Forums (I/O Tower)
Forums 
 TRON: LEGACY 
 The "What are physical conditions like on the Grid?" thread


New New Comments | Post No Change | Locked Closed
AuthorComments: FirstPrevious Page: of 3 PagesNextLast
Subject1138
User

Posts: 45
RE: The "What are physical conditions like on the Grid?" thread

on Wednesday, February, 02, 2011 11:12 PM
Also, if the programs didn't have genitals why would they wear codpieces (Jarvis) and have breasts and/or crotch bulges? Ha. I know that the "real world" answer is that the actors/actresses have these things and there is no way to get rid of them easily, but if what you see in the movies is the Tron world, then they obviously have something going on anatomically speaking.

But really I think the whole world would be a happier place if everyone stopped being so uptight about their bodies and sexuality. It isn't weird or gross and frankly I really don't care one way or another if Yori's breaking Tron off a piece in the original.order abortion pill abortion pill buy online where to buy abortion pillabortion pills online abortion pill online purchase cytotec abortion


 
rimwall
User

Posts: 507
RE: The "What are physical conditions like on the Grid?" thread

on Wednesday, February, 02, 2011 11:38 PM
this is what i mean by problems with abstraction

what we see in the grid visuals/concepts/ideas does not
translate well when applied to our real world

and concepts in our real world does not translate well
when applied to the grid.

some ideas/concepts might translate well- but not all.

consider tron 1 - ram was an actuarial program, and the
idea of an actuarial program entering a game program is absurd.

there is no literal-real-world equivalent to the concept.
even if we view ram's source code - the act of inserting
his source code into a game source code would most likely
corrupt the game and render the game useless.(in our real world terms)

in a lot of situations, everytime we try to connect
the concepts of the two worlds, we run into
problems

consider also the real-world encom system in tron 1.
it probably had quarterly report programs, database programs,
memo PIM programs.

if we could examine the actual programming
code we will not see anything inside the code about the
program having a body, a face, emotions etc. - and yet the
programs manifest with a body.

therefore -there is something else at work when our real-world
programming code manifest as bodies with faces and emotions.
(and btw that something is not under user control)

consider the whole real-world encom operating system,(tron 1)
the source code would not have a gravitational constant,
and yet in grid you have gravity (and that gravity affects
program movement like running walking jumping).
if nobody programmed the constant then how do we
explain the presence of gravity in the tron universe.

i can be sure of one thing, the tron universe "fills in"
what the programmer does not "explicitly" write in code:

  • if the programmer did not include hands face emotions
    for his actuarial code then the "tron universe" fills
    that in.

  • if the programmer of the operating system did not "explicitly"
    code-in a gravitational constant then "tron universe"
    will fill that in.
  • if the programmer did not explicitly code-in living
    quarters for programs then "tron universe" fills that in.
think of it as a "tron universe directive" the directive
being:

create a world populated by people and having laws of
nature like gravitational constant, heat, energy etc.
given only lines of programming code. (we could even
accept that the laws of nature in the tron universe
as pre-existing)

for engineers think of it as the black-box technique
(technical manual writers use this concept too)


real world universe:
concepts---------------black box------tron universe
ideas------------------black box------concepts ideas
laws of nature---------black box------laws of nature

treat each universe as a separate universe with
its own laws. we can add to the laws of the tron
universe based only how the tron universe (only) is
depicted in the movies.

just don't let the natural laws inside the tron universe
contradict each other - because that will lead to another
abstraction and we will end up with abstractions within abstractions.

dont try to explain/connect one universe with
concepts of the other universe. thats is the black box's job- translate
one reality to the other.

there are however several concepts that the movie
explicitly says are directly connected and can
bypass the black box technique


real world universe------tron universe

programming code ----- tron-universe-person

programmer mental characteristics-----tron-universe-person inherits some mental char.

user body-------unique program body that can bleed

programmer body-----unique program body w/ full power over his inanimate creations recognizers etc.

programmer body ----unique program body w/ limited power over his programs manifested as people.

programmer body----unique program body that is more resilient to damage

the operative word is explicit. if the movie
makes a direct explicit connection then we can add it
to the list above.

would this be an acceptable form of abstraction?


