DaveTRON User
Posts: 5,314 | TRON Legacy Soundtrack on Tuesday, December, 07, 2010 2:39 PM
Well first, I paid $3.99 today on Amazon to download the ENTIRE TRON Legacy Soundtrack today. Great price, get it while you can.
Now I knew nothing of Daft Punk prior to the announcement of their doing this soundtrack.
I learned a little about them and have become a fan of some of their music because of it, so I had very high hopes for this soundtrack.
Unfortunately, any life and joy that I find in their other music I feel is completely missing in this soundtrack.
I am 15 songs into a 23 song soundtrack and I feel like I have basically been listening to the same thing for 15 songs.
It's really not at all on par with the Wendy Carlos score, and I am not saying that due to my love of the original. I just feel like something is missing. the spark these two provide in their own works is just not here.
Consider me a disappointed fan after hearing this work.
DaveTRON
|
IsoLine User
Posts: 1,025 | RE: TRON Legacy Soundtrack on Tuesday, December, 07, 2010 2:47 PM
I didn't want to harsh anyones love of DP and the soundtrack as well, but I probably will sit out buying this one. I listened to it when all the links were put up days ago and tried to like it, but its just not sitting well with me. I used to really like DP back in the late 90's but something happened and I just don't hear their music the same way now as I did back then. Sorry fans, with me they are broken. I think someone like Solar Fields would have done a far sight better doing a Tron soundtrack then DP....Just my opinion.
"Word to the Motherboard!" - IsoLine |
BlueTronWarrior Sector Admin
Posts: 609 | RE: TRON Legacy Soundtrack on Tuesday, December, 07, 2010 3:21 PM
I like it!
Listening to "Adagio for Tron" made me sad though. I haven't read any reviews, but I can tell what happens to our beloved hero just by the tone of the song. abortion pills online abortion questions cytotec abortion
|
cirlin User
Posts: 382 | RE: TRON Legacy Soundtrack on Tuesday, December, 07, 2010 3:28 PM
DaveTRON Wrote:Well first, I paid $3.99 today on Amazon to download the ENTIRE TRON Legacy Soundtrack today. Great price, get it while you can.
Now I knew nothing of Daft Punk prior to the announcement of their doing this soundtrack.
I learned a little about them and have become a fan of some of their music because of it, so I had very high hopes for this soundtrack.
Unfortunately, any life and joy that I find in their other music I feel is completely missing in this soundtrack.
I am 15 songs into a 23 song soundtrack and I feel like I have basically been listening to the same thing for 15 songs.
It's really not at all on par with the Wendy Carlos score, and I am not saying that due to my love of the original. I just feel like something is missing. the spark these two provide in their own works is just not here.
Consider me a disappointed fan after hearing this work. |
That's a shame that it's not working for you. Perhaps it will be more satisfying in the context of the movie? When I compare my reaction to the music from just listening vs. seeing and hearing the preview clips or the Tron Night footage, I find that I enjoy the album quite a bit but it works even better with the visuals and sound effects.
I've haven't listened to too much of Daft Punk outside the sountrack, so I can't speak too much about how they use repitition in their other work. However in the OST I found the repeating themes strong enough and varied enough that they didn't bother me. I did always enjoy when they took the familiar themes into new territory though, so perhaps more variety would have been even better.
I'm mostly just glad that the tone of the music is in line with what they produced for the concept trailer. That was our first taste of what was to come, and I really had hoped it would keep that mood. So far, so good
|
Pilgrim1099 User
Posts: 606 | RE: TRON Legacy Soundtrack on Tuesday, December, 07, 2010 3:34 PM
DaveTron,
Well, Daft Punk was trying to do something a bit different using the orchestral set. Actually, a 99 set orchestra, if I'm not mistaken, but mostly relating to violin (or strings, if you will). I read an article on Daft Punk's interview which surprised me in that they were into classical music and the fact they mentioned that anything conventional will last temporarily while instruments such as the violin will always be around.
The soundtrack is designed to set the mood for the movie, not the dance floor at a nightclub .
