Forums (I/O Tower)
Forums 
 TRON: LEGACY 
 tron's redemption


New New Comments | Post No Change | Locked Closed
AuthorComments:  Page: of 2 PagesNextLast
rimwall
User

Posts: 507
tron's redemption

on Saturday, April, 23, 2011 2:32 AM
my friends and i were discussing tron legacy and the topic of tron's
redemption invevitably came up. someone asked for us to at least point
to a tv trope or explain in terms of loose programming.

so we came up with this:

the closer tron/rinzler gets to "actually" killing flynn then
the closer tron gets to two conflicting decision points/directives.
obviously the core-original coding part of tron won out.
obviously clu's rectification process does not go that deep

and here is the movie trope:
john connor: what is your mission?
ahhhhhhnold: to ensure the survival of john connor and katherine brewster
john connor: you are about to FAIL that mission!

seeing flynn obviously had an impact on tron but it was
clu's conflicting directive that pushed tron to the edge -
making tron choose between his deep original directives or
clu's recent order.

two events have to happen in order for tron's original
directives to kick in.
1. the original basic directives have to be directly challenged
2. and rinzler has to be pushed to point where his next move kills flynn

the terminator3 clip was chosen because discussion boards
never had a problem with the visual of arnold's override.
the static-ky visual is practically a hollywood standard
in terms of visual tropes.

i could not understand why my non-fan friends could not
accept the scene. until i realized that they probaby
had a problem with voices in the head being too "humanlike"
i guess they wanted a computereeze visual explanation.

obviously T:Legacy's director cannot insert a visual like "terminator
override" so i guess he opted for voices in the head.



thoughts?


little off-topic:
speaking of visual tropes did anyone find it intriguing
that flynn's flashback of clu's coup has static.
where to buy abortion pill http://blog.bitimpulse.com/template/default.aspx?abortion-types buy abortion pill online

I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.

 
Tron Fanatic
User

Posts: 1,461
RE: tron's redemption

on Saturday, April, 23, 2011 3:19 AM
A visual screen effect wouldn't work in a TRON film because they're Programs, not robots. Following the rules of TRON, a Terminator would have an OS full of Programs running around inside (if you could manage the digitization process). So Programs don't see funky HUD effects in their vision, or unplug their limbs and fix them, etc. As far as they're concerned, they're normal people.

And I will say, if the film HAD suddenly gone into a Tron vision-mode with funky effects, that probably would have made me feel ill. I was able to get by with the blood on the Grid thing (which was really pushing the CANON envelope), but that would have been WAY too much.

Aye, I did find the analog memory thing a bit odd. Didn't really know where they were going with that. Though there is something in the ARG about Flynn storing media files of his family, presumably, onto his Grid computer. Maybe that's how it looks when he brings it up, and well, after a thousand years, his coherent memories of them went bye bye and all he had to go by was the video footage, which was all cheap NTSC imagery. So that and that alone became his memory, glitchy artifacts and all.

'>
 
Jackie Lawless
User

Posts: 52
RE: tron's redemption

on Saturday, April, 23, 2011 4:12 AM
this actually kinda makes sense.

when he fought sam, it was after he had wounded him he completely relented, instead of simply derezzing him instantly like any other combatant.

after he realizes who was actually inside the lightjet, he completely flips mode.

very reasonable. i like the terminator analogy tho lol.

He Sill fights for the users...
 
rimwall
User

Posts: 507
RE: tron's redemption

on Saturday, April, 23, 2011 4:24 AM
i agreee TronFanatic. i have to ask tho:

what's your interpretation?
why does tron's redemption scene bother some people?

i've seen the discussions on some of the movie blogs. and i've seen
some posts here in tron sector.


I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.

 
rimwall
User

Posts: 507
RE: tron's redemption

on Saturday, April, 23, 2011 4:42 AM
thanks for pointing out tron's fight with sam Jackie.

that scene was the biggest hurdle we had to explain,
before we came up with the terminator trope

in order for tron to turn good(during disk wars), clu would have to
order tron to kill sam and keep pushing tron/rinzler
until near the point-of-no-return.

thank god for ahhnold.


