Vaporware User
Posts: 217 | Quorra's Fighting Skills/Choreography on Saturday, November, 19, 2011 9:38 AM
I know we could all make a huge list of thing we would like to tweak about Legacy. Little things that could have enhanced the movie w/o damaging it. After a recent watching of T:L I realized that I was unimpressed by Quorra's fighting skills in the EOL Club. Given that she didn't exactly mop the floor with Black Guards, I was less convinced that she was capable of protecting Sam from Clu later on at the Portal.
It seemed to me that Quorra should have been a much more effective fighter against the Black Guard.
In the film, she leaps between Sam and the Guards, and then holds two of them off as Sam gets up.
In the film, the way she's positioned - holding off those guys with her Light Katana and Disc- with her back to them was meant to impress us. But it kinda ended there. She didn't dispatch the two guards from the same position (which would have been awesome).
Instead she and Sam getting into a sloppy back-to-back fighting position so that they can get surrounded and then they flail about somewhat wildly until Sam gets knocked down and Quorra's skills suddenly evaporate.
After multiple watchings, I'm really unimpressed by the fight choreography here. It didn't have to be "poetry-in-motion" but it could have been a bit better. It looked really sloppy.
If she had actually derezzed a couple of the guards single-handedly, before getting injured, I would have found her defense of Sam on the Portal Catwalk a bit more believable.
Thoughts?
|
Kaisergrendel User
Posts: 298 | RE: Quorra's Fighting Skills/Choreography on Saturday, November, 19, 2011 12:23 PM
Agreed on all points. The fighting was a bit lame, and the EOL club fight was flaccid and messy, and totally half-baked. What makes it even more pathetic, although it isn't necessarily the filmmakers' fault, was that Quorra was marketed as at least adept at melee combat or as a femme fatale in the extreme (god I hate using that term).
For the next movie I think they should hire Yuen Wo Ping, the guy who choreographed the Matrix films and Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon, at least in an advisory role. Or Brad Allen, who did Scott Pilgrim vs The World, whose action was surprisingly fluid and punchy.
You say it doesn't have to be poetry in motion, I say it definitely wouldn't hurt.
Edit: Adding to the EOL fight undermining Quorra's ability to defend against CLU at the portal, don't forget she lasted all of 2 seconds (okay maybe 4) against Rinzler, and CLU pummeled Tron's ass pretty quick.
|
trekking95 User
Posts: 2,440 | RE: Quorra's Fighting Skills/Choreography on Saturday, November, 19, 2011 2:06 PM
All I have to say is *sigh*
The movie is the way the movie is so you have to be happy with it since its the only one there is! Just try looking by the faults and at the good parts! abortion pills online abortion pill online purchase cytotec abortion Thanks to FlynnOne for the signature!
Save Tron 3! |
DrP User
Posts: 242 | RE: Quorra's Fighting Skills/Choreography on Saturday, November, 19, 2011 2:13 PM
trekking95 Wrote:All I have to say is *sigh*
The movie is the way the movie is so you have to be happy with it since its the only one there is! Just try looking by the faults and at the good parts! |
Hey at least the music was good during the fight scene.......
How's that for looking on the bright side?order abortion pill http://unclejohnsprojects.com/template/default.aspx?morning-after-pill-price where to buy abortion pill END OF LINE |
trekking95 User
Posts: 2,440 | RE: Quorra's Fighting Skills/Choreography on Saturday, November, 19, 2011 2:30 PM
Good point, that actually was one of my favorite music spots! Thanks to FlynnOne for the signature!
Save Tron 3! |
TRON.dll User
Posts: 4,349 | RE: Quorra's Fighting Skills/Choreography on Saturday, November, 19, 2011 3:02 PM
I kind of agree with the original post. While Quorra's arm getting chopped off and her nearly derezzing builds up some slight emotional connection with her and the audience, I feel that she really could have been developed more as a stronger female character had she not been (almost) killed at the club. The scene with her and Sam sitting on the Solar Sailer could have still been there, as well.
I guess you could say there's one important part to the whole "Quorra is almost dead" scenes, that being to stress to the audience that her survival as the last remaining ISO is extremely important.on line abortion pill misoprostol dose abortion medical abortion pill online
TRON 2.0 (PC) name - TRON.dll
I'll play any mode, but I'm best at LC.