I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.

 
Subject1138
User

Posts: 45
RE: The "What are physical conditions like on the Grid?" thread

on Wednesday, February, 02, 2011 11:58 PM
LWSrocks Wrote:I'm glad that Lisberger answered the question. I will reference that post next time I see someone mentioning it.

"And the idea that Yori and Tron could touch in a cyber-esque way, by affecting each other's energy and bring certain circuits to life that were dormant. I think that was a really nice moment and a lot more could have been made from that and there's a chance in a Tron 2 that we'll make more of that."

There is an exact transcription of what Lisberger actually says. Now I just put the DVD in and started typing what he was saying; sorry I can't find an official transcript of the interview or anything.
That is from the interviews on the special features disc of the 2002 edition of the film.

I was wrong about Lisberger actually using the word sexuality. It turns out that it was Bruce Boxleitner who uses that word when he is interviewed about the scene.

The producer uses the words "sexy" and "romantic" to describe the scene.

And I didn't even remember to mention Castor in my first post! He is about as suggestive as one could be in a Disney movie. Even fully-clothed and without using any kind of language at all he gives off an aggressive, over-sexualized vibe, very much like Alex deLarge from A Clockwork Orange. Even in the non-sexual parts of ACO Malcolm McDowell gives off...a vibe, I guess. One that Castor also radiates throughout his entire scene.


 
IsoLine
User

Posts: 1,025
RE: The "What are physical conditions like on the Grid?" thread

on Thursday, February, 03, 2011 12:18 AM
If it is any help the co-author of the original Story of TRON, Bonnie McBird wrote TRON as a computerized love story.order abortion pill http://unclejohnsprojects.com/template/default.aspx?morning-after-pill-price where to buy abortion pill

"Word to the Motherboard!" - IsoLine
 
Subject1138
User

Posts: 45
RE: The "What are physical conditions like on the Grid?" thread

on Thursday, February, 03, 2011 12:43 AM
IsoLine Wrote:If it is any help the co-author of the original Story of TRON, Bonnie McBird wrote TRON as a computerized love story.

I actually didn't know this, but based on the things I've read/heard Lisberger say I think that Tron would have pretty different if it hadn't of ended up a Disney movie.

Thanks for laying that factoid on us, Iso!


 
IsoLine
User

Posts: 1,025
RE: The "What are physical conditions like on the Grid?" thread

on Thursday, February, 03, 2011 1:07 AM
Subject1138 Wrote:
IsoLine Wrote:If it is any help the co-author of the original Story of TRON, Bonnie McBird wrote TRON as a computerized love story.

I actually didn't know this, but based on the things I've read/heard Lisberger say I think that Tron would have pretty different if it hadn't of ended up a Disney movie.

Thanks for laying that factoid on us, Iso!

Yeah, there used to be an interview with Bonnie McBird here on the site somewhere I believe...Her account of what TRON was "supposed" to be is entirely different. In some ways she even sounded a little bitter over what the story became.

"Word to the Motherboard!" - IsoLine
 
rimwall
User

Posts: 507
RE: The "What are physical conditions like on the Grid?" thread

on Thursday, February, 03, 2011 1:13 AM
better yet, treat the encom system as specific for the tron universe

the windows system is another universe. windows will never look like the tron universe.

this would still fit the multiverse concept.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiverse
excerpt
-------
Modal realism

Possible worlds are a way of explaining probability, hypothetical statements and the like, and some philosophers such as David Lewis believe that all possible worlds exist, and are just as real as the actual world (a position known as modal realism).[20]--------abortion pills online abortion pill online purchase cytotec abortion

I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.

