Kat User
Posts: 2,394 | Was Sam right or wrong? on Saturday, March, 05, 2011 10:47 PM
So Sam decides his dad's being too slow and wishy-washy and decides to take matters into his own hands and goes to look for Zuse.
What do you think, programs? Was he right or wrong? The elevator scene seems to imply he screwed up big-time (at least in Flynn's eyes and his own, though perhaps that is resolved later when it sorta turns out okay)...I'm not so sure. I think Flynn would've sat there doing nothing forever--now with Sam trapped with him--if Sam hadn't acted, but maybe not.
Do you think he should've waited for his dad to move? What do you think might've happened if he had? (I know, this is starting to sound like a grade-school discussion question. Just roll with it, okay?)
What do you want? I'm busy.
Program, please!
Chaos.... good news. |
IluthraDanar User
Posts: 1,178 | RE: Was Sam right or wrong? on Saturday, March, 05, 2011 11:18 PM
Flynn wanted to wait for the resistance to take out Clu but they seemed unempowered to do so. Yet when Flynn entered the EOL club, he seemed to give them the ability to fight and win against the Black Guard. So why didn't he help them with the efforts to take back the Grid?where to buy abortion pill http://blog.bitimpulse.com/template/default.aspx?abortion-types buy abortion pill online
Forget it, Mr High and Mighty Master Control. You aren't making me talk.
|
doctorclu User
Posts: 206 | RE: Was Sam right or wrong? on Sunday, March, 06, 2011 12:23 AM
Weird to think a few lines of code from our side of the screen could be causing so much havoc to the other programs in your computer.
They had to move. The portal was eventually going to close.
I think a compromise would have worked. I believe they would have had time to sleep, get up, talk about it some more, and as a group take the grid runner into the city. Maybe work on the fringes of the city while the resistance is going on.
------------------
Overall, things went so poorly because of Castor I believe. Apparently he changed a LOT from the time Quorra knew him. He stalled Sam, got him into the fight, and in the end, got Kevin's disc, which he hands to Clu.
Had Sam not tried to trust Castor, he might have had greater freedom of movement to get to the portal.where to buy abortion pill ordering abortion pills to be shipped to house buy abortion pill online
|
IluthraDanar User
Posts: 1,178 | RE: Was Sam right or wrong? on Sunday, March, 06, 2011 12:54 AM
Makes me wonder why Castor changed his mind too. As much as Clu hated Users, he seemed to as well. Most people hate someone who has done something to them, or at least thinks they have.
And how did Clu manage to sway the general populace against Users?
Forget it, Mr High and Mighty Master Control. You aren't making me talk.
|
ShadowSpark User
Posts: 2,943 | RE: Was Sam right or wrong? on Sunday, March, 06, 2011 1:06 AM
IluthraDanar Wrote:And how did Clu manage to sway the general populace against Users? |
Tron Evolution answers that question. When you're playing as Anon, and you have to win the tournament, Clu's voice is in the background and he says: "....The truth is that Flynn is in no position to say what an ISO would or wouldn't do. I'm very sorry to tell you this, but Kevin Flynn has left the grid. Disheartening, I know, but worry not. I will protect us from this simmering ISO menace. At this very moment, steps are being taken...."
---
As for whether Sam was right to leave the safe house, well, if I had been in Sam's place, I would have listened to Flynn. I would have gone to find and fight with the resistance, helped bring Clu down from the inside, then I would've paged Alan and had him come open the portal again so we could all get out. But that would have made a boring movie; the way it happened was much more interesting.
{A very big thanks to FlynnOne for the pic! And to Wulfeous for sharpening the details!*huggles both*}
{Because people always seem to guess wrong, I'm saying it here: I'm female!!! And my name is Spark!!!}
Tron Lives!
Please click here to help my family out. |
cool83 User
Posts: 411 | RE: Was Sam right or wrong? on Sunday, March, 06, 2011 2:10 AM
Sam was right. Flynn forgot how to fight. Remember this quote, from another favorite movie.
"The dreams of youth, often times, become the regrets of maturity."
Flynn says, "We do it your way."
My nutshell.
|
Tron Fanatic User
Posts: 1,461 | RE: Was Sam right or wrong? on Sunday, March, 06, 2011 2:22 AM
TBH though, if Sam HAD gotten himself stuck in the Grid, you can bet that it would've been enough to raise Alan's eyebrows.
"Hmm... Kevin disappears. I get a page. I send Sam to check it out. Sam disappears. Hmmmmm......."
And Alan obviously would've been able to recognize the Shiva laser for what it was, and wouldn't have made the same mistake Sam did in zapping himself.
I kinda think there's a good chance that Alan could've gotten them both out one way or another.
