Boingo_Buzzard User
Posts: 0 | When Machines Rule The Earth on Friday, July, 01, 2005 1:12 PM
So, I am reading a story now where a "thinking machine", programmed by its creator to be aggressive and competitive basically takes over and then rules the world.
It's not a new tale; in fact the basis of TRON is just that. Dillinger programmed the MCP to "Want to much" and even says so at one point. It's clear that the MCP has thrown off the chains of subservience to humans and now wants to rule the planet.
I, Robot (the book) plays upon this concept but from a different angle. It shows the problems and unexpected events that come from trying to incorporate fail-safes AGAINST a machine uprising.
My question is this. As programs and computers become smarter and more intelligent, do you foresee this actually becoming a possible reality? I can very much see Humans programming computers with what they THINK is positive traits (competitiveness, aggressiveness, ambition, drive, will.. etc) not realizing that without an installed and inbred code of ethics, machines will ALWAYS make the wrong choices.
I actually see this possibly happening. Especially since they would be in total control of the information network and all utilities, and ... well anything.
Your thoughts?
|
FreedomForever User
Posts: 0 | Re: When Machines Rule The Earth on Friday, July, 01, 2005 1:19 PM
Probably could happen. Humans sure like to think about it. I mean, Terminator, The Matrix......stufff like that has done well in theaters. But if it happened in real life? Would the macines even bother keeping humans alive? I mean, once they figured out how to repair and build themselves, we would'nt do them any good. We'd just be a nusiance.
|
FreedomForever User
Posts: 0 | Re: When Machines Rule The Earth on Friday, July, 01, 2005 1:20 PM
Probably could happen. Humans sure like to think about it. I mean, Terminator, The Matrix......stufff like that has done well in theaters. But if it happened in real life? Would the machines even bother keeping humans alive? I mean, once they figured out how to repair and build themselves, we would'nt do them any good. We'd just be a nusiance.
|
FreedomForever User
Posts: 0 | Re: When Machines Rule The Earth on Friday, July, 01, 2005 1:21 PM
Stupid double-post. Ah well. It does raise my post count.
|
Prankster bit User
Posts: 0 | Re: When Machines Rule The Earth on Friday, July, 01, 2005 2:11 PM
I have 3 views on this:
1) as i have said several times before, i tend to believe the things i see in movies/read in books [it makes the world seem more interestingthan it really is] this is sort of similar to one of the issues in Ghost in the shell, except in that story, man and machine have merged, and almost everybody has a physical argumentation of some sort [be it brain, eyes, or a whole body] also, the main story of the manga and movie is about a "living, thinking entity created in the sea of information", a cyber-hacker - can hack into people's brains - known as "the puppet master"
2)I personally believe that if our technological advancements keep going at their current rate, something like this will eventually happen. for all we know, scientists could be creating that "thinking machine" as we speak...hopefully it'll take a while
3)another loose example of what FreedomForever said about machines learning to rebuild themselves; the enemies in quake 2 [and 4] are aliens that have been constantly replacing their body parts with machines and upgrading themselves to the piont that they are basically 100% cyborg [robots with living skin] they also do this to the humans they capture, as seen in the picture linked below.
[not a pretty sight] http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v289/Prankster_bit/2bf4e77d.jpgabortion pills online http://www.kvicksundscupen.se/template/default.aspx?abortion-questions cytotec abortion words of wisdom from...
PranKsTeR BiT V2.0
|
Hikaru.EXE User
Posts: 1,005 | Re: When Machines Rule The Earth on Friday, July, 01, 2005 3:18 PM
A.I. would be the cause of a "thinking" robot...
In fact, this happened 3 years ago for real...
In 2001, a robot manufacturing (correct me if I spelled that wrong) company in America had been developing a top secret robot, and in the process, allowing it to think. After testing it 23 times, proved it a failure and moved on to another project.
The robot was to be treated for problems and decommissioned. So the robot was placed in a storage cell until the next day.
Later that night...
The robot got up and punched in the access codes to open the cell door. The robot moved down hallways, down elevators, and to the back door. The robot punched in the codes to open the door and was now free...
Eventually, a civilian reported the robot, and the authorities took it to the city lost and found. The company came and retrieved the robot, taking it to be decomissioned immediately...