 
rimwall
User

Posts: 507
RE: The "What are physical conditions like on the Grid?" thread

on Thursday, February, 03, 2011 2:36 AM
rimwall Wrote:--------Kat wrote
Well, if there are solids and liquids in the Grid, then it makes sense to me that there would also be gases. As far as the fire...it was implied in other threads that Flynn would've created several things in the safe house (such as the books, etc.) and that the food is an avatar for real food, though it's really just the same energy as the drinks. It makes sense to me that a user might create simulations of things from "back home." My OC in my fanfic does this extensively--Tron comments on the "hardwood floor" in her flat, she insists on simulating a lot of energy "food" (heh, imagine programs tasting hummus for the first time...), etc. In this case, the smoke from the "fire" may not be an actual function of the fire per se, but perhaps it was built it because that's the way one expects a fire to act, so to be authentic... (so then the other question is...is it real fire? Is something actually burning? Or is it just a visual effect?)
--------

i think youre right Kat. fire should exist in the tron universe.

let us try to approach from another direction.

if fire cannot exist in the grid then:

heat can't exist
heat transfer cant exist, evaporation cant exist, rain water wont be able to evaporate, clouds cant exist.
what about friction. rubbing two objects together is supposed to
produce heat. can friction exist without heat?

so postulating a universe where heat does not exist
is almost impossible. because in our universe
heat is one of the laws of nature.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heat
-----
In physics and thermodynamics, heat is energy transferred from one body or thermodynamic system to another
-----

to deny the existence of heat means
to deny the existence of energy.



let me put it another way
to accept the existence of energy (in tron universe) means
to accept the existence of all forms of energy and that includes heat and fire etc.
-- it also includes all the properties of energy heat transfer etc.
-- it also includes accepting the existence of matter because
matter is energy.

if we accept energy to exist in the tron universe we accept all the implications.order abortion pill abortion pill buy online where to buy abortion pill

I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.

 
Kat
User

Posts: 2,394
RE: The "What are physical conditions like on the Grid?" thread

on Thursday, February, 03, 2011 7:08 AM
DAMMIT JEFF BRIDGES! I just cannot read this:

rimwall Wrote:even if we view ram's source code - the act of inserting
his source code

after that whole post about sex, without my mind going bad bad places.

What do you want? I'm busy.


Program, please!


Chaos.... good news.
 
Subject1138
User

Posts: 45
RE: The "What are physical conditions like on the Grid?" thread

on Thursday, February, 03, 2011 9:53 AM
LWSrocks Wrote:If sexuality becomes important to the story of Tron 3, they will find a way to make it fit, but if that doesn't become an important plot point (which I doubt it will, because it's a Disney film, and Disney knows that kids are watching and interested) they will either leave the subject untouched and open for speculation, or there will be some detail in the story that makes us go, "Nah, see, remember this? No sex on the grid guys. Sorry."


It's definitely not going to factor into the third movie, especially since the original director isn't directing anymore. Nor should it, in my opinion. That isn't what the movies are about.
I got into it in such detail because I read a couple posts on the first page that were speculating about it.

I personally don't think that it needs to be explored any further and I'm pretty happy that Tron: Legacy didn't go there, which I know might sound surprising after my last posts. Ha.
But there were several Sam and Quorra scenes in T:L where I was thinking to myself, "Please don't kiss right now," because the movie just didn't need it.

So in my opinion, it's there, but completely unimportant to the overall plot.

But like most "nerd" hobbies, such as Star Trek and Star Wars ninty percent of conversations about it are going to be about really unimportant aspects of the lives of people who don't exist in real life. I swear that my fellow Star Wars nerds could probably have a two day long debate on what color socks Boba Fett prefers.where to buy abortion pill ordering abortion pills to be shipped to house buy abortion pill online


 
Tron Fanatic
User

Posts: 1,461
RE: The "What are physical conditions like on the Grid?" thread

on Thursday, February, 03, 2011 4:55 PM
Kat Wrote:Well, on the most basic level, an encyclopedia program is there for the users, of course. But I don't see why programs wouldn't utilize it as well--after all, it would be hard for a user NOT to mention the real world, or for a program who's interacted with a user not to wonder about it. If there was reference material available, they would no doubt use it. It's not essential to any action storyline, but it makes sense to think that programs might wonder. The encyclopedia or dictionary program itself would not need its own resources, but Tron and Daft Punk and Gem don't have that knowledge built in, so they are like the rest of us car owners who need to go to the mechanic or the car parts store. We may own a bookstore or a computer store or a grocery store, but while we're specialized in one area, we still don't have the car parts. And the car part store owner comes to us for a copy of Oliver Twist or a stick of RAM or a banana.

