Forums (I/O Tower)
Forums 
  General Discussion 
 Problems with original TRON Blu-Ray?


New New Comments | Post No Change | Locked Closed
AuthorComments:  Page: of 2 PagesNextLast
Byteman
User

Posts: 83
Problems with original TRON Blu-Ray?

on Wednesday, April, 06, 2011 11:57 AM
After watching the blu-ray of the original TRON, I was left with mixed feelings. I liked the updated colors, and there seemed to be a few seconds worth of material I never saw before. However, I feel that maybe the original TRON works best at standard definition.

In the computer world, there seems to be a massive amounts of flickering and harsh edges around the suit lights throughout the whole movie.

During the scene where Ram and Chrom meet, right before they transition to "meanwhile in the real world" where Flynn is directing Clu. There is massive amounts of artifacts around Ram's helmet Also, there is one instance of his helmet "tearing" apart in this scene.

During the closeups of Sark's face, you can actually see the frames shifting color slightly. Like they had to do some copy and pasting from other reels. Around the Jai-alai (scoop-ball game) scene, when Sark is remembering the MCP saying "I want him in the games until he dies playing".

During some screen pans, there is a lot of choppiness. One of them involved Alan. I think it was around the popcorn scene, where he's putting on his jacket to go meet Dillinger.

I'm watching on a LG 32LH30 32" 1080p 60hz set, the disc is played through a fully updated Slim PS3.

My disc is from THE ULTIMATE TRON EXPERIENCE box set, the one with the light-up disc display.

Can anyone else confirm or deny these visual issues?
Can anyone compare and contrast with the DVD version?
Or other non-ultimate box set Blu rays of the original TRON?

If you have a 120hz set or greater, please compare with the "motion-flow" or whatever turned on and off.

Thanks.


 
TRON.dll
User

Posts: 4,349
RE: Problems with original TRON Blu-Ray?

on Wednesday, April, 06, 2011 12:49 PM
I have the DVD version. I watched two scenes (introduction and Tron's disc arena match) and at first glance there appeared to be some improvement, but I'm yet to compare it with the 20th Anniversary DVD or watch the full movie.

I did not notice any major issues that were not present in the original film.


TRON 2.0 (PC) name - TRON.dll
I'll play any mode, but I'm best at LC.



PSN - TRON-dll
XBOX Live/Games for Windows Live - TRONdll
-I have a Wii, DS, and 3DS. PM me to exchange friend codes.
 
Byteman
User

Posts: 83
RE: Problems with original TRON Blu-Ray?

on Wednesday, April, 06, 2011 1:04 PM
User897 Wrote:It could be because your PS3 is outputting 720p.

I'll double-check, but I'm sure it was outputting 1080p.
Even if that were the problem, that wouldn't account for the color shifting or the helmet tearing.where to buy abortion pill ordering abortion pills to be shipped to house buy abortion pill online


 
allen 1
User

Posts: 55
RE: Problems with original TRON Blu-Ray?

on Wednesday, April, 06, 2011 2:44 PM
huh interseting i watched the regular dvd one and it had the most beautiful sound and quality but i did notice one instat of what looked like z fighting but it was breiforder abortion pill morning after pill price where to buy abortion pill







 
MCPcomputer
User

Posts: 1,945
RE: Problems with original TRON Blu-Ray?

on Wednesday, April, 06, 2011 3:54 PM

I haven't seen the Blu Ray yet...
But I watched the original tron on DVD..
and it looks great!
The sound was awesome as well! abortion pills online abortion pill online purchase cytotec abortion

"I want him in the games until he dies playing" -MCP
The Grid a Physical Frontier funny Tron Videohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xaMViP_QtZ8
 
Logansneo
User

Posts: 106
RE: Problems with original TRON Blu-Ray?

on Wednesday, April, 06, 2011 4:08 PM
Perspective....the special effects for TRON are in the caveman-era of CGI so tearing, flicker, aliasing, color shifting, have all been left in the film to present it as accurately to it's original theatrical presentation as possible. That said I also noticed these artifacts and have come to accept that without a complete overhaul of the original special effects (ala George Lucas) they will remain this way, as they should! This isn't a defect of the blu-ray edition, it's the way it originally looked in theaters 29 years ago! If it's not your cup of tea or you are unable to appreciate the STUNNING leap in clarity and consistency that the original TRON blu-ray represents, by all means, enjoy the DVD! where to buy abortion pill abortion types buy abortion pill onlineabortion pills online abortion pill online purchase cytotec abortion


 
BrokenLevel
User

Posts: 36
RE: Problems with original TRON Blu-Ray?

on Wednesday, April, 06, 2011 10:07 PM
Pretty much what Logansneo said.