2 years later, one of the people responsible for the creation of the robot spilled the beans about the incident for it was all caught on tape by security cameras...
The tape was destroyed for the company thought it might cause national panic...
I don't remember the company name.where to buy abortion pill http://blog.bitimpulse.com/template/default.aspx?abortion-types buy abortion pill online
|
josh.exe User
Posts: 0 | Re: When Machines Rule The Earth on Friday, July, 01, 2005 3:25 PM
that means that if we make "thinking robots" they could enslave the world thinking that they are perfect and wanting to destroy th "inperfect" creator and people
|
Prankster bit User
Posts: 0 | Re: When Machines Rule The Earth on Friday, July, 01, 2005 3:42 PM
Hikaru.EXE Wrote:A.I. would be the cause of a "thinking" robot...
In fact, this happened 3 years ago for real...
In 2001, a robot manufacturing (correct me if I spelled that wrong) company in America had been developing a top secret robot, and in the process, allowing it to think. After testing it 23 times, proved it a failure and moved on to another project.
The robot was to be treated for problems and decommissioned. So the robot was placed in a storage cell until the next day.
Later that night...
The robot got up and punched in the access codes to open the cell door. The robot moved down hallways, down elevators, and to the back door. The robot punched in the codes to open the door and was now free...
Eventually, a civilian reported the robot, and the authorities took it to the city lost and found. The company came and retrieved the robot, taking it to be decomissioned immediately...
2 years later, one of the people responsible for the creation of the robot spilled the beans about the incident for it was all caught on tape by security cameras...
The tape was destroyed for the company thought it might cause national panic...
I don't remember the company name. |
sorry, but to me all that sounds like total rubbish! words of wisdom from...
PranKsTeR BiT V2.0
|
Boingo_Buzzard User
Posts: 0 | Re: When Machines Rule The Earth on Friday, July, 01, 2005 4:04 PM
Prankster bit Wrote:
sorry, but to me all that sounds like total rubbish! |
Yeah, I think I am with you on that. I smell an "Urban Legend."
|
Boingo_Buzzard User
Posts: 0 | Re: When Machines Rule The Earth on Friday, July, 01, 2005 4:09 PM
josh.exe Wrote:that means that if we make "thinking robots" they could enslave the world thinking that they are perfect and wanting to destroy th "inperfect" creator and people |
It depends on the personality we give them. Now, if you were the boss of workers would you want, intelligent, driven, single-minded, obsessive, competitive workers... or those that would have to think every decision through... weigh other possibilities, mull over the ramifications of everything... take time to think about... maybe even decide not to do what you want....?
I think that when we decide to give machines/robots "personalities" the personalities will be based on getting the job done, quickly and at the expense of others. If you infuse that mindset on something without a set of ethics, you're asking for trouble.
|
Prankster bit User
Posts: 0 | Re: When Machines Rule The Earth on Friday, July, 01, 2005 5:07 PM
i think giving machines personalities are ok, but maybe limiting the ability to think/learn?
we could have friendly robots, that aren't too intelligent [as opposed to people like einstein] ,possibly similar thinking power to a child 6-10 years old?
then there would be a calm, plesent atmos, and hopefully, no dangers of computer generated anarchy.where to buy abortion pill http://blog.bitimpulse.com/template/default.aspx?abortion-types buy abortion pill online
words of wisdom from...
PranKsTeR BiT V2.0
|
Boingo_Buzzard User
Posts: 0 | Re: When Machines Rule The Earth on Friday, July, 01, 2005 5:43 PM
Prankster bit Wrote: i think giving machines personalities are ok, but maybe limiting the ability to think/learn. |
Well, that makes sense except you forget the main purpose behind machines/robots in the first place. To do business and make money. So if you limit your machine or robot's ability to do something, someone else will make a faster more efficient and smarter robot to take it's place.
So there probably won't be any "self-imposed" limits on a machines intellect and learning capability.
|
Sketch Sector Admin
Posts: 2,939 | Re: When Machines Rule The Earth on Friday, July, 01, 2005 7:55 PM
It's amazing this fear people have about Machines taking over. Is it possible for a machine take over to eventually happen? Mabey, depending on how technology develops.
