ChessMess User
Posts: 443 | Sam's Helmet Vistor - Looks Bad & is Useless on Saturday, September, 04, 2010 10:33 PM
We keep seeing scenes where it appears Sam pulls the disc from his back or something happens and a helmet appears over his head with a clear glass front.
Why?
First the glass front looks bad, just look at the picture on the front page in the news (at this moment). I guess it doesn't cover the mouth so that it doesn't present an issue with hearing spoken dialog.
But it servers no real purpose, you get hit with a disc and its over, no matter where it hits you. Its just dumb. The full helmets for the villians looks good, but Sams just looks silly.
|
Anon User
Posts: 0 | Re: Sam's Helmet Vistor - Looks Bad & is Useless on Saturday, September, 04, 2010 11:17 PM
I think it looks awesome personally.
Anyway, the visor isn't useless as it obviously protects his face. Yes, I realize it won't stop him from being derezzed if hit by the disc, but it still protects him from other kinds of damage and is as useful as the rest of the armour he wears which covers his whole body.
|
isMetaClass User
Posts: 529 | Re: Sam's Helmet Vistor - Looks Bad & is Useless on Saturday, September, 04, 2010 11:47 PM
there seems to be "damage" and maybe even "injury" in this digital world so protective gear isn't useless.
but yeah, if you're hit dead-on with a disc it's blocko time!
i think it looks cool and i'm waiting for this:
order abortion pill abortion pill buy online where to buy abortion pill
Legion Of The Disney-raised, proud member |
CaptainCR User
Posts: 1,468 | Re: Sam's Helmet Vistor - Looks Bad & is Useless on Saturday, September, 04, 2010 11:53 PM
only problem i have with the visor is that it looks like it can't be removed on the action figureorder abortion pill http://unclejohnsprojects.com/template/default.aspx?morning-after-pill-price where to buy abortion pill
"You know you don't look a thing like your pictures?" |
BlueTronWarrior Sector Admin
Posts: 609 | Re: Sam's Helmet Vistor - Looks Bad & is Useless on Sunday, September, 05, 2010 12:01 AM
CaptainCR Wrotenly problem i have with the visor is that it looks like it can't be removed on the action figure |
It can't, it's glued on.where to buy abortion pill http://blog.bitimpulse.com/template/default.aspx?abortion-types buy abortion pill onlineabortion pills online http://www.kvicksundscupen.se/template/default.aspx?abortion-questions cytotec abortion
|
KiaPurity User
Posts: 3,488 | Re: Sam's Helmet Vistor - Looks Bad & is Useless on Sunday, September, 05, 2010 12:20 AM
I'm still iffy on the visor--
Or maybe I just like the retro '82 hockey helmet better ;_;where to buy abortion pill http://blog.bitimpulse.com/template/default.aspx?abortion-types buy abortion pill online
Kia: Cool. I'm a infamous mythological perfect User.
|
ShadowDragon1 User
Posts: 2,056 | Re: Sam's Helmet Vistor - Looks Bad & is Useless on Sunday, September, 05, 2010 12:45 AM
Sam's helmet is pretty cool IMO, it reminds me of Joe the Condor's helmet from " Gatchaman ".
I see no reason why such a minor thing like a character's helmet has to be complained about.
It's easier to enjoy a movie if one doesn't over-analyse and nitpick on every minor little thing. Just saying. "The film is about finding human connection in an increasingly digital world." - Joseph Kosinski
|
KiaPurity User
Posts: 3,488 | Re: Sam's Helmet Vistor - Looks Bad & is Useless on Sunday, September, 05, 2010 12:48 AM
I blame Amano for that.