But, my beef lies more with their 'color correction' choices.

http://tinyurl.com/3mnoswu

http://tinyurl.com/3ffs9uu

http://tinyurl.com/4xfqoch

and http://tinyurl.com/3fvax7w vs. http://tinyurl.com/4x9uh6w [lol yeah not shooping them together /laze]

what is this i don't even---

Sark's torture scene going through the grimdark filter looks really great [because really, who can say no to high-octane nightmare fuel?] - even if it kinda serves to highlight one of David Warner's flat acting spats.

But the MCP and Sark going out in a sea of super-bright 'tee-hee let's connect it more to legacy, aesthetically!' sparkle white lens-flair uguu? Notsomuch, in my humble opinion.

And furthering my bawwwing over the 'color correction', in the DVD anyway whoops i have been outed, the circuitry detail has actually lost much of the clarity that it had in the 20th Anniversary release. In many frames that were once pretty darn clear and detailed in the meticulous and beautiful circuitry department, the circuits are now meshed together into a blurry technicolor mass of ohgodwhy.abortion pills online abortion questions cytotec abortion


 
gkarris
User

Posts: 393
RE: Problems with original TRON Blu-Ray?

on Wednesday, April, 06, 2011 11:07 PM
Was it restored or simply re-mastered (there is a difference)?

From what was said in the "Making of Tron" (on the 20th Anniversary Ed.) - they at first took the film cells out of sequence (the boxes were numbered), and doing this made the exposures inconsistent and the "flickering" we say. They did some cool stuff to work it in the film...

Maybe the HD version emphasizes it?

Have yet to watch my BR copy...where to buy abortion pill http://blog.bitimpulse.com/template/default.aspx?abortion-types buy abortion pill onlineabortion pills online abortion questions cytotec abortion


 
Logansneo
User

Posts: 106
RE: Problems with original TRON Blu-Ray?

on Thursday, April, 07, 2011 2:47 AM
BrokenLevel Wrote:
Sark's torture scene going through the grimdark filter looks really great [because really, who can say no to high-octane nightmare fuel?] - even if it kinda serves to highlight one of David Warner's flat acting spats.

But the MCP and Sark going out in a sea of super-bright 'tee-hee let's connect it more to legacy, aesthetically!' sparkle white lens-flair uguu? Notsomuch, in my humble opinion.

And furthering my bawwwing over the 'color correction', in the DVD anyway whoops i have been outed, the circuitry detail has actually lost much of the clarity that it had in the 20th Anniversary release. In many frames that were once pretty darn clear and detailed in the meticulous and beautiful circuitry department, the circuits are now meshed together into a blurry technicolor mass of ohgodwhy.

Yeah, I see what you mean about the Sark/MCP torture shots and did notice a bit of a darker image in those shots, not exactly sure why but I would have to agree they appear pretty darn dark. As for the circuitry detail and other general detail it does appear that this "DVD" edition is somewhat softer than it's 20th anniversary predecessor, and my only guess as to why that may be is probably because the DVD version was less of a priority as far as pushing the format's boundaries compared with their goals for the Blu-Ray version.

And in regards to the shots on the mesa of Tron fighting Sark in all honesty i'd say that I prefer the newer version because it IS considerably more consistent throughout in color and tones. I did like that sepia-like tonality of the MCP derezzing but again it appears more consistent with the rest of the films color palette now.

Oh, and thanks for all your work on those great comparison shots! If I'm able to capture some HD shots of these scenes I'll be sure to post them later.



 
typicaltronname
User

Posts: 1,667
RE: Problems with original TRON Blu-Ray?

on Thursday, April, 07, 2011 2:52 AM
User897 Wrote:Christ. It's the Star Wars tampering all over again, although NOBODY could screw something up as bad as Star Wars.


Oh man, don't tell me they made Hayden Christensen into Tron....


"Reveal your creation date or I will disassemble your code one operation at a time!"
 