I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.

 
Tron Fanatic
User

Posts: 1,461
RE: tron's redemption

on Saturday, April, 23, 2011 5:43 AM
rimwall Wrote:i agreee TronFanatic. i have to ask tho:

what's your interpretation?
why does tron's redemption scene bother some people?

i've seen the discussions on some of the movie blogs. and i've seen
some posts here in tron sector.

I'm really not sure what is bothering some people about it. I think more of it pertains to him being left to rot in the water (with not so much as an indication of whether or not he survived), moreso than how he 'turned back to the light side.'

I think there were two possibilities, both of which directly relate to contact with Kevin. I'd have to check again to make sure, but I'm pretty sure the moment that Flynn looks up at him from inside the light jet is the first contact those two have had with each other since who knows when. Yori in the short time the MCP's group seven lockdown was in progress, was acting more or less like a drone, and didn't recognize Tron until he gave her an extra shake. And we know how long Kevin has been trapped in the Grid, which means it's been roughly 1K years for Tron too, so even without rectification, Tron's mind would be in a pretty dark place after all that time.

One of two things clicked for Tron's at that moment. I can't really be sure of the first one or not because of the black visor, but it's my feeling the Kevin and Tron made eye contact. Second, which is easier to figure, is Tron heard Kevin say "What have you become?"

Either way, that could be the first time in centuries that Tron knew Flynn was even alive anymore. So even more than realizing your friend is still around, its realizing your god is still around. Just imagine what that kind of realization would feel like for someone who has been a slave for untold eons.abortion pills online abortion pill online purchase cytotec abortion

'>
 
rimwall
User

Posts: 507
RE: tron's redemption

on Saturday, April, 23, 2011 6:02 AM
Tron Fanatic Wrote:
rimwall Wrote:i agreee TronFanatic. i have to ask tho:

what's your interpretation?
why does tron's redemption scene bother some people?

i've seen the discussions on some of the movie blogs. and i've seen
some posts here in tron sector.

I'm really not sure what is bothering some people about it. I think more of it pertains to him being left to rot in the water (with not so much as an indication of whether or not he survived), moreso than how he 'turned back to the light side.'

I think there were two possibilities, both of which directly relate to contact with Kevin. I'd have to check again to make sure, but I'm pretty sure the moment that Flynn looks up at him from inside the light jet is the first contact those two have had with each other since who knows when. Yori in the short time the MCP's group seven lockdown was in progress, was acting more or less like a drone, and didn't recognize Tron until he gave her an extra shake. And we know how long Kevin has been trapped in the Grid, which means it's been roughly 1K years for Tron too, so even without rectification, Tron's mind would be in a pretty dark place after all that time.

One of two things clicked for Tron's at that moment. I can't really be sure of the first one or not because of the black visor, but it's my feeling the Kevin and Tron made eye contact. Second, which is easier to figure, is Tron heard Kevin say "What have you become?"

Either way, that could be the first time in centuries that Tron knew Flynn was even alive anymore. So even more than realizing your friend is still around, its realizing your god is still around. Just imagine what that kind of realization would feel like for someone who has been a slave for untold eons.

thanks for the perspective Tron Fanatic where to buy abortion pill ordering abortion pills to be shipped to house buy abortion pill online

I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.

 
Kat
User

Posts: 2,394
RE: tron's redemption

on Saturday, April, 23, 2011 11:29 AM
Tron Fanatic Wrote:
rimwall Wrote:i agreee TronFanatic. i have to ask tho:

what's your interpretation?
why does tron's redemption scene bother some people?

i've seen the discussions on some of the movie blogs. and i've seen
some posts here in tron sector.

I'm really not sure what is bothering some people about it. I think more of it pertains to him being left to rot in the water (with not so much as an indication of whether or not he survived), moreso than how he 'turned back to the light side.'