This is just how I'm thinking about it in terms of breaking something down to what it is on a computer. It seems strange because of the sheer amount of data involved. For example, if you break it down into the number of bytes contained in something, a simple email is actually more complex then a lightcycle from the original Tron arcade game. (and by a similar example, a dev once said that a single windows 3.1 icon contained more bytes of data than ALL of the code that ran the old vector Defender game).

Huge troves of data like a whole encyclopedia would take up a significant block of space on a harddrive, and in my mind, I see that as being in a huge warehouse somewhere, like a museum archive with shelves full of cataloged documents and artifacts. By the sheer amount of data contained, there's no way a Program could carry it around on his or her person, anymore than one of us can carry a house around. Tron 2.0 seemed to have it right. An archive bin containing old server emails was so huge that it required a floating platform to get to different parts of it (like one of those tall ladders in classic medieval libraries), and the corridor was so vast that it seemed to stretch into infinity.

But then, this argument doesn't REALLY hold up either, because the biggest discrepancy in all of this are the Users who visit the Grid. Even if we had the technology to 'save' a human in a binary format, our bodies are so infinitely complex, that there isn't a storage device that exists that could hold all the information. But then maybe that's just IF the human were moved to the Grid... according to Dumont, the molecules remain suspended in the laser beam. Technically I'd think that would mean that while the body is floating in individual molecules, the body is dead and the soul of the individual is having some kind of Out of Body Experience. it's easier to swallow than the idea of bringing a pig roast (or coding it manually, which Kevin could not possibly know how to do since he's a programmer not a bio-engineer) onto the grid to eat for dinner.

IsoLine Wrote:
Subject1138 Wrote:
IsoLine Wrote:If it is any help the co-author of the original Story of TRON, Bonnie McBird wrote TRON as a computerized love story.

I actually didn't know this, but based on the things I've read/heard Lisberger say I think that Tron would have pretty different if it hadn't of ended up a Disney movie.

Thanks for laying that factoid on us, Iso!

Yeah, there used to be an interview with Bonnie McBird here on the site somewhere I believe...Her account of what TRON was "supposed" to be is entirely different. In some ways she even sounded a little bitter over what the story became.

Though I wouldn't mind reading the original screenplay just to see if I'm off about this, something about Tron as a love story just sounds terrible, especially looking at the tidbits of that plot that still managed to find their way into one public format or another. In the trailer for TRON, it is said that on the grid, love is FORBIDDEN - a plot element that obviously never made the final cut. A similar hint of this appears in the deleted love scene when Yori tells tron how "illegal" what they're doing is. Something about a literal fight for the freedom to love on another just seems ridiculously contrived, like something thought up by a villain from Care Bears - though maybe, just maybe, it might make for a clever metaphor for the G/B community fighting for the legal right to marry, but such a political message would also feel forced in my opinion.

On the idea of the Programs being sexual beings though (and I'll ignore the fact that the idea of Programs having babies is one of the most ridiculous concepts imaginable - and maybe just assume that they can enjoy one another physically, but not reproduce),a very different perspective on the whole thing hit my like a ton of bricks as I was reading this thread today: Faeries. If someone were to show Tron to somebody who lived 100 years ago or more, they'd probably say that Flynn was a magician who messed with the wrong entity and got himself trapped in a Faerie Realm. The parallels to Faerie lore are actually quite obvious, but the sci-fi setting immediately pulls our minds away from such an idea. But really, think about it. Faeries traditionally are workers who manipulate the natural world. They're so tiny and fast that you'll never see one (though typically they're depicted as having glowing bodies or little balls of light), and they do their part to make flowers bloom, paint the sky blue, make the rain fall, or in this case, cause images to appear on the screen of a device that to all but tech and software engineers might as well be a magical device. Faeries, typically, were also depicted as being VERY sexual, enjoying it whenever possible. Whether or not Lisberger got any inspiration from this Lore is anyone's guess (most when analyzing the mythology of Tron, spend most of their time looking at the pseudo-Christian story of Romans debunking their religion by making them fight and die in gladiatorial games, and the "MCP is Satan who wants to overthrow God" parallel). It's an interesting angle to look at and I'm amazed I hadn't thought of it before now.where to buy abortion pill http://blog.bitimpulse.com/template/default.aspx?abortion-types buy abortion pill online