FusionAddict
User

Posts: 450
RE: Problems with original TRON Blu-Ray?

on Thursday, April, 07, 2011 7:31 AM
This was a high-quality, deep restoration, not a remaster. A lot of dust & scratches were removed and the color was re-graded.

The reason the color difference is so dramatic are twofold:

1) Lisberger never had the time to properly adjust the color because of the impending release date. That means a lot of the colors have actually been incorrect the entire time.

2) Celluloid film, even properly stored, degrades over time, eventually dissolving into vinegar. One of the first stages of this degradation is a yellow tint. As you can see in the above screenshots, the closeups of the costumes show a yellow tint because the film was starting to dissolve.

There was no money for a full restoration for the 20th Anniversary release, so that DVD was basically a high-quality transfer from a flawed master. This is the movie as Lisberger originally intended. The difference between this and the Star Wars Specials Editions is that, with a few exceptions, Lucas didn't add anything that he had originally intended to shoot, he was simply assembling what amounted to a tech demo. Lisberger was hamstrung by the impending release date and lack of budget to do proper color timing, which is usually a standard postproduction procedure for live-action films, while animated films rarely require it.

I have heard a few people complain about the amount of grain in the film, but keep in mind this movie was shot ON FILM. The picture has -- and should have -- visible, natural noise due to the celluloid grain, because Blu-Ray is intended to replicate the theatrical experience. The fact that this grain is present and that there is so little digital artifacting should be cause for celebration, especially when the tendency is for studios to polish all of the grain from films. For an excellent example, take a look at Fox's PREDATOR Blu-Ray, as examined by The Digital Bits:

http://www.thedigitalbits.com/mytwocentsa181.html#063010babortion pills online http://www.kvicksundscupen.se/template/default.aspx?abortion-questions cytotec abortion

The Clu abides, man...

 
binaryzero
User

Posts: 136
RE: Problems with original TRON Blu-Ray?

on Thursday, April, 07, 2011 8:15 AM
or to further the grain arguement, look at how the original was made.

exposure on top of exposure, etc. the grain is high in the original film with the amount of optical printing had to be done.
think of how noisy a picture would be if you printed it, scanned it, printed it, scanned it, etc.

it's all there in the theatrical presentation, just you forget how projection and screens soften the image. add to that a lifetime of watching it in 'dirty' standard def transfers.
now you're getting 6 times the resolution and zero softness from your tv.where to buy abortion pill http://blog.bitimpulse.com/template/default.aspx?abortion-types buy abortion pill online


 
trench
User

Posts: 136
RE: Problems with original TRON Blu-Ray?

on Thursday, April, 07, 2011 10:05 AM
binaryzero Wrote:or to further the grain arguement, look at how the original was made.

exposure on top of exposure, etc. the grain is high in the original film with the amount of optical printing had to be done.
think of how noisy a picture would be if you printed it, scanned it, printed it, scanned it, etc.

Yeah, I think some of the scenes in Tron were composites of like 20 images...order abortion pill http://unclejohnsprojects.com/template/default.aspx?morning-after-pill-price where to buy abortion pillabortion pills online abortion pill online purchase cytotec abortion


 
binaryzero
User

Posts: 136
RE: Problems with original TRON Blu-Ray?

on Thursday, April, 07, 2011 8:39 PM
trench Wrote:
Yeah, I think some of the scenes in Tron were composites of like 20 images...

i'm trying to simplify alot of my points because i could get rather technical on home formats over the years with regards to color spaces and resolution.

for example one of those matte line hiccups in the film.

let's say it was 3 pixels wide on the bluray.
on the dvd it would be a 1/2 pixel in size and therefore pretty much invisible.

that's what spurred the original special edition for star wars. due to the light loss from theater projection you could see the matte lines around the starship models in the space scenes. once the film dropped on tv and vhs, all of that suddenly became blatantly visible and lucas felt they needed to be fixed. obviously that ability to fix things got out of control, but you can see how it started.

outside of the i think 3 scenes heavily retimed, we're getting the actual fim warts and all.
so i guess the question is: would customers be happier if they pulled a lucas and fixed all the matte lines and hiccups or a more faithful blu-ray with all the errors present?

where to buy abortion pill http://blog.bitimpulse.com/template/default.aspx?abortion-types buy abortion pill online