Kia: Cool. I'm a infamous mythological perfect User.
|
ShadowDragon1 User
Posts: 2,056 | Re: Sam's Helmet Vistor - Looks Bad & is Useless on Sunday, September, 05, 2010 12:51 AM
Hey, Yoshitaka Amano is an awesome artist. Please don't diss the Amano. order abortion pill abortion pill buy online where to buy abortion pill "The film is about finding human connection in an increasingly digital world." - Joseph Kosinski
|
KiaPurity User
Posts: 3,488 | Re: Sam's Helmet Vistor - Looks Bad & is Useless on Sunday, September, 05, 2010 10:20 AM
I know.
I especially love his watercolors for the Final Fantasy logos -- especially astonishing that he did few artwork for FF7, FF8, and FF10 (despite Nomura being the major character designer on those)
And I've been playing Dissidia which hasn't been helping things what with the character designs being a mix of Nomura and Amano.
...
We got off track, oops? where to buy abortion pill ordering abortion pills to be shipped to house buy abortion pill online Kia: Cool. I'm a infamous mythological perfect User.
|
Theflynnabides User
Posts: 215 | Re: Sam's Helmet Vistor - Looks Bad & is Useless on Sunday, September, 05, 2010 7:51 PM
bigbangbilly.exe Wrote:Well the visor looks like it can protect your eyes from dust
Besides Rinzler's helmet appear to have the same degree of uselessness as Sam's visor |
This
It's like complaining about the use of helmets in the original TRON. And if you're in a lightcycle, sure, you have a helmet, but the moment you slam into a wall, you're finished.
It's there purely for aesthetic appeal, and nothing more. ____________________________________
"Tron is for NERDS!"
Yea, well, that's just like, your opinion, man...
|
Pilgrim1099 User
Posts: 606 | Re: Sam's Helmet Vistor - Looks Bad & is Useless on Sunday, September, 05, 2010 7:54 PM
KiaPurity Wrote:I know.
I especially love his watercolors for the Final Fantasy logos -- especially astonishing that he did few artwork for FF7, FF8, and FF10 (despite Nomura being the major character designer on those)
And I've been playing Dissidia which hasn't been helping things what with the character designs being a mix of Nomura and Amano.
...
We got off track, oops? |
Off track? Nahh. Amano IS God . One of my favorite illustrators, next to Sid Mead and Moebius, of course. |
xalener User
Posts: 238 | Re: Sam's Helmet Vistor - Looks Bad & is Useless on Sunday, September, 05, 2010 8:56 PM
ChessMess Wrote:We keep seeing scenes where it appears Sam pulls the disc from his back or something happens and a helmet appears over his head with a clear glass front.
Why?
First the glass front looks bad, just look at the picture on the front page in the news (at this moment). I guess it doesn't cover the mouth so that it doesn't present an issue with hearing spoken dialog.
But it servers no real purpose, you get hit with a disc and its over, no matter where it hits you. Its just dumb. The full helmets for the villians looks good, but Sams just looks silly. |
Debris & sparks
/thread
Alan: I was paged last night. Came from your dad's arcade
sam: So?
Alan: the number's been disconnected for 20 years!
Sam: THEN WHO WAS PAGER |
lurkinghorror User
Posts: 803 | Re: Sam's Helmet Vistor - Looks Bad & is Useless on Sunday, September, 05, 2010 9:13 PM
Trying to figure out the practical applications for something 100% fictional is an exercise in futility. It was designed by people who never ever will use them for their intended purpose, as the intended purpose does not exist outside the imagination. It's a stylistic choice. That's all.
That said, I do not like the execution of the helmets (or hair on the people of the digital world). What I was drawn to aesthetically from the the original film seems largely absent in this incarnation, and I think losing the identifiable aesthetic of something that has become so iconic is as wrong headed as completely redesigning Superman.
|
WorldOutWest Sector Admin
Posts: 432 | Re: Sam's Helmet Vistor - Looks Bad & is Useless on Sunday, September, 05, 2010 9:15 PM
Cool to hear everyone's vantage points here, always creates great discussions... my standpoint: I'm diggin' the look of the visor and how it activates.