'>
 
Tron Fanatic
User

Posts: 1,461
RE: The "What are physical conditions like on the Grid?" thread

on Thursday, February, 03, 2011 5:42 PM
LWSrocks Wrote:Ok, well what about this- if Programs could have sex, what would it be in computer tech terms? I mean, when your thinking of programs as not only beings on the Grid but also as files you download in real life on your computer. Maybe a program needing information from another program to function? (I.E, using photos you edited in photoshop and putting them in a Publisher document. Would that be Photoshop making love to Publisher on the grid?)

I think most of us are thinking that "downtime" can be used for whatever a Program wants, such as chilling at a night club, or having disc battles, boinking, etc, and none of this leisure activity ever registers in any way on output devices, just like a boss never sees what his employees do when they leave work.where to buy abortion pill http://blog.bitimpulse.com/template/default.aspx?abortion-types buy abortion pill onlineabortion pills online abortion pill online purchase cytotec abortion

'>
 
Tron Fanatic
User

Posts: 1,461
RE: The "What are physical conditions like on the Grid?" thread

on Thursday, February, 03, 2011 6:09 PM
LWSrocks Wrote:So it's kind of like the Toy Story theory- when the user isn't sitting at his computer, the programs now have personalities and attributes and whatnot but when the user IS, they exist purely for carrying out their function. And the reason that there wasn't more of the "carrying out their function" in the movie is because there was not a User behind the computer .

Exactly. Though in that case it might even be MORE independent, because it seems that the T:L Grid was created almost solely to observe behavior.

'>
 
rimwall
User

Posts: 507
RE: The "What are physical conditions like on the Grid?" thread

on Thursday, February, 03, 2011 8:43 PM
Kat Wrote:DAMMIT JEFF BRIDGES! I just cannot read this:

rimwall Wrote:even if we view ram's source code - the act of inserting
his source code

after that whole post about sex, without my mind going bad bad places.


then i see ram turning to flynn in the games locker room
"dude! see this red pixel? know any good anti-virus cream."

darn it now im thinking it.
where to buy abortion pill http://blog.bitimpulse.com/template/default.aspx?abortion-types buy abortion pill online

I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.

 
rimwall
User

Posts: 507
RE: The "What are physical conditions like on the Grid?" thread

on Thursday, February, 03, 2011 9:32 PM
about disks

rebels don't know clu can read disks.

the interesting thing - when clu was reading sams
disks it appears to contain only his most recent
memories going back to insertion of the disk
on his back (weird and worth exploring for implications)

i don't know if clu and flynn are the only ones
who can read other disks.

worth noting too that MCP in tron1 and novelization
showed no ability to read disks.




I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.

 
rimwall
User

Posts: 507
RE: The "What are physical conditions like on the Grid?" thread

on Friday, February, 04, 2011 6:05 AM
LWSrocks Wrote:
rimwall Wrote:about disks

rebels don't know clu can read disks.

the interesting thing - when clu was reading sams
disks it appears to contain only his most recent
memories going back to insertion of the disk
on his back (weird and worth exploring for implications)

i don't know if clu and flynn are the only ones
who can read other disks.

worth noting too that MCP in tron1 and novelization
showed no ability to read disks.



1. Don't know what made you think this post belonged here.
2. I think everybody can read disks, not just Clu and Flynn.
3. MCP wouldn't have to read disks. I mean, in the original film's story, disks weren't very important. They were just a weapon and they had all of your memory saved to them. In Legacy, disks were very important. They were weapons and used extensively (only used in battle ONCE in Tron) and also, Kevin's disk was huge to the story of Legacy.
4. Rebels don't know Clu can read disks?