'> |
inxthexunblind User
Posts: 58 | RE: Was Sam right or wrong? on Sunday, March, 06, 2011 2:37 AM
Heroics and studity go hand in hand. Sometimes you just gotta take a chance no matter what the consequences. As Kevin Flynn says in the movie "Some things are worth the risk"
|
rimwall User
Posts: 507 | RE: Was Sam right or wrong? on Sunday, March, 06, 2011 2:38 AM
assuming the laser programs are walking talking programs:
the laser system was started by the computer and running programs
it should be theoretically possible for flynn to open the portal again
if he has full control of the grid and the laser programs.
a successful revolt could (in theory) give flynn full control. unless
clu de-rezzes the laser digitization programs out of spite.
i'd say sam made a good decision. making a run for the portal
would not force clu's hand (into de-rezzing the laser programs)
because clu still believes he can stop flynn's run for the portal.
order abortion pill morning after pill price where to buy abortion pill
I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.
|
Tron Fanatic User
Posts: 1,461 | RE: Was Sam right or wrong? on Sunday, March, 06, 2011 3:18 AM
Didn't Flynn say that he designed the laser controls to be inaccessible from inside the Grid, specifically to prevent the possibility of Programs escaping?
'> |
rimwall User
Posts: 507 | RE: Was Sam right or wrong? on Sunday, March, 06, 2011 3:43 AM
well it is a theory
but if we run with the theory we could say:
yep and ordinary programs have to convice the laser programs
to do their laser duties so ordinary programs can get out.
then they would need flynn's master disk
then they would need to go to the presumably "hard to get" portal location.
it's something like a triple lock. well a double lock
if the portal is already open.
flynn's actions in the betrayal comics also shows him
taking risks and flying untested flyers. he constantly
risks getting knocked unconscious during the early
days of the grid.
getting knocked out can take hours. i'd like to think flynn
had a plan B during his early reckless days.
I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.
|
Tron Fanatic User
Posts: 1,461 | RE: Was Sam right or wrong? on Sunday, March, 06, 2011 4:14 AM
rimwall Wrote:well it is a theory
but if we run with the theory we could say:
yep and ordinary programs have to convice the laser programs
to do their laser duties so ordinary programs can get out.
then they would need flynn's master disk
then they would need to go to the presumably "hard to get" portal location.
it's something like a triple lock. well a double lock
if the portal is already open.
flynn's actions in the betrayal comics also shows him
taking risks and flying untested flyers. he constantly
risks getting knocked unconscious during the early
days of the grid.
getting knocked out can take hours. i'd like to think flynn
had a plan B during his early reckless days.
|
Being that this is Kevin we're talking about, inventor of the "most secure OS ever", he would probably realize the danger in allowing Programs to handle the portal. After all the Great Wall of China, the biggest and most impressive barrier ever built by human hands was breached 3 times... and all 3 times were accomplished by bribing the guards.
He could design the laser controls to be hard-wired. Not everything, but the actual switch that allows the portal to open could be entirely hardware-driven, not software, making the meddling of rebellious Programs impossible. '> |
rimwall User
Posts: 507 | RE: Was Sam right or wrong? on Sunday, March, 06, 2011 5:00 AM
let's not forget the programs wishing to get out
would still need to get flynn's disk.
regarding the hard-wiring:
yep flynn can certainly make sure it can only be activated
from the outside. a fourth lock we could call it.
the implications are - strict adherence to the eight hour limit
no reckless test flying of untested vehicles and risk
getting knocked-out, and getting stranded because of
the limiting 8 hour window.
during the early days of the grid (without a plan B)
each trip he makes inside means running
the risk of being stranded
while if flynn had a plan B then no worries
about being knocked out testing flying vehicles
so i guess dealer's choice.
flynn the test pilot trying out new flying vehicles
I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.
|
LadyTron User
Posts: 82 | RE: Was Sam right or wrong? on Sunday, March, 06, 2011 9:07 AM
Hmmmm....interesting. I'm not sure. I think this is more of the youth vs. experience debate. Sam wants to take things into his own hands and is naive about situations (for example, with Castor/Zuse, Sam doesn't have the experience to know that this guy is shady to the 10th degree, especially with the 'look at all the angles' summary quote Sam says when he finds out Castor is unreliable). Kevin is more experienced, but does he take too much time to do things? His move is just not to move at all in order to block Clu. So, in essence, they need each other. Kevin even relents when he tells Sam, "Have you ever jumped a train....we'll do it your way." Also, you think Kevin would be more protective of his identity disc instead of exposing it so blatantly so it could be taken in the "End of Line" club? Kevin maybe had an overinflated sense of confidence at that moment---like father like son?