Now, if you want some hardcore Daft Punk, I'm sure they will be able to get back in the game. Although, I did catch some youtube clips of them with the Phoenix band which was very interesting as a combination. |
DaveTRON User
Posts: 5,314 | RE: TRON Legacy Soundtrack on Tuesday, December, 07, 2010 5:10 PM
Tron Unit Wrote:DaveTRON Wrote:Well first, I paid $3.99 today on Amazon to download the ENTIRE TRON Legacy Soundtrack today. Great price, get it while you can.
Now I knew nothing of Daft Punk prior to the announcement of their doing this soundtrack.
I learned a little about them and have become a fan of some of their music because of it, so I had very high hopes for this soundtrack.
Unfortunately, any life and joy that I find in their other music I feel is completely missing in this soundtrack.
I am 15 songs into a 23 song soundtrack and I feel like I have basically been listening to the same thing for 15 songs.
It's really not at all on par with the Wendy Carlos score, and I am not saying that due to my love of the original. I just feel like something is missing. the spark these two provide in their own works is just not here.
Consider me a disappointed fan after hearing this work. |
If you downloaded the 23 track version then you really didn't listen to the ENTIRE TRON album. Of course, you'll just complain that the other 7 tracks sound just like the other 23 so don't bother.
It's not supposed to Wendy Carlos' score just like Tron Legacy isn't Tron. It's its own thing and not trying to repeat what Wendy had already done.
|
Wow, you didn't get what I said at all.
I wasn't expecting it to be like Wendy's score, I was merely expecting it to be GOOD.
It isn't. It is boring and repetitive.
If there are 7 more tracks, why isn't Amazon selling them? Frankly, if there are 7 better tracks that are not part of the official soundtrack on sale from a legitimate outlet, then Disney/DaftPunk have done fans a huge disservice.
I seriously doubt anything those 7 tracks contain can elevate this tepid piece in my opinion. I just don't think it is a very good soundtrack at all.
order abortion pill http://unclejohnsprojects.com/template/default.aspx?morning-after-pill-price where to buy abortion pill DaveTRON
|
DaveTRON User
Posts: 5,314 | RE: TRON Legacy Soundtrack on Tuesday, December, 07, 2010 5:16 PM
Pilgrim1099 Wrote:DaveTron,
Well, Daft Punk was trying to do something a bit different using the orchestral set. Actually, a 99 set orchestra, if I'm not mistaken, but mostly relating to violin (or strings, if you will). I read an article on Daft Punk's interview which surprised me in that they were into classical music and the fact they mentioned that anything conventional will last temporarily while instruments such as the violin will always be around.
The soundtrack is designed to set the mood for the movie, not the dance floor at a nightclub .
Now, if you want some hardcore Daft Punk, I'm sure they will be able to get back in the game. Although, I did catch some youtube clips of them with the Phoenix band which was very interesting as a combination. |
Again, I wasn't expecting their pop stuff, I knew that this would differ from their previous work, but there is a spark, a joy, a power in their music that I just feel is missing in this music.
This is lifeless, repetitive and boring. The previous note I responded to touched on the comparison to the original movie's soundtrack.
While I do not make a habit of listening to soundtracks, for TRON I did, and I really liked what Wendy Carlos did. There is a variation in each track, a pallette that she worked from to create variants in mood and texture.
Again, I was not expecting this to be the same as her sound track at all, but I do sort of expect some highs and lows, and they are not there. It stays in a medium band and never veers too far off of that.
I just expected something more exciting from the dynamic duo and I didn't get it.
I am very glad others are enjoying it, and I hope I am in a minority, but I don't think I will be in the long run.
DaveTRON
|
IsoLine User
Posts: 1,025 | RE: TRON Legacy Soundtrack on Tuesday, December, 07, 2010 5:21 PM
Hey Dave....To me the score felt very Zimmerish, if you understand me. I knew it would be orchestral and all, but it sounds very neoclassical in terms of current soundtracks and like you described.