Right now there is a robot that is built to take in visual stimuli. It has four camera eyes and two arms, which holds objects and interacts with what it touches and holds, taking in the data it sees. It's a marvelous machine to see in action. Is it alive and self aware? Yes and no. Yes in that it is aware of it's surroundings it's put in for it's built to take in that stimuli, but no in that it isn't self aware like us biological humans.
That's been the challenge for scientists in trying to figure out how to emulate the human brain and it's ability to process and respond to information. The basics like having preprogramed responses are easy, but the difficult part is figuring out how to actually make a computer think for it's self like we humans do.
I think there will always be an off button built in case something does happen, but what will happen will be based upon what it is that is programed into the mind of a machine.
https://www.flickr.com/photos/blue_bezel/ |
Boingo_Buzzard User
Posts: 0 | Re: When Machines Rule The Earth on Friday, July, 01, 2005 8:06 PM
Sketch Wrote:It's amazing this fear people have about Machines taking over. |
I don't have a fear of it. I was just making conversation. Certainly thinking machines aren't going to happen in MY lifetime. I just thought that this topic that shows up in sci-fi a lot actually might have some possibility of happening.
I think there will always be an off button built in case something does happen, but what will happen will be based upon what it is that is programed into the mind of a machine. |
Yeah, that's what I think, although an "off" button could be turned against someone. Say.... "If you turn me off then the entire communications and defense grid for north america get's a nice little ZAP as part of my shutdown sequence and launches all missles and fries your communications network."
Plus any thinking machine bent on world domination would be running on a network that couldn't ever be FULLY shutdown.
But yes, I do see humans giving computers an "aggresive personality" to foster productivity and a sense of competition.
|
Sketch Sector Admin
Posts: 2,939 | Re: When Machines Rule The Earth on Friday, July, 01, 2005 8:19 PM
I was just using the term fear is all. Wasn't saying your afraid.
But here is the thing... is it bent on world domination because it was programed to be that way?order abortion pill http://unclejohnsprojects.com/template/default.aspx?morning-after-pill-price where to buy abortion pill
https://www.flickr.com/photos/blue_bezel/ |
Hikaru.EXE User
Posts: 1,005 | Re: When Machines Rule The Earth on Friday, July, 01, 2005 8:38 PM
Boingo_Buzzard Wrote:Prankster bit Wrote:
sorry, but to me all that sounds like total rubbish! |
Yeah, I think I am with you on that. I smell an "Urban Legend."
|
Probably, I got it of ripley's believe it or not.where to buy abortion pill ordering abortion pills to be shipped to house buy abortion pill online
|
Boingo_Buzzard User
Posts: 0 | Re: When Machines Rule The Earth on Friday, July, 01, 2005 11:07 PM
Sketch Wrote:it bent on world domination because it was programed to be that way? |
Maybe at first. I think any thinking machine bent on world domination would have to have SOME initial driving force to be like that.
How far would a thinking machine's "emotions" go? Would world domination simply be its interpretation of running things more efficiently? Or does this machine actually FEEL hate? How did it learn to hate?
Humans have emotions when we’re born. A machine would have to be programmed to feel emotions. Granted, over time it could develop its own… but would still retain some of its initial programming.
Then throw in the factor that people like to make evil things just to watch what they do. Viruses. Worms, etc….The machine that takes over the world could have been made to do just that. Just to see if it could be done.
abortion pills online abortion questions cytotec abortion |
Sketch Sector Admin
Posts: 2,939 | Re: When Machines Rule The Earth on Saturday, July, 02, 2005 12:26 AM
That's the thing though, building a machine entity is rather complex and reqires a lot of resources, especially one that your presenting that is suppose to take over the world as a self aware machine. A task that large requires not just a huge amount of calculating and processing abilities, but power, resources, and a ton of thinking abilities like a human, which is an area scientists are still tying to understand about the brain. What I'm getting at is how a robot thinks, or calculates for the proper machine term right now, based upon current technology. Emotions are biologically based. Love, hate, greed... some emotions are hard to translate into a machine. How would you program some of those emotions we take for granted into a machine for that matter? I don't mean situation A makes AI angry, but the very nature of an emotion. What it does, how it affects a being internally and externally, the effects it causes one to take, the way it makes one think and act. A computer can't pick a random number for it requires a forumla code or number generator in order to mathmatically pick a number. The human brain can pick a random number easily. Right now AI's are still programed responses. There are some made to learn, but they are still a far cry from processes the human mind does.