1. clu and flynn's ability to read disks seems to be part of
physicality of programs. i remember some posts back about
book reading. tho if Kat objects i'm amenable to transferring
this to "nailing down rules" thread

2. for the purposes of being exact i can only say clu and flynn.
flynn being the creator and clu is not exactly a typical program.
if clu was a normal program then i can provisionally say that
every program can read disks. but that's not the case.

3. the MCP comment was for the benefit of those not familiar
with tron 1. so that they could note that disk reading of somebody
else's disk is unique tron : legacy

4. the rebel bartik in castor's bar. and obviously clu's disk reading
ability is not known by the rebels. so i expect tron:uprising to
reflect the rebels being unaware of clu's disk reading.

I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.

 
Kat
User

Posts: 2,394
RE: The "What are physical conditions like on the Grid?" thread

on Friday, February, 04, 2011 7:09 AM
rimwall Wrote:
Kat Wrote:DAMMIT JEFF BRIDGES! I just cannot read this:

rimwall Wrote:even if we view ram's source code - the act of inserting
his source code

after that whole post about sex, without my mind going bad bad places.


then i see ram turning to flynn in the games locker room
"dude! see this red pixel? know any good anti-virus cream."

darn it now im thinking it.
"Now Ram, you know we've had this discussion before about just picking up any program you find on the internet. And why weren't you using an anti-virus to protect yourself in the first place, young man?" (Wow, malware and Norton/McAfee exist on the Grid too! )


LWSrocks Wrote:1. Don't know what made you think this post belonged here.
?
I think it was meant for that other thread about discs.

What do you want? I'm busy.


Program, please!


Chaos.... good news.
 
rimwall
User

Posts: 507
RE: The "What are physical conditions like on the Grid?" thread

on Friday, February, 04, 2011 8:47 AM
Kat Wrote:
"Now Ram, you know we've had this discussion before about just picking up any program you find on the internet. And why weren't you using an anti-virus to protect yourself in the first place, young man?" (Wow, malware and Norton/McAfee exist on the Grid too! )



I think it was meant for that other thread about discs.

will move it to the rules thread

I.T. support: yes sir - you click start to turn off your p.c.

 
Tron Fanatic
User

Posts: 1,461
RE: The "What are physical conditions like on the Grid?" thread

on Friday, February, 04, 2011 10:49 AM
rimwall Wrote:worth noting too that MCP in tron1 and novelization
showed no ability to read disks.

The MCP just absorbed Programs and added them to his own code. I would think that includes any info contained on a disc.
abortion pills online abortion pill online purchase cytotec abortion

'>
 
Subject1138
User

Posts: 45
RE: The "What are physical conditions like on the Grid?" thread

on Friday, February, 04, 2011 11:48 AM
I'll try to make quick bulletpoints in response to everything I remember reading, to force my own two cents back into this convo. Ha.

1) I also think that anyone can access anyone's disc.
2) Clu doesn't really try to keep it a secret that he can read discs.
3) Sam's "disc memmory" did not go back only as far as when he received the disc. If that were true the only thing Clu would have seen would have been Gem and the sirens and the armory, but he clearly saw Alan holding up his pager and that memory was all the way back from the Real World. Obviously the discs are able to copy recent memory that is inside the program/digitized user itself. Or it was a movie mistake
4) The programs are unable to reproduce sexually. I don't think this is ever said in the movies, but it seems pretty obvious.
5) The programs have downtime which they seem to be able to spend however they like. This is especially obvious in T:L where the Grid is modeled much more after "real life". I mean, Castor runs a night club where you can plainly see blackguards sitting around, drinking and making out with random programs. Ha. If that isn't downtime I don't know what is!

And finally it's one of those things where you kind of have to come up with a set of things you think are "true" about the Grid and the programs and then not over-think it. Especially you guys on here who are really sciency and keep posting with all kinds of technical jargon, trying to get the movies to fit within real life scientific parameters; it isn't going to happen. The movies are amazing and fun and they make sense to me and I'm able to fill in all the plot-holes to my own satisfaction, but from a logical, real-life science standpoint they're fairly ubsurd.


 
FirstPrevious Page: of 3 PagesNextLast
New New Comments | Post No Change | Locked Closed
Forums 
 TRON: LEGACY 
 The "What are physical conditions like on the Grid?" thread