PSN - TRON-dll
XBOX Live/Games for Windows Live - TRONdll
-I have a Wii, DS, and 3DS. PM me to exchange friend codes. |
Vaporware User
Posts: 217 | RE: Quorra's Fighting Skills/Choreography on Saturday, November, 19, 2011 3:50 PM
At least we actually got a movie *and* it has a great soundtrack.
To be honest, I still only partially understand what people didn't like about this film. Perhaps they were expecting the effects of Transformers, the Kung Fu of Matrix, and the plot of Apocalypse Now..?
I haven't watched it a dozen times because I hated it. But I still think it's worth considering what parts of this movie seem to leave us feeling unsatisfied.
People ding Kosinzki for style over substance, and particularly hit the plot. I had no issues with the plot, but I did feel like there were some things that didn't go over quite right. This fight was definitely one of them.
Perhaps I was expecting Uma Thurman from Kill Bill Vol. 1? I don't think we needed to see some "phantom menace" style over-choreography, but this was a chance for us to see Quorra as something more than a cocky (and surprisingly naive) program.
Afterwards, I didn't know what to think of her anymore. It wasn't until she was in the flying the Light Jet that i started thinking she was actually good at anything.
order abortion pill abortion pill buy online where to buy abortion pillwhere to buy abortion pill ordering abortion pills to be shipped to house buy abortion pill online
|
TRON.dll User
Posts: 4,349 | RE: Quorra's Fighting Skills/Choreography on Saturday, November, 19, 2011 6:00 PM
Vaporware Wrote:At least we actually got a movie *and* it has a great soundtrack.
To be honest, I still only partially understand what people didn't like about this film. Perhaps they were expecting the effects of Transformers, the Kung Fu of Matrix, and the plot of Apocalypse Now..?
I haven't watched it a dozen times because I hated it. But I still think it's worth considering what parts of this movie seem to leave us feeling unsatisfied.
People ding Kosinzki for style over substance, and particularly hit the plot. I had no issues with the plot, but I did feel like there were some things that didn't go over quite right. This fight was definitely one of them.
Perhaps I was expecting Uma Thurman from Kill Bill Vol. 1? I don't think we needed to see some "phantom menace" style over-choreography, but this was a chance for us to see Quorra as something more than a cocky (and surprisingly naive) program.
Afterwards, I didn't know what to think of her anymore. It wasn't until she was in the flying the Light Jet that i started thinking she was actually good at anything.
|
I wasn't suggesting it was a horrible movie. Just providing insight on how I thought it could have been better. where to buy abortion pill ordering abortion pills to be shipped to house buy abortion pill online
TRON 2.0 (PC) name - TRON.dll
I'll play any mode, but I'm best at LC.
PSN - TRON-dll
XBOX Live/Games for Windows Live - TRONdll
-I have a Wii, DS, and 3DS. PM me to exchange friend codes. |
Moses613 User
Posts: 274 | RE: Quorra's Fighting Skills/Choreography on Saturday, November, 19, 2011 7:05 PM
That fight scene and it's choppy editing and lame choreography didn't do justice to Olivia Wilde's supposed three months of pre-production fight training. For what? a barely coherent and brief fight scene? No complaint though, the movie still ROCKS.
As for me, I'm still wondering exactly where everyone in the EOL club seems to dissapear to as the fight goes on. There has to have been some kind of emergency evacuation system. Maybe some stairs or an emergency stasht of those paraglider wings they could have donned and used to soar to safety from the outer balcony section of the club. Part of it is open air after all. Fire codes probably demanded an alternate exit route.
|
J User
Posts: 248 | RE: Quorra's Fighting Skills/Choreography on Saturday, November, 19, 2011 7:29 PM
I had to think about that. Okay, I put WAY too much thinking into stats and how a scene could play out, especially with novel-length fanfic.
I figure she's one of the glass cannon or fragile speedster tropes. Sure, she can dish it out, and it's difficult to get a hit on her, but she goes down hard if you do manage a solid hit. River Tam is along the same lines. Part of the problem on Quorra is that she might have learned to fight from competent, but not stellar, fighters. Flynn? No slouch with the disk, probably, but he resorted to User abilities more often than not. Anon? Very competent in his own right, probably on par with Tron circa the first movie...but still a rookie. My head-canon also adds a couple Iso scouts and Yori...again, competent but not utter badasses.