"Word to the Motherboard!" - IsoLine |
DaveTRON User
Posts: 5,314 | RE: TRON Legacy Soundtrack on Tuesday, December, 07, 2010 5:27 PM
IsoLine Wrote:Hey Dave....To me the score felt very Zimmerish, if you understand me. I knew it would be orchestral and all, but it sounds very neoclassical in terms of current soundtracks and like you described. |
I getcha. I am glad I am not completely alone in my view.
Remember people, it's just one opinion, and I am allowed to have my own apart from the group, just as you are yours, so please avoid telling me I am wrong and just share your own opinions and discuss instead.order abortion pill abortion pill buy online where to buy abortion pillwhere to buy abortion pill abortion types buy abortion pill online DaveTRON
|
Imbroglio User
Posts: 416 | RE: TRON Legacy Soundtrack on Tuesday, December, 07, 2010 5:27 PM
DaveTRON Wrote:Well first, I paid $3.99 today on Amazon to download the ENTIRE TRON Legacy Soundtrack today. Great price, get it while you can.
Now I knew nothing of Daft Punk prior to the announcement of their doing this soundtrack.
I learned a little about them and have become a fan of some of their music because of it, so I had very high hopes for this soundtrack.
Unfortunately, any life and joy that I find in their other music I feel is completely missing in this soundtrack.
I am 15 songs into a 23 song soundtrack and I feel like I have basically been listening to the same thing for 15 songs.
It's really not at all on par with the Wendy Carlos score, and I am not saying that due to my love of the original. I just feel like something is missing. the spark these two provide in their own works is just not here.
Consider me a disappointed fan after hearing this work. |
Uh oh. You will be chastised very shortly by the rabid dp defender tag team.
The repetitiveness is the same issue I was having early on with DP doing the entire soundtrack. They are a techno/rave group that lives off of heavy bass line, repeating samples and the thing that you mention might be missing is DEPTH. It is a far cry from a band like Toto's work on the Dune soundtrack or Danny Elfman (Oingo Boingo) who has shown very diverse music in his movie and tv compositions. It would have been fine if DP just did some songs for the End of Line club and end credits. For a reported $300+ million movie it was a huge gamble and probably just a way of marketing the movie to the 18-24 year olds.
|
VECTOR INVADER User
Posts: 123 | RE: TRON Legacy Soundtrack on Tuesday, December, 07, 2010 5:31 PM
I can see what is happening here..... tron fans are expecting what we all remebered 28 years ago, but, it's a entirely new audience. I think you will see more tron fans say it's blah, while you get the new tron audience saying it's an amazing soundtrack.
anyway, i happen to respect both soundtracks in different ways.
THE VIDEO CRAZE |
DaveTRON User
Posts: 5,314 | RE: TRON Legacy Soundtrack on Tuesday, December, 07, 2010 5:39 PM
VECTOR INVADER Wrote:I can see what is happening here..... tron fans are expecting what we all remebered 28 years ago, but, it's a entirely new audience. I think you will see more tron fans say it's blah, while you get the new tron audience saying it's an amazing soundtrack.
anyway, i happen to respect both soundtracks in different ways. |
VI, that is great, I am glad you like it.
I am not judging it AT ALL on it's comparison to the older soundtrack.
I am judging it as a piece of music. I am a fan of music. I love great music, but this in my own personal opinion isn't great music.
While there may be some judging it as you suggest, I am not one of those and I really hate being painted with the same brush as everyone else.
We were told this was going to be something incredible, and it simply isn't in my POV.
It's OK, it's not unlistenable, but it isn't re-listenable either. I have little or no desire to hear any of it again except for when I see the film.