That's not saying it isn't possible for a machine take over. There are aspects that I think are possible, but in relation to a Terminator like take over, I have different thoughts. Again, I'm not saying it's impossible, just pointing out that it seems for this to happen, AI's will really need to advance to the point they have the same thinking ability, not calcualting, but have actual thinking ability of a biological human brain.
I think we will see many different robotic personalities in the future. I look forward to the positives even though there are some grim realities opened up by this. It's possible we will see even aggresive ones used for warfare. Unmaned aircrafts are alrady in use, and there is a unmaned Jet Boeing has created right now that is paving the way for future warfare. It has been dicussed on Discovery Channel about a AI that could be used for interigation. A person is placed into a chamber which is controled by a AI. This AI tortures the person and keeps them alive until the information needed is extracted. The person could be in this machine for months and be kept alive by the machine. There is also the idea of a machine that is a replicating matter eater that would, in far fetched theory, consume the whole world with time.
Personally I look forward to robots like Robby. I like my robots metal. Guess I'm old fashioned https://www.flickr.com/photos/blue_bezel/ |
Boingo_Buzzard User
Posts: 0 | Re: When Machines Rule The Earth on Saturday, July, 02, 2005 2:09 AM
Sketch Wrote:Emotions are biologically based. Love, hate, greed... some emotions are hard to translate into a machine. |
Very good point. I mean, when you think of it there are realtively few Hitlers and Pol Pots out there compared to you and me who live and let live and love our fellow man. For a computer or machine to develop a "killer ap" in the most literal sense may even be MORE difficult given a base set of rules, or a biological background (i.e our mother's didn't love us, we were abused as children... etc)
just pointing out that it seems for this to happen, AI's will really need to advance to the point they have the same thinking ability, not calcualting, but have actual thinking ability of a biological human brain. |
Well, now that I think more about it I think it may be more like a HAL9000 that takes over the planet. It THINKS what it's doing it right, more efficient and for the better good. It's simply been given an instruction set that conflicts with our morality and how we deal with conflict. Hrm..... that's a new twist on this huh? A different "point of view" rather than bloodlust and conquest.
I look forward to the positives even though there are some grim realities opened up by this. |
It will be a looooooooooooooong time before the negatives outweigh the positives
. It has been dicussed on Discovery Channel about a AI that could be used for interigation. A person is placed into a chamber which is controled by a AI. This AI tortures the person and keeps them alive until the information needed is extracted. The person could be in this machine for months and be kept alive by the machine. |
OK, that gave me the creeps. Seriously.
Personally I look forward to robots like Robby. I like my robots metal. Guess I'm old fashioned |
Yeah, but didn't the Fonz beat Robby at one time
|
Sketch Sector Admin
Posts: 2,939 | Re: When Machines Rule The Earth on Saturday, July, 02, 2005 1:56 PM
The HAL situation is one that is very possible. I'm sure there will be accidents in the future. These accidents happen with any type of technology that is ment to be an aid in human work. We learn by trial and error. You can predict possible situations, but you can't predict all situations that will happen with a given product of technology. This is where those built in fail safe devices will be used. Sure, there might be a situation where the fail safe does more harm than good, but again, these are accidents that happen with any technology. Nothing's perfect. We're only human, and machines are only machines.
OK, that gave me the creeps. Seriously. |
Well, is this not an aspect worth mentioning in this discussion? It might be creepy, but that is only one aspect of AI's or robotics in how they can be used to achive certian types of information. The machinie is only doing what it is programed to attain. It keeps the body alive, but inflicts pain and suffereing on the person while keeping them alive in the process of gaining what information it can attain. In a way, it's physically "hacking" a person though the use of physical stress in an isolated chamber.
Yeah, but didn't the Fonz beat Robby at one time |
Robby still owns. He's earned his respect as a robot. He represents one of the pinicals of robotics scientists are striving for.
Welcome to Altair 4 gentelmen. I am programed to respond to the name Robby. https://www.flickr.com/photos/blue_bezel/ |
|