By comparison? Sam might be using a very subtle form of User powers when he's fighting - regeneration, ability to mimic other Programs' fighting techniques, subconsciously enhancing his speed and strength, etc. Head-canon also says he got in WAY too many fights as a kid, and that his maternal grandpa was career Army and taught a few tactics.
If you're inclined to do patchwork fics, I see Jet as not able to deal out as much damage with his hits, being the lowest dexterity of the "second Gen" crew, and not able to regenerate damage, but able to take a lot more damage, and having User abilities centered on assimilating foreign code and transmuting things like the patch orbs and virus-ridden subroutines into something that helps him.
It's an entire universe in there, one we created, but it's beyond us now. Really. It's outgrown us. You know, every time you shut off your computer...do you know what you're doing? Have you ever reformatted a hard drive? Deleted old software? Destroyed an entire universe?"
-- Jet Bradley, Tron: Ghost in the Machine on why being a User isn't necessarily a good thing. |
Kaisergrendel User
Posts: 298 | RE: Quorra's Fighting Skills/Choreography on Saturday, November, 19, 2011 9:41 PM
trekking95 Wrote:All I have to say is *sigh*
The movie is the way the movie is so you have to be happy with it since its the only one there is! Just try looking by the faults and at the good parts! |
I thought it went without saying, but I'm sure all of us are here because we liked the movie in general, but that doesn't mean we have to keep quiet about its faults, especially when there's constructive criticism to be made.
|
Kaisergrendel User
Posts: 298 | RE: Quorra's Fighting Skills/Choreography on Saturday, November, 19, 2011 9:43 PM
J Wrote:I figure she's one of the glass cannon or fragile speedster tropes. Sure, she can dish it out, and it's difficult to get a hit on her, but she goes down hard if you do manage a solid hit. River Tam is along the same lines.
|
Except River Tam's never been defeated in hand to hand, whether one on one or against dozens of combatants. Quorra went down fighting her first two.
|
Kaisergrendel User
Posts: 298 | RE: Quorra's Fighting Skills/Choreography on Saturday, November, 19, 2011 9:48 PM
Moses613 Wrote:As for me, I'm still wondering exactly where everyone in the EOL club seems to dissapear to as the fight goes on. |
The black guard seemed to be derezzing at will, so...
Moses613 Wrote:There has to have been some kind of emergency evacuation system. Maybe some stairs or an emergency stasht of those paraglider wings they could have donned and used to soar to safety from the outer balcony section of the club. Part of it is open air after all. Fire codes probably demanded an alternate exit route. |
Liiiiittle bit too much guesswork innit?
|
Kaisergrendel User
Posts: 298 | RE: Quorra's Fighting Skills/Choreography on Saturday, November, 19, 2011 9:51 PM
TRON.dll Wrote:I kind of agree with the original post. While Quorra's arm getting chopped off and her nearly derezzing builds up some slight emotional connection with her and the audience, I feel that she really could have been developed more as a stronger female character had she not been (almost) killed at the club. The scene with her and Sam sitting on the Solar Sailer could have still been there, as well.
I guess you could say there's one important part to the whole "Quorra is almost dead" scenes, that being to stress to the audience that her survival as the last remaining ISO is extremely important. |
I don't see why you can't have one without the other. She could have taken out many black guards before being overwhelmed herself. It kind of made her look like a burden for the other two instead of a worthy member of the team.where to buy abortion pill abortion types buy abortion pill online
|
J User
Posts: 248 | RE: Quorra's Fighting Skills/Choreography on Saturday, November, 19, 2011 10:27 PM
Perhaps she's merely a case of more enthusiasm than experience. It's not like she got a lot of fight experience holed up in the Outlands with a "master" that was FAR too broken to think of fighting back anymore. order abortion pill http://unclejohnsprojects.com/template/default.aspx?morning-after-pill-price where to buy abortion pill
It's an entire universe in there, one we created, but it's beyond us now. Really. It's outgrown us. You know, every time you shut off your computer...do you know what you're doing? Have you ever reformatted a hard drive? Deleted old software? Destroyed an entire universe?"