I am actually hoping that after I see the film I will like it a bit more. DaveTRON
|
TriggerEXE User
Posts: 339 | RE: TRON Legacy Soundtrack on Tuesday, December, 07, 2010 6:11 PM
Like I said in another thread, I like the soundtrack. I like techno/trance, and I like Tron, so its double goodness. I can see what you're saying about the repetativeness, however that's kinda how trance is supposed to be. People said that about DP's music even back in the 90s. People would say that every song sounds the same, but that was mainly because their first album was compsed of songs that all flowed together to tell a story. I think the same can be said of their TL album. Its their first time doing a musical score for a movie and if it works out then they'll do more. If not, they'll learn from their mistakes and try something else. It seems like the fanbase is a little split on this one though. Like I said, I like the soundtrack and I think its the first movie soundtrack where I actually like every track. order abortion pill http://unclejohnsprojects.com/template/default.aspx?morning-after-pill-price where to buy abortion pillabortion pills online http://www.kvicksundscupen.se/template/default.aspx?abortion-questions cytotec abortion
"The dark can embrace the light, but never eclipse it." |
DaveTRON User
Posts: 5,314 | RE: TRON Legacy Soundtrack on Tuesday, December, 07, 2010 6:19 PM
Tron Unit Wrote:DaveTRON Wrote:Tron Unit Wrote:DaveTRON Wrote:Well first, I paid $3.99 today on Amazon to download the ENTIRE TRON Legacy Soundtrack today. Great price, get it while you can.
Now I knew nothing of Daft Punk prior to the announcement of their doing this soundtrack.
I learned a little about them and have become a fan of some of their music because of it, so I had very high hopes for this soundtrack.
Unfortunately, any life and joy that I find in their other music I feel is completely missing in this soundtrack.
I am 15 songs into a 23 song soundtrack and I feel like I have basically been listening to the same thing for 15 songs.
It's really not at all on par with the Wendy Carlos score, and I am not saying that due to my love of the original. I just feel like something is missing. the spark these two provide in their own works is just not here.
Consider me a disappointed fan after hearing this work. |
If you downloaded the 23 track version then you really didn't listen to the ENTIRE TRON album. Of course, you'll just complain that the other 7 tracks sound just like the other 23 so don't bother.
It's not supposed to Wendy Carlos' score just like Tron Legacy isn't Tron. It's its own thing and not trying to repeat what Wendy had already done.
|
Wow, you didn't get what I said at all.
I wasn't expecting it to be like Wendy's score, I was merely expecting it to be GOOD.
It isn't. It is boring and repetitive.
If there are 7 more tracks, why isn't Amazon selling them? Frankly, if there are 7 better tracks that are not part of the official soundtrack on sale from a legitimate outlet, then Disney/DaftPunk have done fans a huge disservice.
I seriously doubt anything those 7 tracks contain can elevate this tepid piece in my opinion. I just don't think it is a very good soundtrack at all.
|
So that's why you started a thread so you can bitch about how much you don't like it? That's just your opinion and you're entitled to it and I don't agree with it at all but there was no point to starting a new thread when we already had one discussing the score but somehow it makes you feel special to start one somehow justifies it.
If fans are going to start getting this polarizing with the score just wait until the movie opens. This board will start looking like all of the Star Wars fanboy forums with incessant whining. |
Why are you so angry about it is my question? I shared my opinion. Big fat hairy deal. It's just my opinion, no need for you to get upset with me over it.
I'm so sorry that my starting my own thread offends you so deeply too. I looked at a few other threads and didn't see one that fit what I wanted to say, so I started a new one. Why does it upset you so?
you seem to have a vested interest in telling me I am wrong wrong wrong. I have made it clear I don't expect to be in majority on this subject and I have every right to share my opinion whether you like it or not.
So turn your gaze inward and try to figure out why you are being such a major tool about this. My little ol' opinion (or "whining" as you call it) you don't agree with doesn't deserve this level of vitriol. Take your anger out on someone else.
abortion pills online abortion pill online purchase cytotec abortion DaveTRON
|
DaveTRON User
Posts: 5,314 | RE: TRON Legacy Soundtrack on Tuesday, December, 07, 2010 6:54 PM
Tron Unit Wrote:You don't like it. We got it. Move on.
/Thread |
Oooh! Aren't we a commanding little tyrant.
You started the fight pal. I just voiced one of many opinions. Consider it ended. DaveTRON
|
Fygee User
Posts: 88 | RE: TRON Legacy Soundtrack on Tuesday, December, 07, 2010 6:58 PM
I'm enjoying it, but I do feel that it at times comes off as being redundant. And yes, there are parts where the soundtrack screams Hans Zimmer, especially The Dark Knight. Then again, Daft Punk tend to use redundancy as a part of their style.