I think there were two possibilities, both of which directly relate to contact with Kevin. I'd have to check again to make sure, but I'm pretty sure the moment that Flynn looks up at him from inside the light jet is the first contact those two have had with each other since who knows when. Yori in the short time the MCP's group seven lockdown was in progress, was acting more or less like a drone, and didn't recognize Tron until he gave her an extra shake. And we know how long Kevin has been trapped in the Grid, which means it's been roughly 1K years for Tron too, so even without rectification, Tron's mind would be in a pretty dark place after all that time.

One of two things clicked for Tron's at that moment. I can't really be sure of the first one or not because of the black visor, but it's my feeling the Kevin and Tron made eye contact. Second, which is easier to figure, is Tron heard Kevin say "What have you become?"

Either way, that could be the first time in centuries that Tron knew Flynn was even alive anymore. So even more than realizing your friend is still around, its realizing your god is still around. Just imagine what that kind of realization would feel like for someone who has been a slave for untold eons.
This. I assumed they looked each other in the eye, and Tronzler either read his lips or heard him or both. I dunno. I deal with it in a Rinzler story I'm writing, but it's not quite done yet so I don't want to give too much away (I've gotta watch the movie again to make sure I've got stuff right). But after seeing the movie twice, I still assume that's precisely what happened and honestly, anything else didn't even occur to me. After all, Rinz pulls up after he sees Flynn, which is before Clu says "take the shot" (him backing off is what *prompts* that line from Clu). Throughout that whole scene, he is just as close to killing them as any other moment, and it's not until he actually looks into Flynn's eyes that he thinks twice about it. He has just seen the first concrete thing from who he used to be--after all, Clu has both changed his name and made it so he can't see what he looks like

What do you want? I'm busy.


Program, please!


Chaos.... good news.
 
rimwall
User

Posts: 507
RE: tron's redemption

on Saturday, April, 23, 2011 2:50 PM
thanks for the input Kat order abortion pill abortion pill buy online where to buy abortion pillabortion pills online abortion pill online purchase cytotec abortion

I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.

 
rimwall
User

Posts: 507
RE: tron's redemption

on Saturday, April, 23, 2011 2:52 PM
sorry guys i forgot to post this earlier

the sequence of events is:

rinzler lines up his shots to hit and disable the
weapons (this was deliberate since the engine is the
bigger target and rinzler never aimed for the engine)

rinzler speeds up then flips around and checks out his
disabled opponents. he sees flynn.

rinzler then falls back to take aim for his kill shot
this is the only time he hears the words inside his head "flynn go!"
then rinzler shakes his head.



next





clu activates his turbo
then wide camera shot of clu
clu seeing that rinzler is lined up for a perfect kill shot
on a defenseless opponent
clu: rinzler take the shot!

still rinzler hesitates
camera shows a closer view of clu
clu: finish the game!
rinzler looks back at clu

then rinzler decides to pull up

sam stares at tron's climbing lightjet.



extra note:
regarding rinzler lining up his shots, the movie
shows it more clearly as rinzler fires into the air
then leads the shots to his intended target and disarm
the weapons.

it appears to be a rinzler's trademark move.
disarm an opponent before killing them.
he did the same thing to sam in disk wars.

i suppose its some deep ingrained habit from the
betrayal comics when the game was not about killing.
order abortion pill abortion pill buy online where to buy abortion pillwhere to buy abortion pill ordering abortion pills to be shipped to house buy abortion pill online

I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.

 
rimwall
User

Posts: 507
RE: tron's redemption

on Saturday, April, 23, 2011 3:02 PM
forgot again

have a nice easter everyone in tron sector

I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.

 
Kat
User

Posts: 2,394
RE: tron's redemption

on Saturday, April, 23, 2011 4:17 PM
rimwall Wrote:sorry guys i forgot to post this earlier

the sequence of events is:

rinzler lines up his shots to hit and disable the
weapons (this was deliberate since the engine is the
bigger target and rinzler never aimed for the engine)

rinzler speeds up then flips around and checks out his
disabled opponents. he sees flynn.

rinzler then falls back to take aim for his kill shot
this is the only time he hears the words inside his head "flynn go!"
then rinzler shakes his head.



next





clu activates his turbo
then wide camera shot of clu
clu seeing that rinzler is lined up for a perfect kill shot
on a defenseless opponent
clu: rinzler take the shot!

still rinzler hesitates
camera shows a closer view of clu
clu: finish the game!
rinzler looks back at clu

then rinzler decides to pull up

sam stares at tron's climbing lightjet.



extra note:
regarding rinzler lining up his shots, the movie
shows it more clearly as rinzler fires into the air
then leads the shots to his intended target and disarm
the weapons.

it appears to be a rinzler's trademark move.
disarm an opponent before killing them.
he did the same thing to sam in disk wars.

i suppose its some deep ingrained habit from the
betrayal comics when the game was not about killing.

