Forums (I/O Tower)
Forums 
 TRON: LEGACY 
 Real world physics vs Grid physics


New New Comments | Post No Change | Locked Closed
AuthorComments: FirstPrevious Page: of 2 Pages
Tron Fanatic
User

Posts: 1,461
RE: Real world physics vs Grid physics

on Thursday, April, 28, 2011 12:56 AM
DarthMeow504 Wrote:
"You've still have not answered any of the questions I put forth or given any rational
in-canon examples on how Clu would magically make all his vehicles and soldiers materialize or even work in the "real world". "

Have you even read anything I've written? I said how it would work. Repeatedly. You seem to have ignored it.

Where does the energy and matter come from? Simple. Perhaps you've heard of a little equation called e=mc2?

It means that you don't need the city's power grid nor do you need containers of specially designated matter for the Shiva laser. Once you can convert matter to energy and back again, as the Shiva laser has been demonstrated on screen to do, any and all matter is both your fuel and your raw material.

Doesn't that imply the 'perfect machine?' As in, no energy loss?


'>
 
DarthMeow504
User

Posts: 134
RE: Real world physics vs Grid physics

on Thursday, April, 28, 2011 3:32 AM
Tron Fanatic Wrote:Doesn't that imply the 'perfect machine?' As in, no energy loss?

No it just means that as long as you feed it matter to convert into energy, it can keep going. Presumably some of it would be used up / lost in the process, thus keeping it within the laws of thermodynamics.

Think of it this way. One kilogram of matter, if converted completely to energy, would release the equivalent energy of a mulit-kiloton atomic explosion. Einstein taught us that. That should be more than enough to fuel the Shiva laser, even if it's efficiency is atrocious --it's a LOT of energy.

So, say, you want to rez up a nice old-school Tron tank. Let's say that puppy weighs in at just shy of 70 tons. So, to do it, you need to first dematerialize somewhere over that weight, to provide both the raw materials for the finished tank and the energy to power the process. The formula would be:

69 tons (the tank) + x (the amount of matter needed to convert to the energy needed to do the whole job) = the amount of matter you'd need to feed the Shiva.

The bad part is that extra matter is for practical intents gone, you're not getting it back. The good part is it can be anything, rock, soil, even garbage. The mass is what matters, not it's composition.

The Shiva is appropriately named, as it is truly a god machine. It takes in waste, and outputs goods and energy. It would make all other forms of energy generation and manufacturing instantly obsolete, and would also completely revolutionize construction.

Of course, by using raw matter as it's fuel, the energy that is lost in the process through basic thermodynamic ineficciencies means you actually lose matter, but it doesn't seem from the films that it actually uses that much so it should be quite a while before we feel any pinch on raw matter supplies.

Like I have said repeatedly, give me a Shiva laser and I'll take over the world.


 
laphtiya
User

Posts: 948
RE: Real world physics vs Grid physics

on Thursday, April, 28, 2011 4:31 AM
I love how everyone ignores the "He's found a way to do it" line. This implies that Flynn only thought it was posible for CLU to leave the grid, however CLU with access to the disk and all the information sotred on it, remember that "Everything you do or learn will be imprinted on this disk". Over 20 years real world time of experiance and however much grid time CLU was able to go through and find out what he needed to be able to take it ALL with him. You're all saying "there isn't enough power" seems to have been enough power to keep a computer running 24/7 for 20 years. Now Flynn said that due to the power consumption the portal can only stay open for 8 hours, was he talking about power from "the grid" or power from the mains supply?? We simply do not know, it doesn't matter what you or I think, for the purpose of the story IT WILL WORK simple as that. CLU had found a way to do it, we do not know how we just know that he HAS found a way. CLU isn't a moron, he would not have tried to take all that with him if he knew it wouldn't work or even suspected it. He wanted out he wouldn't have risked his getting out for some other program.

As for things working in the real world.........well I seriously do not know, I think that was left open. We know they had jets on the recognisers, we do not know how well programed they were how realistic they were so we cannot say either way.

But at the end of the line guys and gals, this is a movie and if in the movie they say it will work it will work and other opinions don't really matter because if you didn't write the movie or directed the movie then you're wrong. Don't wanna step on any toes or offend anyone but think we can get past the "It wouldnt have worked" and talk about something else to do with TL?.....please?


 
Jackie Lawless
User

Posts: 52
RE: Real world physics vs Grid physics

on Thursday, April, 28, 2011 4:52 AM
DarthMeow504 Wrote:
ShadowDragon1 Wrote:I very highly doubt it.

Doubt all you want, the film itself disagrees with you.

Flynn said directly that if Clu accessed the portal with his master key disc, it was "Game Over". This is in-canon fact, that the character most knowledgeable about the subject believes without question that Clu's plan is not only workable, but unstoppable.

I've explained how it could work using what we know about the Shiva laser and the Grid. I may be off on some point or another, but the conclusion is undeniable. I've worked backwards from the canon facts the film gave us to puzzle out a theory on how it could work, because the film says it does work.

The film says that Clu's plan IS viable. Period. You can disagree with me on the particulars of how it would work, but if you claim that it would fail you are WRONG. The viability of Clu's threat is canon fact and undeniable.

I don't get the flood of posters saying "I don't think it works like that", as if they're describing a real thing that can be objectively investigated. It's fiction, what the author says goes. And the author has said, in the most definitive way possible short of voice-over Word of God narration, that in his story the threat of Clu is real.

What about that is so difficult to understand?

i agree with you 100% Fllynn DIRECTLY says "with my disc, it's possible." He wouldnt say that unless he knew for a fact it would happen, let alone spend 25 or so years safegaurding it, and Quorra...order abortion pill abortion pill buy online where to buy abortion pill

He Sill fights for the users...
 
ShadowDragon1
User

Posts: 2,056
RE: Real world physics vs Grid physics

on Friday, April, 29, 2011 6:27 AM
At that point he was refering to Clu entering the "real world". He would be a threat as Clu could pose as Flynn, and use Encom to further his plans for establishing facsict like order and "perfection" upon the "real world" by any means available to Clu using Encom's tech and resources.

Later, when on the Command Ship, Sam and Kevin are only **assuming* Clu's army and ships could make it "out" somehow. I have given specific, logical reasons why that wouldn't really be possible.

Dismiss the reasons why it wouldn't work all you want, doesn't mean that magically all those *digital simulations* are going to emerge/materialize from some laser wormhole into the "real world" ala the campy "Masters of the Universe" the movie from the 80's.

IMO and many other Tron fans I know, the very notion is very. very campy and sounds straight out of Bugs Bunny cartoon. order abortion pill morning after pill price where to buy abortion pill

"The film is about finding human connection in an increasingly digital world." - Joseph Kosinski

 
Ben_otter
User

Posts: 22
RE: Real world physics vs Grid physics

on Friday, April, 29, 2011 11:51 AM
I think that the real threat was Disney didn't think that through. Lol.order abortion pill morning after pill price where to buy abortion pill


 
FirstPrevious Page: of 2 Pages
New New Comments | Post No Change | Locked Closed
Forums 
 TRON: LEGACY 
 Real world physics vs Grid physics