Ultimately it's purpose is to support the movie, so we'll see how it does in that regard. The good thing is that even critics that seem to hate it still gave kudos for how the soundtrack worked with the movie.order abortion pill abortion pill buy online where to buy abortion pill
|
Vortex.EXE User
Posts: 471 | Here's my ten cents, my two cents. It's free. on Tuesday, December, 07, 2010 7:11 PM
Guys, I picked it up today.
I've been listening to it nonestop.
Track 2 (The Grid) gives me chills everytime.
As far as the musical quality, I can definately understand the repetitious comments.
However, I will say (because I've been playing this while I put circuits on my jacket for the premier) that as background music, this stuff is absolutely killer.
|
Imbroglio User
Posts: 416 | RE: TRON Legacy Soundtrack on Tuesday, December, 07, 2010 7:22 PM
VECTOR INVADER Wrote:I can see what is happening here..... tron fans are expecting what we all remebered 28 years ago, but, it's a entirely new audience. I think you will see more tron fans say it's blah, while you get the new tron audience saying it's an amazing soundtrack.
anyway, i happen to respect both soundtracks in different ways. |
Well, the thing with TRON that made it memorable wasn't just the movie or the soundtrack, but the combination of both together. Everything was just so unique and memorable compared to other movies in that era.
The majority people I have heard saying that TL has an "amazing" soundtrack are pre-TL DP fans. I saw numerous times in the comment sections of the trailer from youtube and other movie sites that the DP fans overall didn't give a damn about TL and said things like "get rid of the dialogue and make it a 2 hour DP music video" and "everyone bring glowsticks to the theater and make it a rave".
Since the soundtrack has been released the box office numbers will tell if the hype was more successful at selling DP or the movie. If the movie does poorly, but the soundtrack sells very well don't be surprised if the TL sequel (if there is one) is turned into a musical and the DP fanboys get their 2 hour music video.
|
i86time User
Posts: 31 | RE: TRON Legacy Soundtrack on Tuesday, December, 07, 2010 9:16 PM
IsoLine Wrote:Hey Dave....To me the score felt very Zimmerish, if you understand me. I knew it would be orchestral and all, but it sounds very neoclassical in terms of current soundtracks and like you described. |
Well, there's a good reason for it feeling Zimmerish, they thank him, among others, in the liner notes, for his "generosity." I'm guessing he helped with some arrangements.
I'll pipe up that I'm also underimprssed with the score. I never expected it to be a 21st centrury re-tread of Carlos' work (which is among my favorite top 3 scores), and I applaud DP for not trying to do so. However, the type of music they play necessitates repetition, and that doesn't work well for a score (other than repeating themes throught separate tracks). It's just a 140+ bpm 4/4 pumping bass fest - for the most part. The orchestration feels forced. It plays like a video game score. Those aren't necessarily bad, but they don't work on the same level as a movie score. Games require interaction, so they can repeat, repeat, repeat until you complete the right activity or encounter the right character, and then change. You just can't do this with a score.
Overall, I expected better. It's not horrible, but it's not excellent. Feeling "meh" about something creative is worse than hating it though.
|
DaveTRON User
Posts: 5,314 | RE: TRON Legacy Soundtrack on Tuesday, December, 07, 2010 9:31 PM
Fygee Wrote:I'm enjoying it, but I do feel that it at times comes off as being redundant. And yes, there are parts where the soundtrack screams Hans Zimmer, especially The Dark Knight. Then again, Daft Punk tend to use redundancy as a part of their style.
Ultimately it's purpose is to support the movie, so we'll see how it does in that regard. The good thing is that even critics that seem to hate it still gave kudos for how the soundtrack worked with the movie. |
I am hoping once I see it in the context of the film I will enjoy it more. I really want to like it more, I just don't right now.abortion pills online abortion pill online purchase cytotec abortion DaveTRON
|
|