I had always assumed he pulled back in behind the 3-man jet to block it from Clu, NOT to continue the attack...hence why Clu is back there wondering why Rinz doesn't just pull the trigger already, because he doesn't know the motive... the Clu tells him to take the shot, and Tronzler decides what to do and then pulls up and attacks Clu...


What do you want? I'm busy.


Program, please!


Chaos.... good news.
 
IluthraDanar
User

Posts: 1,178
RE: tron's redemption

on Saturday, April, 23, 2011 8:43 PM
After so many cycles of having no contact with Flynn, Rinzler/Tron meets his son, visits his home and sees him live and in person. Must have been a shock to his system even in the smallest way.order abortion pill abortion pill buy online where to buy abortion pill


Forget it, Mr High and Mighty Master Control. You aren't making me talk.


 
Mayorcan
User

Posts: 188
RE: tron's redemption

on Saturday, April, 23, 2011 10:17 PM
IluthraDanar Wrote:After so many cycles of having no contact with Flynn, Rinzler/Tron meets his son, visits his home and sees him live and in person. Must have been a shock to his system even in the smallest way.

This succinctly gets it. Rinzler was regressing back to Tron the minute he realizes Combatant 3 is a "User". Finally seeing Flynn face to face sealed the deal and allowed him to make sense of the conflict that had been brewing inside him. Naturally, he swiftly swooped to Sam, Quorra, and Flynn's defense near the end of the film.

Why use Norton AV or AVG to protect your computer when you could be using TRON instead!?
 
rimwall
User

Posts: 507
RE: tron's redemption

on Saturday, April, 23, 2011 11:22 PM
Kat Wrote:
I had always assumed he pulled back in behind the 3-man jet to block it from Clu, NOT to continue the attack...hence why Clu is back there wondering why Rinz doesn't just pull the trigger already, because he doesn't know the motive... the Clu tells him to take the shot, and Tronzler decides what to do and then pulls up and attacks Clu...


i think the sequence was-

when rinzler positioned his plane for the kill shot
we can see that clu was not yet at the scene.
(empty sky behind rinzler)

we can see its a full six seconds of perfect kill time.

(sorry kat - time is not accurate with the animated gifs
i had to decimate 1 frame for every 3 frames
to keep the gif sizes down. so the entire scene appears shorter)

clu appears right after rinzler hears the words in
his head "flynn run!"

in the first animated gif
we can see clu appearing after rinzler's headshake
clu's plane appears at the top of the screen. (but clu is still way behind)

then clu activates his turbo/afterburners to catch up
with the action

I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.

 
rimwall
User

Posts: 507
RE: tron's redemption

on Sunday, April, 24, 2011 3:28 AM
IluthraDanar Wrote:After so many cycles of having no contact with Flynn, Rinzler/Tron meets his son, visits his home and sees him live and in person. Must have been a shock to his system even in the smallest way.

sorry IluthraDanar i have nothing when it comes to whats going
on in rinzler's head the moment he spotted kevin.
we could however observe rinzler's actions.

we could say that from the moment rinzler was in
the perfect kill position -
that was when he heard the tron voice.

we could say this:

we know rinzler saw flynn
we know that in preparation for his kill shot- rinzler knew he was going to kill flynn
we know that a fraction of a second before a shot was ever made
rinzler heard a voice in his head

that's why we put the terminator trope as analogy:

the moment rinzler hears trons voice in his head-
he had two codes running at the same time - rinzler's code and tron

we could note that the director gave us a visual cue of what a full tron persona
should look like (the colors change from red to blue)

i guess we could say that when he rammed clu-
it was still as rinzler/tron dual-persona. (he was still sporting red colors)

it is probably why we hear the struggle in his voice when he said
"i...fight...for the users"

(in terms of visual cues) he is still not fully tron when he rammed clu.



side note:
it's something to think about tho. in terms of visualization
(since the director had an architectural background)
why depict tron struggling to assert himself but still
show the red uniform light when hitting clu.