-- Jet Bradley, Tron: Ghost in the Machine on why being a User isn't necessarily a good thing. |
trekking95 User
Posts: 2,440 | RE: Quorra's Fighting Skills/Choreography on Sunday, November, 20, 2011 12:07 AM
Kaisergrendel Wrote:trekking95 Wrote:All I have to say is *sigh*
The movie is the way the movie is so you have to be happy with it since its the only one there is! Just try looking by the faults and at the good parts! |
I thought it went without saying, but I'm sure all of us are here because we liked the movie in general, but that doesn't mean we have to keep quiet about its faults, especially when there's constructive criticism to be made. |
Yeah, I guess if we didn't we would have nothing to talk about!order abortion pill abortion pill buy online where to buy abortion pill Thanks to FlynnOne for the signature!
Save Tron 3! |
Kaisergrendel User
Posts: 298 | RE: Quorra's Fighting Skills/Choreography on Sunday, November, 20, 2011 8:08 AM
J Wrote:Perhaps she's merely a case of more enthusiasm than experience. It's not like she got a lot of fight experience holed up in the Outlands with a "master" that was FAR too broken to think of fighting back anymore. |
Even if this were true the fight scene and any previous exposition fails to convey any of those conditions. It's still apologetic rationalization for a poor scene.
|
Moses613 User
Posts: 274 | RE: Quorra's Fighting Skills/Choreography on Sunday, November, 20, 2011 11:29 AM
We saw very few of the EOL patrons getting derezzed. Plus to do that to at least fifty people would take some time, then you'd have to many bits laying about on the floor that you wouldn't be able to walk around withouut slipping on them. In defense of the EOL staff, they did fight bravely-and first-to save the patrons from the BG.
|
Kat User
Posts: 2,394 | RE: Quorra's Fighting Skills/Choreography on Sunday, November, 20, 2011 11:50 AM
Kaisergrendel Wrote:TRON.dll Wrote:I kind of agree with the original post. While Quorra's arm getting chopped off and her nearly derezzing builds up some slight emotional connection with her and the audience, I feel that she really could have been developed more as a stronger female character had she not been (almost) killed at the club. The scene with her and Sam sitting on the Solar Sailer could have still been there, as well.
I guess you could say there's one important part to the whole "Quorra is almost dead" scenes, that being to stress to the audience that her survival as the last remaining ISO is extremely important. |
I don't see why you can't have one without the other. She could have taken out many black guards before being overwhelmed herself. It kind of made her look like a burden for the other two instead of a worthy member of the team. |
She still does more than Sam, who largely just stands there wondering what to do with a "holy crap!" look on his face. I mean, he impulsively jumps into the fray, realizes he's in trouble, and then luckily Q shows up and tries to defend him. Flynn himself doesn't do much more than turning the lights off and looking badass.
I suspect she could've done more, as well, but if she did I suspect we'd then be asking where she learned to fight like that and whether it was realistic (I know we've had "where did Quorra learn to fight" discussions before anyway).
( I'm still trying to figure out where she learned to fly a jet. I don't imagine that's something most civilian programs get to do. Probably even less common than the number of people in our society who know how to fly a plane, because in the Grid, it sort of seems like the jets are military-type vehicles only.)
Kaisergrendel Wrote:J Wrote:Perhaps she's merely a case of more enthusiasm than experience. It's not like she got a lot of fight experience holed up in the Outlands with a "master" that was FAR too broken to think of fighting back anymore. |
Even if this were true the fight scene and any previous exposition fails to convey any of those conditions. It's still apologetic rationalization for a poor scene. |
But there's also no exposition to show that she would have any fighting skills, either. All we have to go on is what they show us in that scene.
What do you want? I'm busy.
Program, please!
Chaos.... good news. |
CB2001 User
Posts: 549 | RE: Quorra's Fighting Skills/Choreography on Sunday, November, 20, 2011 12:04 PM
Kaisergrendel Wrote:For the next movie I think they should hire Yuen Wo Ping, the guy who choreographed the Matrix films and Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon, at least in an advisory role. Or Brad Allen, who did Scott Pilgrim vs The World, whose action was surprisingly fluid and punchy.
|
My vote goes for Brad Allen. I think Yuen Wo Ping would make it too far out.order abortion pill http://unclejohnsprojects.com/template/default.aspx?morning-after-pill-price where to buy abortion pill
|
|