 
JInfantry23
User

Posts: 99
RE: Problems with original TRON Blu-Ray?

on Thursday, April, 07, 2011 11:03 PM
Over all? I found the Tron: Classic blu ray to be done pretty well. I did notice some upgrades (Is it just me, or were the guards staffs more "sparkly" and Clu seemed more in color tone with his succesor?) but basically? I liked it! Well worth getting IMHOwhere to buy abortion pill ordering abortion pills to be shipped to house buy abortion pill online


 
Logansneo
User

Posts: 106
RE: Problems with original TRON Blu-Ray?

on Friday, April, 08, 2011 2:53 AM
JInfantry23 Wrote:Over all? I found the Tron: Classic blu ray to be done pretty well. I did notice some upgrades (Is it just me, or were the guards staffs more "sparkly" and Clu seemed more in color tone with his succesor?) but basically? I liked it! Well worth getting IMHO


If your speaking about Clu when he's being questioned/tortured by the MCP, I remember him always having an orange-ish hue to his circuits, as opposed to him inside of the Tank.

As far as Lucas and the reasoning behind returning to older films to "fix" problems with them, the real question that arises is where do they stop? Gee, I think those tearing polygons in the background look horrible, but now the light cycles look dated. Now that we've fixed the flickering on Sark's cruiser maybe we should add a subtle texture map to it, and so on.... I believe that Lucas started from a similar standpoint with the original Star Wars trilogy and as was stated above, went nuts!! IMHO this blu-ray is a solid representation of exactly what the director intended audiences to see when this film was released. In it's own way it is a time capsule preserving TRON by properly representing the original achievements of the artists, designers, and everyone else involved without dishonoring their creation in the selfish way Lucas has done with Star Wars!on line abortion pill misoprostol dose abortion medical abortion pill onlineorder abortion pill morning after pill price where to buy abortion pillwhere to buy abortion pill abortion types buy abortion pill online


 
FusionAddict
User

Posts: 450
RE: Problems with original TRON Blu-Ray?

on Friday, April, 08, 2011 3:10 PM
In addition, it should be noted that, as I stated, the original negative for the film will not last forever, even under the best of circumstances. This new digital transfer is a way to guarantee that the film can be shown in master quality and will survive, as it was supposed to appear, forever.

The Clu abides, man...

 
typicaltronname
User

Posts: 1,667
RE: Problems with original TRON Blu-Ray?

on Friday, April, 08, 2011 3:23 PM
FusionAddict Wrote:.

2) Celluloid film, even properly stored, degrades over time, eventually dissolving into vinegar.

What type of vinegar? White? Apple cider Vinegar? Balsamic? Malt? Coconut?
on line abortion pill misoprostol dose abortion medical abortion pill onlinewhere to buy abortion pill abortion types buy abortion pill online

"Reveal your creation date or I will disassemble your code one operation at a time!"
 
FusionAddict
User

Posts: 450
RE: Problems with original TRON Blu-Ray?

on Friday, April, 08, 2011 3:27 PM
typicaltronname Wrote:
FusionAddict Wrote:.

2) Celluloid film, even properly stored, degrades over time, eventually dissolving into vinegar.

What type of vinegar? White? Apple cider Vinegar? Balsamic? Malt? Coconut?

http://www.film-to-video.com/warning.htmlwhere to buy abortion pill http://blog.bitimpulse.com/template/default.aspx?abortion-types buy abortion pill onlineabortion pills online abortion questions cytotec abortion

The Clu abides, man...

 
typicaltronname
User

Posts: 1,667
RE: Problems with original TRON Blu-Ray?

on Friday, April, 08, 2011 3:38 PM
FusionAddict Wrote:
typicaltronname Wrote:
FusionAddict Wrote:.

2) Celluloid film, even properly stored, degrades over time, eventually dissolving into vinegar.

What type of vinegar? White? Apple cider Vinegar? Balsamic? Malt? Coconut?

http://www.film-to-video.com/warning.html

Huh! That's really interesting.

I wonder if VHS tapes have this problem. It seems unlikely, though.


"Reveal your creation date or I will disassemble your code one operation at a time!"
 
 Page: of 2 PagesNextLast
New New Comments | Post No Change | Locked Closed
Forums 
  General Discussion 
 Problems with original TRON Blu-Ray?