I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.

 
Kat
User

Posts: 2,394
RE: tron's redemption

on Sunday, April, 24, 2011 7:18 AM
Now I'm wondering what the writers really intended. They obviously didn't make it clear if everybody is taking that scene a different way. I thought the "Flynn, go" was what Rinzler SAID, not that it was in his head...

What do you want? I'm busy.


Program, please!


Chaos.... good news.
 
rimwall
User

Posts: 507
RE: tron's redemption

on Sunday, April, 24, 2011 9:20 AM
the "flynn go!" was word for word and tone for tone
exact of the flashback from clu's coup. the head thing
just had a more distinct echo.

strange coincidence you should mention the writers Kat.

i was re-reading all the post by everyone
on the thread. and i was wondering whether
the scene itself was designed to be ambiguous.

using visual cues for rinzler then using
verbal cues for tron - then in-between
use action cues interchangeably between the
two - then at the end use a visual cue for tron.

take the ramming clu portion - the uniforms
says visual cue rinzler but the verbal cue
and resulting action says tron

take the portion where rinzler's jet climbs straight up
we might think that its tron finally dis-engaging
from the killing position. but the resulting
action results in clu taking a shot at the flynns

hmmm. now that i've been able to verbalize it-
i'm beginning to wonder if mixing cues is
a good idea.
order abortion pill http://unclejohnsprojects.com/template/default.aspx?morning-after-pill-price where to buy abortion pill

I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.

 
rimwall
User

Posts: 507
RE: tron's redemption

on Sunday, April, 24, 2011 9:45 AM
i'm going to post this, before i loose this train of thought.
nothing in particular just thinking out loud.


from the perfect killshot to the time clu yells "take the shot!"
its about nine seconds.

in that entire nine seconds - who is behind flynn's jet?
is it rinzler or is it tron?

if it is rinzler, why hasn't he fired?

if it is tron, why hasn't he looped back to attack clu?
--clu is way back behind and even had to turn on afterburners to catch up.
--if tron is acting as flynn's escort - it's not wise to let clu get close.


for a baseline of rinzler's response times:
we should note that in firing the dis-arming shots
rinzler takes just under a second to fire in response to sam's
first initial volley.

(rinzler has fast response times when set on a course of action.
it's the reason why rinzler's hesitation is so painfully noticeable
to clu)

extra note little off-topic:
by the way there is something consistently weird
in the way rinzler fights sam after the disk wars:

their first fight in disk wars- rinzler made the first shot

but the encounters in the carrier and in the dogfight
rinzler waited for sam to make the first shot.
(just found it weird is all)


I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.

 
rimwall
User

Posts: 507
RE: tron's redemption

on Sunday, April, 24, 2011 11:51 AM
rimwall Wrote:the "flynn go!" was word for word and tone for tone
exact of the flashback from clu's coup. the head thing
just had a more distinct echo.

additional:
the echo is standard audio cue (echoes from the past)

here is a minor inconsistency:
during flynn's flashback they did not use echoes for the
voices

i only consider it minor because the blurry video edges makes
it distincly a flashback.
as a matter of fact i remember it as having an echo. so my mind
must have supplied the echo because that's what i expect a flashback
to sound like.

it's weird that the mind does that. but it emphasizes the importance
of standards.

we expect flashbacks to look and sound a certain way.

(in the case of rinzler ) we expect persons who hears voices
in their head to look and act a certain way.

and the standards were set by the previous movies or tv shows that we
have seen.




I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.

 
 Page: of 2 PagesNextLast
New New Comments | Post No Change | Locked Closed
Forums 
 TRON: LEGACY 
 tron's redemption