How much does it actually protect and how useful is it actually? Well, if perhaps comparing it as to why some basketball players wear goggles to protect their eyes while duking it out in thick of the game... it makes sense on that level, as well as bike riders wearing them to protect their eyes from the rush of air and wind -- that then warriors would wear them in riding the light cycles that they sit astride on in TRON: LEGACY.
But I agree with some of the other comments too that there's no need to over analyze things... especially in a fictional, sci-fi setting... if you did that, most (if not all) sci-fi/fantasy films would crumble when applying "real world logic" -- that's why they're called sci-fi and fantasies... the suspension of disbelief in viewing this type of genre film is the vantage point that you're supposed to utilize... and if you really dug into the likes of the STAR WARS movies, STAR TREK, etc... you'd see when applying practical science, technology, etc. -- it all doesn't add up. These movies, including the TRON movies, are not documentaries, they are entertainment, and first, foremost, and always should be approached as such. There's an idealism that each has that could possibly be realized in some technical ways in the distant future and some have elements that are rooted in the practical science and technology of today, but again as is, these films largely remain fantasies.
- Jay
Castor from TRON: LEGACY - "Change the scheme..! Alter the mood...! Electrify the boys and girls if you'd be so kind.." |
xalener User
Posts: 238 | Re: Sam's Helmet Vistor - Looks Bad & is Useless on Sunday, September, 05, 2010 9:53 PM
lurkinghorror Wrote:Trying to figure out the practical applications for something 100% fictional is an exercise in futility. It was designed by people who never ever will use them for their intended purpose, as the intended purpose does not exist outside the imagination. It's a stylistic choice. That's all.
That said, I do not like the execution of the helmets (or hair on the people of the digital world). What I was drawn to aesthetically from the the original film seems largely absent in this incarnation, and I think losing the identifiable aesthetic of something that has become so iconic is as wrong headed as completely redesigning Superman.
|
I agree to an extent, but the hair in tron 1 wasn't all that crazy? That one woman (prostitute?) in the town area had regular hair, and everyone had eyebrows...so... :/
I understand about other things though, they changed a lot. But most of it was for simple practicality reasons, like the fluctuating scale of the Recognizer in the first Tron had to be rectified (just really one example of probably many if I cared enough to think of em). Everything else is as you said a style choice. Alan: I was paged last night. Came from your dad's arcade
sam: So?
Alan: the number's been disconnected for 20 years!
Sam: THEN WHO WAS PAGER |
WorldOutWest Sector Admin
Posts: 432 | Re: Sam's Helmet Vistor - Looks Bad & is Useless on Sunday, September, 05, 2010 10:15 PM
xalener Wrote:lurkinghorror Wrote:
That said, I do not like the execution of the helmets (or hair on the people of the digital world). What I was drawn to aesthetically from the the original film seems largely absent in this incarnation, and I think losing the identifiable aesthetic of something that has become so iconic is as wrong headed as completely redesigning Superman.
|
I agree to an extent, but the hair in tron 1 wasn't all that crazy? That one woman (prostitute?) in the town area had regular hair, and everyone had eyebrows...so... :/
|
Regarding hair in the digital world -- in the original film, as xalener mentioned, programs still had eyebrows and the woman "solicitor" had a head full of hair -- as well, Dumont and many of the "older programs" had beards or goatees -- and Cindy Morgan/Yori didn't have a helmet on at one point in the "love scene" that was cut from the film: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nED_W7NA2Vs
- Jay
order abortion pill http://unclejohnsprojects.com/template/default.aspx?morning-after-pill-price where to buy abortion pill Castor from TRON: LEGACY - "Change the scheme..! Alter the mood...! Electrify the boys and girls if you'd be so kind.." |
Anon User
Posts: 0 | Re: Sam's Helmet Vistor - Looks Bad & is Useless on Sunday, September, 05, 2010 10:25 PM
lurkinghorror Wrote:Trying to figure out the practical applications for something 100% fictional is an exercise in futility. It was designed by people who never ever will use them for their intended purpose, as the intended purpose does not exist outside the imagination. It's a stylistic choice. That's all.
