Wikipedia has been sucking a lot recently. One guy decided to rename the article that I worked so hard on, somehow effectively removing all previous edits made on that article including mine. I had to say something about it, so I posted on the talk page for the article that I originally created it.
I hope this would eventually work out with the Admins and us.
EDIT: I wish I could join you guys, but I'm too nervous to join in on this (unfortunately) rather hostile discussion.
OPEN SOURCE TRON PROJECT
"what the hell is a limux.."
- Gattorcar (a user on YouTube) April 17, 2007
test |
|