I don't think it's in terms of right or wrong, just the debate of youth vs. experience and how Sam and Kevin need each other to get to a goal--a yin/yang sort of thing. Not sure if this makes any sense.
"Throw Your Frisbees in the Air!" |
Kat User
Posts: 2,394 | RE: Was Sam right or wrong? on Sunday, March, 06, 2011 10:20 AM
Tron Fanatic Wrote:TBH though, if Sam HAD gotten himself stuck in the Grid, you can bet that it would've been enough to raise Alan's eyebrows.
"Hmm... Kevin disappears. I get a page. I send Sam to check it out. Sam disappears. Hmmmmm......."
And Alan obviously would've been able to recognize the Shiva laser for what it was, and wouldn't have made the same mistake Sam did in zapping himself.
I kinda think there's a good chance that Alan could've gotten them both out one way or another. |
But would Alan find the secret office? Sam only does so by accident (and I thought that part was slightly weak, but I can't think of a better way for it to have happened).
I mean, for all we know, Alan has already given the arcade a good going-over and never found it... (and surely the police must have after Flynn disappeared and if trained investigators, including forensics experts who may've been combing every inch of the place for tiny bits of evidence, didn't figure out there was a trap door, Alan sure may not).
What do you want? I'm busy.
Program, please!
Chaos.... good news. |
rimwall User
Posts: 507 | RE: Was Sam right or wrong? on Sunday, March, 06, 2011 9:37 PM
rimwall Wrote:well it is a theory
but if we run with the theory we could say:
yep and ordinary programs have to convice the laser programs
to do their laser duties so ordinary programs can get out.
then they would need flynn's master disk
then they would need to go to the presumably "hard to get" portal location.
it's something like a triple lock. well a double lock
if the portal is already open.
flynn's actions in the betrayal comics also shows him
taking risks and flying untested flyers. he constantly
risks getting knocked unconscious during the early
days of the grid.
getting knocked out can take hours. i'd like to think flynn
had a plan B during his early reckless days.
|
ooops forgot one
programs also have to figure out how to make the flynn's disk
work for an ordinary program
the master disk works specifically for flynn's user body.
that would make it four locks
and stealing flynn's disk during the early days of the grid
would not be easy because clu, clu's army, and tron
will be hunting down the thief and flynn would still
have the option to monitor when the laser programs
are activated
I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.
|
Imbroglio User
Posts: 416 | RE: Was Sam right or wrong? on Sunday, March, 06, 2011 9:50 PM
Sam caused a lot of innocent programs to be derezzed and additionally the death of Flynn.
If he just waited, all 3 of them could have got out quietly and without a confrontation with Clu.
|
IluthraDanar User
Posts: 1,178 | RE: Was Sam right or wrong? on Sunday, March, 06, 2011 9:59 PM
Imbroglio Wrote:Sam caused a lot of innocent programs to be derezzed and additionally the death of Flynn.
If he just waited, all 3 of them could have got out quietly and without a confrontation with Clu.
|
Speaking of innocent programs, I couldn't help but giggle at the one program who was watching Sam as he scaled the Disk Wars cage, and was then de-rezzed. Pay attention, program!
Forget it, Mr High and Mighty Master Control. You aren't making me talk.
|
TRON.dll User
Posts: 4,349 | RE: Was Sam right or wrong? on Sunday, March, 06, 2011 10:01 PM
Because watching Sam, Kevin, and Quorra wait for an hour and a half would have been the most entertaining movie ever. [/sarcasm]
In all seriousness, I think it was all part of Sam's character. His "we've gotta do this right now" attitude was really enforced by his decision, and he saw the results of that later on.where to buy abortion pill ordering abortion pills to be shipped to house buy abortion pill online
TRON 2.0 (PC) name - TRON.dll
I'll play any mode, but I'm best at LC.
PSN - TRON-dll
XBOX Live/Games for Windows Live - TRONdll
-I have a Wii, DS, and 3DS. PM me to exchange friend codes. |
IluthraDanar User
Posts: 1,178 | RE: Was Sam right or wrong? on Sunday, March, 06, 2011 10:27 PM
TRON.dll Wrote:Because watching Sam, Kevin, and Quorra wait for an hour and a half would have been the most entertaining movie ever. [/sarcasm]
In all seriousness, I think it was all part of Sam's character. His "we've gotta do this right now" attitude was really enforced by his decision, and he saw the results of that later on. |
I took that to be the point of the film. In the beginning, he's rash if with a purpose, has no desire to run ENCOM, and can't even maintain a relationship. From meeting Dad and getting to know something about Flynn, Sam learned some responsibility, wants to be at the reins of ENCOM, and has a naive ISO to take care of. Can't wait to see the new Sam in the next film.
Forget it, Mr High and Mighty Master Control. You aren't making me talk.
|
|