That said, I do not like the execution of the helmets (or hair on the people of the digital world). What I was drawn to aesthetically from the the original film seems largely absent in this incarnation, and I think losing the identifiable aesthetic of something that has become so iconic is as wrong headed as completely redesigning Superman.
|
Except that the world of TRON is not a static and unchanging thing. So it does stand to reason that as it evolves so to may the aesthetic, but I think they have kept true to the original in a lot of ways (the neon circuitry, light cycles minus the canopy, the design of the recognizers). What I have seen has not led me to think or feel that it is complete departure from the first. abortion pills online http://www.kvicksundscupen.se/template/default.aspx?abortion-questions cytotec abortion |
lurkinghorror User
Posts: 803 | Re: Sam's Helmet Vistor - Looks Bad & is Useless on Sunday, September, 05, 2010 10:59 PM
It can be argued and justified a thousand ways if that's what a person wants to do. And for each argument there is a counter argument. A beard on Dumont? I seem to recall hearing that the actor refused to shave. Hair during a cut scene? It was cut. Eyebrows? I never said they should be devoid of human features, I'm talking about a full head of hair. A one off character you barely see? Easily dismissed as outside the norm, as it clearly was.
The problem with all of these arguments is that they address the universe of Tron as if it as some internal logic that guarantees consistency. It's fiction and subject to revision and reinterpretation. The upcoming film is an example of that. They made changes. If you want to look for why these changes make sense and are consistent, you will find them. But the changes are made on a design and marketing level. Not because the world of Tron evolved or because it makes some type of sense.
I don't like hair on people of the digital world. For me, it makes the world feel less..."Tron". The lighting and effects and design of the original all conspired to take me, as a viewer, out of reality in a new and unique manner. The images from the new film don't convey this as effectively to me, and make me feel as if I'm seeing something else entirely. Doesn't mean it will be bad, just means it might not fit my preference.
|
WorldOutWest Sector Admin
Posts: 432 | Re: Sam's Helmet Vistor - Looks Bad & is Useless on Sunday, September, 05, 2010 11:23 PM
lurkinghorror Wrote:It can be argued and justified a thousand ways if that's what a person wants to do. And for each argument there is a counter argument. A beard on Dumont? I seem to recall hearing that the actor refused to shave. Hair during a cut scene? It was cut. Eyebrows? I never said they should be devoid of human features, I'm talking about a full head of hair. A one off character you barely see? Easily dismissed as outside the norm, as it clearly was.
The problem with all of these arguments is that they address the universe of Tron as if it as some internal logic that guarantees consistency. It's fiction and subject to revision and reinterpretation. The upcoming film is an example of that. They made changes. If you want to look for why these changes make sense and are consistent, you will find them. But the changes are made on a design and marketing level. Not because the world of Tron evolved or because it makes some type of sense.
I don't like hair on people of the digital world. For me, it makes the world feel less..."Tron". The lighting and effects and design of the original all conspired to take me, as a viewer, out of reality in a new and unique manner. The images from the new film don't convey this as effectively to me, and make me feel as if I'm seeing something else entirely. Doesn't mean it will be bad, just means it might not fit my preference. |
It all really just boils down to perspective and preference. I saw the original TRON when it was first released in theatres -- and it immediately resonated with me, and has remained one of my favorite films ever since then. The linear, real time approach that the sequel is taking -- that approximately 28 years have elapsed since the events of the first film -- is an excellent and smart approach. With that, technology has evolved, style and designs have also evolved, so it's only natural to see and expect either variations or changes in the look and design of the digital world, as well as its inhabitants. It all feels very much like a natural progression in the digital world of TRON to me -- without being redundant or constricted, rather, it's innovative and progressive.
- Jay
Castor from TRON: LEGACY - "Change the scheme..! Alter the mood...! Electrify the boys and girls if you'd be so kind.." |
|